Start Here
New · October 2026
Introducing John Tan’s
New Website
Thusness / PasserBy · Books, articles and narrated videos
Exploring anatta, emptiness and dependent arising
I’m happy to share John Tan’s new website. Many readers of Awakening to Reality will know John as Thusness / PasserBy, the author of Seven Stages of Enlightenment and On Anatta (No-Self), Emptiness, Maha and Ordinariness, and Spontaneous Perfection.
The new site brings together his books, articles and narrated videos, with a particular focus on post-anatta insights—the deepening of emptiness and dependent arising. Its opening page, After Anatta, connects these explorations to phases 5–7 of the seven phases of insight. The written materials and videos are free to read, watch and share, and the site also provides read-aloud listening.
I warmly encourage readers at any stage to visit John’s website. The books are especially concerned with right view and non-substantiality, and some discussions can be challenging for those not yet familiar with the distinction between substantialist non-duality and anatta. That need not be a barrier to exploring the site. You can browse it now, learn from what is accessible, and return to more demanding passages as your practice and understanding develop.
New to AtR? A reading path to accompany John’s website
You are welcome to explore John’s website right away. The following are recommended companions, not prerequisites. They provide a broader map and help clarify what John is examining, even if you are only beginning to practise:
- Thusness/PasserBy’s Seven Stages of Enlightenment
The broader experiential map: from I AM, through non-duality, to anatta, emptiness and spontaneous perfection. - On Anatta (No-Self), Emptiness, Maha and Ordinariness, and Spontaneous Perfection
A closer exploration of no-self, the two anatta stanzas, and the relationship between insight, luminosity, emptiness and practice.
These two foundational articles are especially useful for understanding the larger trajectory of John’s newer writings. You can read them in that order, alongside his website rather than feeling you must finish them before visiting it.
If you are still practising toward the I AM realization: the Awakening to Reality Practice Guide is a more direct resource for self-enquiry and practical instructions. At the same time, acquaintance with right view from the outset can help prevent non-dual experience from being mistaken for the realization of anatta. You can explore John’s writings at your own pace without needing to understand all of their arguments immediately.
If you are already investigating anatta, emptiness or dependent arising: John’s guide to reading his books is a natural next stop. His website offers a more sustained exploration of these questions, which can be revisited as insight matures.
Why this collection matters
One of the important themes of John’s After Anatta introduction is that insight, experience and view do not necessarily mature together. He describes how anatta had dawned, yet habitual ways of understanding experience still needed further examination. Seeing through a separate observer does not, by itself, settle every assumption about the reality of mind, phenomena, time or causality.
The new material takes up these questions in depth. How does the understanding of no-self deepen into the emptiness of phenomena? What does dependent designation mean in lived experience? How can continuity, responsibility and everyday functioning be understood without positing an independently existing carrier underneath them?
For readers familiar with the foundational AtR articles, this collection offers a way to follow those questions through sustained explanations, experiential reflections and close engagement with Madhyamaka. I recommend reading slowly, returning to the earlier articles where useful, and bringing the inquiry back to experience.
What you will find: the books
The library currently brings together the following five works. They approach related questions from different directions, so you can move between them as your inquiry develops.
The Logical Necessity of a Substrateless World
The extended argument: an examination of the assumption that anything can exist from its own side, and its implications for mind, perception, causality and continuity.
The Transition from Anatta to Emptiness
The experiential companion: how the understanding develops from anatta into a more thorough understanding of emptiness, including the relationship between view, insight and experience.
Nāgārjuna’s Middle Way
A chapter-by-chapter presentation of Nāgārjuna’s Fundamental Verses on the Middle Way, with Sanskrit, an English translation, explanations and diagrams. It provides textual context for arguments discussed throughout the collection.
The Observer and the Taste of Presence
A shorter route through the inquiry into the observer and the nature of presence, extending into discussions of Madhyamaka and Dzogchen, including the expression “beyond cause and effect.”
The Logic After Anatta
An introduction to the logic of dependency through eight steps, followed by its application to questions about mind, time, rebirth and other topics. This material forms the site’s After Anatta starting page and links into the fuller discussions in the books.
Where I suggest beginning
Whenever you are ready to explore the books, John’s guide to reading them explains how the works relate and offers different routes for readers interested in experience, reasoning or the source texts. You need not follow a fixed sequence:
- If you are mainly practising toward I AM: use the AtR Practice Guide for practical instructions, while browsing John’s site for orientation on right view and questions that interest you.
- For the transition itself: begin with The Transition from Anatta to Emptiness, especially if your interest is how view and experiential insight develop together.
- For a short introduction to the reasoning: try the article The Logic of Dependency, or follow the eight steps in The Logic After Anatta.
- For a sustained study: read The Logical Necessity of a Substrateless World, returning to the relevant chapters of Nāgārjuna’s Middle Way alongside it.
There are also shorter articles on particular questions, including Dependent Designation and the Taste of Presence, Two Modes, One Seeing, and The Architecture of Carrierless Continuity. These can be useful when a specific question draws your attention.
Read, listen, watch—and explore the sources
If you prefer listening, the chapters offer a read-aloud option. The Watch section gathers narrated videos with drawings, providing another way to approach the material and revisit it after reading.
The site also includes Ask the Books, where Claude answers questions using the collection and links to the chapters it draws on. This is an AI reading aid, rather than a direct conversation with John. Follow the chapter links and read the passages in context. The site notes that this feature uses your own Claude allowance and asks for permission on first use.
John Tan · Thusness / PasserBy
Continue exploring
Whether you are just beginning your practice or already deeply exploring anatta and emptiness, I hope you will visit John’s site and return to it often. Read what speaks to your present questions, use the foundational AtR articles and Practice Guide alongside it, and allow both experiential insight and right view to deepen together.
Explore John Tan’s Website ↗atr-passerby.comIntroduction and reading recommendations by Soh Wei Yu · October 2026; reading guidance updated 15 November 2026. Book descriptions and site features are based on John’s reading guide, library and After Anatta introduction, originally checked on 27 October 2026.
Comments
My special appreciation and gratitude to Soh and John for sharing profound dhamma for so long with the world.
Most of the paragraphs in the PDF is worth underlining and contemplating. While John provides deep dhamma points, Soh brings those out by asking great questions and complimenting his own realizations.
This is what I see as unique about this writing:
1) covers broadly both non-dual and buddha's teaching. Even with Buddha's teaching you are not limiting yourself to one branch as you share great pointers from theravada, zen, mahamudra etc.
2) you have succeeded in explaining deep dhamma without using any Pali or Sanskrit words!
3) Soh takes great care to share non-dual, I am, one mind, no-mind, awareness, consciousness etc etc using great examples that covers many angles - a feature that I haven't seen in any other great dhamma books.
4) Most writing is a result of their own realization - a rare point in most modern dhamma books and written in practical terms.
5) I also appreciate John's persistence to keep things simple. Most get bogged-down on dogmas and complicated dhamma points that result in stagnation and/or never ending discussions or arguments.
6) though I wish to highlight so many paragraphs, may I finish with only one:
"Intuit the vipassana and the samatha. Intuit the total exertion and realization. The essence of message must be raw and uncontaminated by words. It cannot be secondhand." -by John Tan, 2019.
May I add that the most important word here is 'intuit (intuition)'. I hope John agrees.
The ePub has just been uploaded: https://app.box.com/s/1yr71xbut8y7gr5qc7c6m4fzfl1bf37s
Hi MarkA,
Thank you so much, MarkA, for your heartfelt appreciation and thoughtful feedback :)