Soh Wei Yu
Admin
Book recommendation for post anatta:
"john tan commented after reading [redditor who recently realised anatta, Mr. JKB] msgs:
[24/12/21, 1:44:08 AM] John Tan: Next he must understand freedom from all elaborations.
[24/12/21, 9:24:04 AM] Soh Wei Yu: Oic.. any books u think he should start on?
[24/12/21,
9:26:30 AM] John Tan: Not easy, it will be too difficult for him to
read mmk. The reason is mmk is not strictly written for the modern ppl
but to refute the other buddhist schools and philosophers.
[24/12/21,
9:47:10 AM] Soh Wei Yu: Oic but what to start on? I think greg goode
recommended dalai lama how to see yourself as you really are as starter
[24/12/21, 9:55:28 AM] Soh Wei Yu: image omitted
[24/12/21, 9:55:29 AM] Soh Wei Yu: image omitted
[24/12/21, 9:55:29 AM] Soh Wei Yu: image omitted
[24/12/21, 9:55:30 AM] Soh Wei Yu: image omitted
[24/12/21, 10:36:40 AM] Soh Wei Yu: Maybe i shld introduce mipham books to him too? Beacon of certainty?
[24/12/21,
10:44:11 AM] John Tan: Yes but will still need to sort out a lot for
him. Anatta is just the beginning so it is not easy to understand at a
single go. If we do not read the teachings of great masters like
Mipham and Tsongkhapa's with a reverent mind, we will be frequently
doing "spiritual bypassing" in our reading colored by insights of
anatta.
[24/12/21, 10:44:44 AM] Soh Wei Yu: Oic..
[24/12/21, 10:44:58 AM] Soh Wei Yu: For tsongkhapa which books you recommend?
[24/12/21,
10:51:18 AM] John Tan: It is even more difficult to understand
Tsongkhapa if ur anatta isn't matured enough to penetrate deeply into
the conventional and that includes understanding the energy system of ur
body in his tantra teachings. It is more advisable and much more
intuitive to progress one's insight from anatta to freedom from all
elaborations into spontaneous presence.
[24/12/21, 10:53:26 AM] Soh Wei Yu: Oic..
[24/12/21, 11:08:29 AM] John Tan: This message was deleted.
[24/12/21,
11:14:35 AM] John Tan: There r books all around about gelug's teaching
of emptiness as mmk is dominated by gelug's interpretation. It is how u
"feel" the heart of his teachings. The only problem I feel is his
rejection of "freedom from all elaborations" which imo is a "pivotal
insight" as he felt it is dangerous illustrate the view, path, result
the way those sudden schools of enlightenment present it as evidenced
by those non-dual junkies in FB 
. This is not to say he knows nothing abt it
.
He is just too compassionate and put great effort in making his
teachings systematic, logical and step by step without compromising
"selflessness", it is a transformative and developmental approach
towards liberation.



There
r many good books that tell u clearly how appearances should be
understood and how non-dual experiences are like for Tsongkhapa. "The
two truths debate" (Soh: can refer to this article for a short excerpt: http://www.awakeningtoreality.com/.../tsongkhapas...
) will be a good read if u want to understand the non-dual experiences
of the gelug. "Self, reality and reason in Tibetan philosophy" is also
good. But I think they did not present the freedom of all elaborations
correctly or, lots of bias 

same applies to other books. That is y if u do not read with a reverent heart, u will not gain anything and simply "bypass".



[24/12/21, 6:02:47 PM] Soh Wei Yu: Oic..
xabir Snoovatar
"
Also for a general overview of Mipham's teachings, can read https://www.amazon.com/Jamgon-Mipam-His.../dp/1590306694 which is also good

AWAKENINGTOREALITY.COM
Tsongkhapa's Epistemic Nonduality
- Reply
- Remove Preview
- 2m
- Edited