- Reply
- Remove Preview
- 1d
- Reply
- Remove Preview
- 1d
- Edited
e
n
o
d
p
r
t
S
o
s
9
u
0
c
u
c
t
1
5
a
0
1
f
:
2
0
8
a
0
1
9
7
t
1
5
1
t
s
7
0
a
2
8
P
h
7
0
g
A
u
M
4
9
2
f
2
Shared with Your friends
BUDDHA-MIND DOES NOT EXIST ~ SHENG YEN
To come to retreat expecting to get enlightened, to experience buddha-mind, is self-deception. Indeed, since there is no such thing as mind, there is also no such thing as buddha-mind.
The self-nature realized after eliminating illusion is also illusory, so it is a mistake to practice with the idea of replacing illusory mind with buddha-mind.
Does this mean you will spend the rest of your life replacing one illusion with another? The Heart Sutra says:
Form is not other than emptiness,
And emptiness is not other than form.
Form is precisely emptiness,
And emptiness is precisely form.
When form disappears, there is no emptiness to speak of. When the illusory mind disappears, true nature disappears as well. When the illusory mind does not move, true mind is not there.
Aspiring to enlightenment makes us diligent, but we should not have that idea in mind when we practice. Even if we become enlightened, we should not think that we have attained anything.
Before practice, people are not aware of their illusory mind; they think that everything they experience is real. After they begin to practice they learn that the mind is illusory. When they finally experience enlightenment, they may think they have replaced illusory mind with true mind.
The "Song of Mind" negates this idea: if the nature of mind is non-arising, then neither illusory mind nor
true mind exists.
2 Comments
Soh Wei Yu
Excerpt from Yogini Abhaya Devi in http://www.awakeningtoreality.com/2018/04/way-of-bodhi.html
“Thus
Bodhidharma’s style was to turn the attention of the disciple inward to
the mind, and into its empty nature. The Master leads the disciple into
realizing that one’s mind by its very nature is
equal to that of a fully awakened Buddha. Yet, when one recognizes the
nature of one’s own mind, nothing is found there to cling to as ‘this is
mind’. Discovering one’s own Buddhahood in the empty-mind is the
essence and the way of Mahayana Buddhism.
Bodhidharma said,
You
should realize that the cultivation of the Way does not exist apart
from your mind. If your mind is pure, everything is pure as
buddha-fields. As sutras states, “If the minds of beings are impure,
beings are impure. If the minds of beings are pure, beings are pure,”
and “To reach a buddha-field, purify your mind. As your mind becomes
pure, everything becomes pure as buddha-fields.” (from the Breakthrough
Discourse)
Dissolving the Mind
Dissolving the mind
Though
purifying mind is the essence of practicing the Way, it is not done by
clinging at the mind as a glorified and absolute entity. It is not that
one simply goes inward by rejecting the external world. It is not that
the mind is pure and the world is impure. When mind is clear, the world
is a pure-field. When mind is deluded, the world is Samsara. Bodhidharma
said,
Seeing with
insight, form is not simply form, because form depends on mind. And,
mind is not simply mind, because mind depends on form. Mind and form
create and negate each other. … Mind and the world are opposites,
appearances arise where they meet. When your mind does not stir inside,
the world does not arise outside. When the world and the mind are both
transparent, this is the true insight.” (from the Wakeup Discourse)
Just
like the masters of Madhyamaka, Bodhidharma too pointed out that mind
and form are interdependently arising. Mind and form create each other.
Yet, when you cling to form, you negate mind. And, when you cling to
mind, you negate form. Only when such dualistic notions are dissolved,
and only when both mind and the world are transparent (not turning to
obstructing concepts) the true insight arises.
In this regard, Bodhidharma said,
Using the mind to look for reality is delusion.
Not using the mind to look for reality is awareness.
(from the Wakeup Discourse)
So,
to effectively enter the Way, one has to go beyond the dualities
(conceptual constructs) of mind and form. As far as one looks for
reality as an object of mind, one is still trapped in the net of
delusion (of seeing mind and form as independent realities), never
breaking free from it. In that way, one holds reality as something other
than oneself, and even worse, one holds oneself as a spectator to a
separate reality!
When
the mind does not stir anymore and settles into its pristine clarity,
the world does not stir outside. The reality is revealed beyond the
divisions of Self and others, and mind and form. Thus, as you learn not
to use the mind to look for reality and simply rests in the natural
state of mind as it is, there is the dawn of pristine awareness –
knowing reality as it is, non-dually and non-conceptually.
When
the mind does not dissolve in this way to its original clarity,
whatever one sees is merely the stirring of conceptuality. Even if we
try to construct a Buddha’s mind, it only stirs and does not see
reality. Because, the Buddha’s mind is simply the uncompounded clarity
of Bodhi (awakening), free from stirring and constructions. So,
Bodhidharma said,
That
which ordinary knowledge understands is also said to be within the
boundaries of the norms. When you do not produce the mind of a common
man, or the mind of a sravaka or a bodhisattva, and when you do not even
produce a Buddha-mind or any mind at all, then for the first time you
can be said to have gone outside the boundaries of the norms. If no mind
at all arises, and if you do not produce understanding nor give rise to
delusion, then, for the first time, you can be said to have gone
outside of everything. (From the Record #1, of the Collection of
Bodhidharma’s Works3 retrieved from Dunhuang Caves)
“
AWAKENINGTOREALITY.COM
Way of Bodhi
Soh Wei Yu
Also see: Bodhidharma’s Doctrine of No Mind
AWAKENINGTOREALITY.COM
The Doctrine of No Mind by Bodhidharma (无心论)