Skip to main content

AtR Dharma Library

Library shortcuts

Continue exploring the core readings, free books, audio and full Dharma library.

Browse Must Reads ↗ — begin with Seven Stages, then On Anatta.

Where is the flower?

By
 
I was contemplating on dependent arising and emptiness this morning, follow on a conversation with a friend ytd.. my inquiry goes -
**
When you see a flower,
ask, is the flower in my mind? is the flower out there apart from my mind? Is the flower in between mind and out there? where? where is the flower?🤨
When you hear a sound, ask,
Is the sound in my ear? in my mind? in my brain? in the radio? in the air? separated from my mind? is it independently floating? WHERE?🤨
when you touch a table, ask,
Is this touch, in my finger? in the table? in the between space? in my brain? in my mind? separated from mind? WHERE?🤨
Keep finding. See, Hear, Feel. The mind need to look to be satisfied. If not it keeps being ignorant.
*
Then you will see, There was never a SELF , self in buddhism means independent thing - singular, independent, one, substantial THING sitting outside or inside or any where in this 'world'.
For the sound to appear, the ear, radio, air, waves, mind, knowing, etc etc etc need to come together and there's a sound. lack of one and there is no sound.
-this is dependent arising.
But then where is it? what really is this that you are hearing? so vivid of an orchestra! but where?! 🤨
-That is Emptiness.
**
It's all just illusory. There, yet not there. Appear yet empty.
That is , the nature of reality.
You never needed to fear. You only wrongly thought it's all real.
You, John Tan, Mr. TJ and 16 others
8 Comments
3 Shares
Like
Comment
Share

8 Comments

Most relevant


  • Mr./Ms. YEH
    wonderful investigation
    ❤️🙏

    Like
    Reply1d
    Mr. RM
    That last part though ❤🙏

    Like
    Reply1d
    John Tan
    Yin Ling Luminous appearance that does not exist (med pa gsal snang)
    See whether u can find articles about "med pa gsal snang", I can't, maybe u can. 🤦
    Like
    Reply1d
    Active
    Yin Ling
    John Tan haha I will try , if cannot I will ask Soh Wei Yu the ever resourceful one 🤣

    Like
    Reply1d
    Active
    Yin Ling
    John Tan https://www.lionsroar.com/this-very-mind-empty-and-luminous/
    this one ok?
    This Very Mind, Empty and Luminous
    LIONSROAR.COM
    This Very Mind, Empty and Luminous
    This Very Mind, Empty and Luminous

    Like
    Reply1d
    John Tan
    Yin Ling yes very good except that it din use that phrase. But the explanation about analytical vs experiential (true) emptiness is good.👍.

    Like
    Reply1dEdited
    Active
    Yin Ling
    John Tan that phrase i cannot find, too many tibetan words appear, cant read lol

    Like
    Reply1d
    Chae Cramb
    Try "par" instead of "pa". No articles, but you'll find a bunch of posts by Malcolm and Kyle if you google "med par gsal snang".

    2
    Like
    Reply10h
    Active

Comments

The AtR Dharma Library

Must Reads

New here? Begin with Seven Stages, then On Anatta. Explore the full collection below.

View full list on page →

New in the AtR library

Latest posts

Up to 20 recent articles, newest publication first.

Browse more posts below.

Browse more posts →

AtR Library

Browse books, articles, recordings and ways to follow AtR.

Start Here →Recommended readings and the free AtR guides John Tan’s Website ↗
Free Books
    View section on page →
    Featured Articles
      View section on page →
      Audio & Video
        View section on page →
        Further Reading
          View section on page →
          Follow Awakening to Reality
            View section on page →
            Full library on page

            Search AtR

            Examples: anatta · I AM · emptiness · dependent origination · Zen · Mahamudra · Dzogchen

            Try Google for broader results ↗

            Google searches this site in a new tab.