Skip to main content

(Korean) 비개념성의 병 - The Disease of Non-Conceptuality

By


New Translation

비개념성의 질병 (The Disease of Non-Conceptuality)

소(Soh):

저는 사유함(Thusness)의 몇몇 게시물들을 다시 살펴보다가 많은 사람들(한때의 저를 포함하여, 그리고 제가 포럼에서 보는 많은 다른 사람들)의 문제를 정말 잘 요약한 게시물을 하나 발견했습니다…

사유함(Thusness):

(2010년 10월 31일)

안녕하세요, 가이스(Geis) 씨,

AEN이 그 후에 그 포럼에서 대혼란을 일으킬 것이기 때문에 다른 사람들의 포럼에 대해 언급하는 것을 ‘두려워’합니다… ㅋㅋ.

농담은 제쳐두고, 아나타(무아)에 대한 통찰이 일어났다고 말하기에는 아직 너무 이르다고 생각합니다. 무아라는 주제에 대해 숙고한 결과로 나타난 다음과 같은 경험들에 대한 혼합과 명료함의 부족이 있는 것 같습니다:

  1. 비개념성 안에 머무르는 것
  2. 궁극적인 주체로서 머무르는 것 또는
  3. 단순한 현상성의 흐름으로서 머무르는 것

사례 1에서 수행자들은 ‘보이는 것은 주관적이지도 객관적이지도 않다… 그것은 단지 있을 뿐이다…’라고 봅니다.

경험의 측면에서, 수행자들은 우주, 생명을 느낄 것입니다. 그러나 이것은 아나타(무아)가 아니라 정체성과 인격성을 벗겨내는(해체하는) 결과입니다.

이러한 비개념적 지각 방식이 궁극적인 것으로 받아들여질 때, “있는 그대로”, “있음(Isness)”, “그러함(Thusness)”이라는 용어들은 종종 단순히 비개념성 안에 머무르며 ‘날것의 현현’에서 아무것도 더하거나 빼지 않는 것을 의미하는 것으로 받아들여집니다. 그러한 경험에는 부작용이 있습니다. 비록 비개념성 속에서 비이원이 가장 생생하고 명확하지만, 수행자들은 ‘개념들’이 문제라고 잘못 결론 내릴 수 있습니다. 왜냐하면 ‘개념들’의 현존이 분리하고 비이원적 경험을 막기 때문입니다. 이것은 주객 이분법에 깊이 뿌리내린 마음에만 논리적이고 합리적으로 보입니다. 매우 빠르게 ‘비개념성’은 수행의 대상이 됩니다. 대상화의 과정은 끝없는 고리처럼 다른 형태를 취하며 영속적으로 반복되는 경향성의 작용의 결과입니다. 이것은 수행자가 그것을 알지 못한 채 개념을 확립하는 것을 심지어 ‘두려워’할 수 있을 정도까지 계속될 수 있습니다. 그들은 견해(dṛṣṭi)와 개념의 형성을 막으려는 노력에 의해 마비됩니다. 우리가 ‘고통은 단지 있을 뿐이다’라고 볼 때, 우리는 비개념성의 ‘질병’에 빠지지 않도록 매우 조심해야 합니다.

사례 2에서는 수행자들이 매우 미묘한 방식으로, 거의 무의식적으로 형이상학적 본질(体)을 계속 의인화하고, 실체화하고, 추론하는 것이 일반적입니다. 이것은 비이원적 깨달음에도 불구하고 이해가 여전히 주객 이분법에 기반한 견해(dṛṣṭi)에서 비롯되기 때문입니다. 따라서 이 경향을 감지하기 어렵고 수행자들은 ‘자아에 기반한 무아’에 대한 이해를 구축하는 여정을 계속합니다.

사례 3의 수행자들은 아나타(무아)의 교리를 이해하는 데 더 나은 위치에 있습니다. 아나타에 대한 통찰이 발생(能生)하면, 모든 경험은 암묵적으로 비이원적이 됩니다. 그러나 그 통찰은 단순히 분리성을 꿰뚫어 보는 것에 관한 것이 아닙니다. 그것은 실체화의 철저한 종식에 관한 것이어서 ‘행위자’가 부가적인 것이며, 실제 경험에서는 존재하지 않는다는 즉각적인 인식이 있도록 하는 것입니다. 그것은 경험적 실재가 항상 그래왔으며 중심, 기반, 근거, 근원의 존재는 항상 가정되어 왔다는 즉각적인 깨달음입니다. 이것은 비개념성과 관련된 ‘정체성과 인격성의 해체’와는 다르지만, 일시적인 현상에서 행위자의 비존재를 ‘실제로’ 보는 것입니다.

여기서 수행자들은 사례 1에서처럼 단지 우주를 느낄 뿐만 아니라, 행위자가 사라졌기 때문에 우리의 타고난 권리인 자유를 즉각적으로 경험하기도 합니다. 여기서 수행자들이 자유를 ‘옳고 그름이 없고 원초적 순수성의 상태에 머무르는 것’으로 착각하지 않는다는 점에 주목하는 것이 중요합니다. 그들은 비개념성에 의해 마비되지 않고, 현상의 ‘발생과 사라짐’을 해방적인 것으로 명확하게 볼 수 있습니다. 왜냐하면 거기에 봄을 ‘방해’할 영구적인 행위자가 없기 때문입니다. 즉, 수행자는 ‘경험이 무엇인지’ 깨달을 뿐만 아니라 경험의 ‘본성’도 이해하기 시작합니다.

사례 3의 깨달음을 성숙시키기 위해서는, 행위자의 부재에 대한 직접적인 경험조차도 불충분하다는 것이 증명될 것입니다. 견해(dṛṣṭi)의 측면에서도 완전히 새로운 패러다임 전환이 있어야 합니다. 우리는 근원, 본질(体), 중심, 위치, 행위자 또는 통제자로부터 우리의 순간순간의 경험적 실재를 분석하고, 보고, 이해하려는 생각, 필요성, 충동, 경향성에 얽매이는 것으로부터 우리 자신을 해방시키고, 전적으로 아나타(무아)와 연기(緣起, Dependent Origination)에 의지해야 합니다.

제 의견으로는, “나는 누구인가(Who am I)”와 “내면의 잡담 잠재우기(Quietening the Inner Chatter)”에 관한 글들을 게시하는 블로그가 비이원성, 아나타(무아), 공(空)에 대한 더 깊이 있는 통찰을 제공합니다. 저자는 ‘경험이 무엇인지’와 경험의 ‘본성(지지하는 조건(pratyaya; paccaya)에 따른 무상, 공, 연기)’에 대한 매우 깊은 명료함을 보여줍니다.

그냥 제 두 푼입니다. :-)


2021년 업데이트:

딘 로빈슨(Din Robinson)

저는 오히려 아무것도 실제로 알려질 수 없지만 존재(Being)는 그것에 대한 앎이 필요 없는 절대적인 것이라고 말하고 싶습니다. 왜냐하면 앎은 그것 안에서, 그것으로서 나타나기 때문입니다.

·

답글

· 1일 전

딘 로빈슨(Din Robinson)

그리고 만약 당신이 제가 무슨 말을 하는지 안다고 생각한다면, 저는 모릅니다, 저는 그냥 되는대로 지어내고 있을 뿐입니다…

·

답글

· 1일 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

존 탄(John Tan)과 저는 “모르는 마음(don't know mind)”에 “반대”합니다. 사실 그것은 보통 아뢰야(alaya)의 미결정성이라고 불리는 마릭파(marigpa, 무지) 상태를 가리킵니다. (다음 게시물 참조)

[18/5/14, 오전 9:56:36] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 어쨌든 그녀가 대광(Dae Kwang)에게 누가 내려놓는지 물었습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:57:07] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 대광은 정확하게 말했습니다. 그가 그녀에게 되물었고, 제 생각에 그녀는 모른다고 대답했고, 그러자 그는 옳다고, 심지어 부처님들도 모른다고, 이 모르는 것이 불성(佛性)이라고 말했습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:57:22] 존 탄(John Tan): 말도 안 돼.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:57:42] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 뭐가 말도 안 된다는 거죠?

[18/5/14, 오전 9:58:01] 존 탄(John Tan): 그런 어중간한 대답은 선(禪)이 아니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:58:08] 존 탄(John Tan): 타락했다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:58:22] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 아, 하지만 그도 말했어요.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:58:29] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 반야심경에 눈도 코도… 등등 없다고.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:58:35] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그런 다음 그가 눈 없음이 무엇이냐고 물었습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:58:48] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그가 누군가에게 물었는데 그 사람은 모른다고 했습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:58:53] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그는 벽이 하얗다고 말했습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:59:46] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 숭산(Seung Sahn)은 항상 모른다는 것을 강조합니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:59:50] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 제 생각엔 그냥 비개념성인 것 같아요.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:59:55] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 모른다는 부분 말이에요.

[18/5/14, 오전 9:59:57] 존 탄(John Tan): 압니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:00:29] 존 탄(John Tan): 이것은 지혜라기보다는 질병입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:01:44] 존 탄(John Tan): "모른다"가 가리키는 것은 "비개념적" 기능입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:03:30] 존 탄(John Tan): 조사와 안정된 통찰이 부족하면 비개념적 기능의 안정된 통찰과 "개념적 해방"을 구별할 수 없을 것입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:04:20] 존 탄(John Tan): 원래 탄주이홍(Tan Jui Hong)에게 말하고 싶었지만 너무 많이 말하고 싶지 않았습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:05:11] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요..

[18/5/14, 오전 10:05:35] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 주이에게 말해야 한다고 생각해요… 어쨌든 주이는 아나타(무아)를 깨달았고, 제 생각엔 완전한 노력에 들어갔을 수도 있지만 확실하지는 않아요.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:06:15] 존 탄(John Tan): 다음에.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:06:21] 존 탄(John Tan): 그가 싱가포르 사람인가요?

[18/5/14, 오전 10:09:06] 존 탄(John Tan): 실체화된 구성물로부터 자유로워지는 것은 완전히 새로운 수행의 세계입니다. 거기서부터 "모르는 마음"이 시작됩니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:14:26] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 주이 말인가요?

[18/5/14, 오전 10:14:31] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 네, 주이는 싱가포르 사람이고, 전에 만난 적 있으시잖아요.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:14:37] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요..

[18/5/14, 오전 10:14:37] 존 탄(John Tan): 네.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:14:40] 존 탄(John Tan): 그렇군요.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:23:21] 존 탄(John Tan): 또한 실체화된 구성물을 이해하고 자신 안에서 실체화된 구성물을 경험하는 것이 가장 중요한 측면입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:24:31] 존 탄(John Tan): 그것이 아나타(무아)의 첫 부분이 집착을 이해하는 열쇠입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:25:25] 존 탄(John Tan): 구성물과 실체화를 이해할 때만이 집착을 이해할 수 있습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:27:23] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요..

[18/5/14, 오전 10:27:49] 존 탄(John Tan): 그래서 정신적 구성물을 이해하는 것은 매우 중요합니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:28:11] 존 탄(John Tan): 그것은 에너지와 심신 반응을 포함합니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:32:53] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요..

‎[18/5/14, 오전 10:46:32] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): ‎이미지 생략됨

[18/5/14, 오전 10:46:43] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 비개념적인 것을 지나치게 강조하는 것 같아요.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:48:17] 존 탄(John Tan): 그것은 통찰과 조사가 부족한 것입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:49:16] 존 탄(John Tan): 즉, 개념적 마음으로 작업하는 것이 부족하여, "이유들"과 "방식"이 적절하게 표현되지 않는다는 것입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:49:33] 존 탄(John Tan): 수학의 아름다움이 있습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:49:59] 존 탄(John Tan): 복잡한 움직임과 변화율을 이해하기 위한 미적분학처럼 말입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:51:03] 존 탄(John Tan): 글렌딘(Glendin)은 완전한 노력과 아나타(무아)를 적절하게 표현할 수 있습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:51:52] 존 탄(John Tan): 에너지, 프라나(prana), 기능성에 대한 알아차림 가르침은 "개념성" 때문이 아닙니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 10:54:06] 존 탄(John Tan): 단지 "모르는 마음"뿐입니다. 그렇게 함으로써, 그는 조사 부족으로 인해 자신과 다른 사람들에게 혼란을 야기했습니다. 비개념적 기능의 방식은 마음으로 해결될 수 없습니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 11:13:12] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요.. 마음으로 해결될 수 없다면 어떤 방식으로 해결되나요?

[18/5/14, 오전 11:15:23] 존 탄(John Tan): 그들이 말하는 "모르는 마음"에 의해서입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 11:15:37] 존 탄(John Tan): 문제는 그들이 모른다는 것입니다.

[18/5/14, 오전 11:15:39] 존 탄(John Tan): ㅋㅋ

·

답글

· 1일 전

· 수정됨

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/.../the-disease-of...

AWAKENINGTOREALITY.COM

비개념성의 질병 (The Disease of Non-Conceptuality)

비개념성의 질병 (The Disease of Non-Conceptuality)

·

답글

·

미리보기 제거

· 1일 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

"모르는 마음"이 실제로는 마릭파(ma-rigpa) (또는 기껏해야 미성숙한 릭파(rigpa)의 거친 형태) 상태라는 점에 대해, 미팜 린포체(Mipham Rinpoche)는 다음과 같이 멋지게 표현합니다:

https://www.lotsawahouse.org/tibetan.../mipham/mipham-lamp

인용: "여기에는 사물을 정확하게 분별하는 위파사나(vipaśyanā)의 명확한 통찰이 전혀 없으므로, 스승들은 그것을 마릭파(“무인식, 무지, 모름”)라고 부릅니다. 당신이 그것을 정의하여 “이것이 이렇다”거나 “이것이 그것이다!”라고 말할 수 없기 때문에, 그러한 상태는 룽마텐(“미결정, 미정”)이라고 불립니다. 그리고 당신이 어떤 종류의 상태에 머물러 있는지, 또는 당신의 마음이 무엇을 생각하고 있는지 말할 수 없기 때문에, 그것은 또한 타말 탕뇰(“무관심한 평범한 상태”)이라고도 불립니다. 사실, 당신은 아뢰야(ālaya) 안의 평범한 상태에 갇혀 있는 것입니다."

릭파(rigpa) (지식)와 대조적으로: "비록 여기에는 경험과 경험자 사이의 이원론적 분리가 없지만, 그럼에도 불구하고 마음은 자신의 진정한 본성에 대해 확신하며, “이것을 넘어서는 것은 아무것도 없다”는 감각이 있습니다. 이것이 일어날 때, 당신이 그것을 개념화하거나 말로 표현할 수 없기 때문에, 다음과 같은 용어를 적용하는 것이 허용됩니다: “모든 극단으로부터 자유로움”, “묘사를 넘어선”, “맑은 빛의 근본 상태” 그리고 “릭파의 순수한 알아차림”."

자신의 진정한 본성을 인식하는 지혜가 동트면서, 그것은 혼란의 눈먼 어둠을 걷어내고, 해가 뜨면 집 안을 명확하게 볼 수 있는 것처럼, 당신은 마음의 진정한 본성에 대한 확신 있는 확실성을 얻습니다."

LOTSAWAHOUSE.ORG

어둠을 밝히는 등불 (A Lamp to Dispel Darkness)

어둠을 밝히는 등불 (A Lamp to Dispel Darkness)

·

답글

·

미리보기 제거

· 1일 전

· 수정됨

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

그리고 마찬가지로, 촉니 린포체(Tsoknyi Rinpoche)와 다른 많은 스승들은 릭파(rigpa)가 확실성으로 특징지어진다고 지적했습니다. 저도 제 일지에서 마찬가지로 말했습니다.

https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/.../absolute-certainty...

절대적 확실성 (Absolute Certainty)

"첫째, 그것을 인정하는 것을 자신의 본성을 인식한다고 합니다. 다음으로, 인식된 것에 대해 결정적이어야 합니다. 이것은 더 복잡합니다. 왜냐하면 실제로 누가 결정하는가? 그것을 결정하는 것은 개념적 마음인가? 아니면 릭파(rigpa) 자체가 결정하는가? 아니면 당신의 스승이 당신의 마음을 결정하는가 - "구루가 그렇게 말씀하셨으니, 그것은 틀림없이 사실일 것이다"? 아니면 현대 기술이 당신을 위해 그것을 검증해 줄 것인가? 릭파 연구실에 가서 기기로 당신의 심장과 뇌를 확인하여 당신의 릭파가 괜찮고 건강한지, 당신의 비이원성이 좋은 상태인지 결정할 수 있을까?

이 점을 어떻게 해결하는가? 자신의 경험을 즉시 지지해야 하는 것이 어려울 수 있지만, 그것이 실제로 릭파라는 60%의 확신만 있어도 결정할 수 있다. 검증의 기초로서, 우리는 스승의 말씀, 진정한 경전의 말씀, 그리고 우리 자신의 경험을 사용한다. 릭파를 경험하는 우리의 상태가 정말로 릭파일 때, 그 안에는 자동적인 확실성의 느낌이 있다. 그 확실성에 도달하기 위해서는 과정에 시간을 좀 들여야 하고, 열정도 있어야 한다. 확실성이 내장된, 자동적인 확실성의 지점이 있다. 일단 이 자연스럽고 흔들리지 않는 확실성에 도달하면, 우리는 너무나 확신하여 부처님 자신이 우리 앞에 와서 "이봐, 네가 틀렸어, 그건 릭파가 아니야!"라고 말씀하신다 해도, 우리는 그분께 와주셔서 감사하다고 하겠지만, 우리의 확실성은 전혀 변하지 않을 것이다. 어떤 시점에서는 공(空)한 본질(体), 인지하는 본성, 그리고 구속되지 않는 능력의 특질들이 너무나 명백해져서 우리는 정말로 알게 된다. 이 시점에서, 우리는 우리 마음속에서 일어나는 모든 것이 그 자체로 해방될 수 있다는 확실성을 얻은 것이다."

  • 촉니 린포체(Tsoknyi Rinpoche), 『두려움 없는 단순함: 복잡한 세상에서 자유롭게 사는 족첸(Dzogchen) 방식 (Fearless Simplicity: The Dzogchen Way of Living Freely in a Complex World)』 꼬리표: 촉니 린포체 |

AWAKENINGTOREALITY.COM

절대적 확실성 (Absolute Certainty)

절대적 확실성 (Absolute Certainty)

·

답글

·

미리보기 제거

· 1일 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

그리고 마찬가지로 존 탄(John Tan)은 위 인용문에서 다음과 같이 말했습니다.

"제가 견해(dṛṣṭi) 없음에 빠져 있지 않다고 언급했던 것 같습니다. 자아를 꿰뚫어 봄으로써 자유로워지는 것은 "모르는" 형태가 아니며, 반대로 그것은 우리의 본성을 직접 이해할 수 있게 해주는 깊은 지혜입니다.”

·

답글

· 1일 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

"그러나 무지 때문에, 우리는 매우 고유하고 이원적인 견해(dṛṣṭi)를 가지고 있으며, 만약 우리가 현존의 본성을 꿰뚫어 본다면, 마음은 계속해서 이원론적이고 고유한 경향의 영향을 받습니다. 많은 사람들이 단순한 비개념성을 통해 그것을 극복하라고 가르치지만, 이것은 매우 오해의 소지가 있습니다." - https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/.../anatta-and-pure...

AWAKENINGTOREALITY.COM

아나타(무아)와 순수 현존 (Anatta and Pure Presence)

아나타(무아)와 순수 현존 (Anatta and Pure Presence)

·

답글

·

미리보기 제거

· 1일 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

[17/9/30, 오후 10:50:32] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그가 입을 열면 이미 틀렸다고 말합니다. 생각을 끊어버리라고… 그런 다음 선봉(禪杖)으로 바닥을 칩니다… 마음과 그 침이 같습니까, 다릅니까? 답은 단지 침일 뿐입니다. 안팎 등이 없습니다… 당신은 어디에서 왔습니까… 하나는 어디로 돌아갑니까 등등. 모두 단지 침일 뿐입니다. 하지만 인터뷰 후에 그들이 서로 토론하는 것을 들었는데, 이해하십니까? 그들은 모두 어깨를 으쓱하며, 스승이 무슨 말을 하는지 모릅니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 10:55:20] 존 탄(John Tan): 선(禪)은 여여함(suchness)의 비언어적 표현입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 10:56:00] 존 탄(John Tan): 아나타(무아)의 실현을 가장 직접적이고 직관적인 방식으로 표현하려는 것입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 10:57:05] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요..

[17/9/30, 오후 10:57:12] 존 탄(John Tan): 그러나 그것의 극단은 통찰이 더 이상의 통찰을 막을 것이라는 점입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 10:57:45] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 비개념적 질병에 빠지기 때문인가요?

[17/9/30, 오후 10:58:32] 존 탄(John Tan): 그리고 실현은 계속 진행 중입니다… 공안(koan) 이후에는, 동전의 양면을 모두 포용하도록 자신을 성숙시켜야 합니다…

[17/9/30, 오후 10:59:12] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 양면이란 무엇인가요?

[17/9/30, 오후 10:59:21] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 견해(dṛṣṭi)와 비이원적 경험인가요?

[17/9/30, 오후 10:59:37] 존 탄(John Tan): 네.

[17/9/30, 오후 10:59:52] 존 탄(John Tan): 비언어적 직접 경험은 중요합니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:00:05] 존 탄(John Tan): 단지 지나친 강조가 문제일 뿐입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:00:17] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요..

[17/9/30, 오후 11:01:52] 존 탄(John Tan): 단지 비언어적인 것에 너무 많은 강조를 두면 마음이 명확하게 볼 수 없기 때문에 우리의 본성에 대한 더 이상의 통찰을 막을 것입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:02:59] 존 탄(John Tan): 그러나 너무 많은 분석과 생각은 에너지와 직관적으로 느껴지는 감각 수행에 심각한 장애물입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:03:05] 존 탄(John Tan): 균형을 맞춰야 합니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:16:37] 존 탄(John Tan): 사트 치트 아난다(Sat chit Ananda)도 매우 정제된 단계일 수 있습니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:16:54] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 나 있음(I amness)의 다른 단계들처럼요?

[17/9/30, 오후 11:17:04] 존 탄(John Tan): 네.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:17:16] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 그렇군요..

[17/9/30, 오후 11:17:58] 존 탄(John Tan): 단지 이것저것 경험했다고 말하고 싶지 않아서요… ㅋㅋ. … 더 이상 논쟁하기에는 너무 늙었어요…

[17/9/30, 오후 11:18:09] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): ㅋㅋ

[17/9/30, 오후 11:19:46] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 방금 그가 인터뷰 전에도 생사를 넘어선 하나의 명확한 것이 무엇이냐고 질문했어요… 그런 다음 저는 그 질문에 앉아 단지 지복스러운 존재성을 경험했어요. 존재성이 지복스러운 것처럼… 사실 비이원적인 것은 무엇이든 지복스러워서 숨쉬는 것조차 믿을 수 없을 정도로 지복스러울 수 있어요.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:21:27] 존 탄(John Tan): 네, 하지만 당신은 아나타(무아) 또는 완전한 노력 또는 장애 없는 자아 발생 현상 속에 있습니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:21:42] 존 탄(John Tan): 아니면 침묵 속에 있나요?

[17/9/30, 오후 11:22:05] 존 탄(John Tan): 아니면 비이원적 알아차림 속에 있나요?

[17/9/30, 오후 11:22:14] 존 탄(John Tan): 모두 비이원적입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:22:19] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): ㅋㅋ

[17/9/30, 오후 11:22:57] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 질문에 따라 다른 것 같아요. 예를 들어, 태어나기 전에 나는 누구인가라는 질문은 더 침묵하는 존재, 단지 마음으로 이어지는 것 같아요.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:23:22] 존 탄(John Tan): 단지 나 있음(I M)입니다.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:23:46] 존 탄(John Tan): 완전히 존재성 속으로.

[17/9/30, 오후 11:25:09] 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu): 네.

·

답글

· 1일 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

딘 로빈슨(Din Robinson)

·

답글

· 23시간 전

딘 로빈슨(Din Robinson)

안녕하세요, 소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 씨, 인용구를 사용하지 않고 가능한 한 적은 단어로 당신이 무슨 말을 하는지 직접 말씀해주시면 감사하겠습니다.

·

답글

· 22시간 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

딘 로빈슨(Din Robinson)

해탈의 열쇠는 아나타(무아)와 공(空)에 대한 더 깊고 깊은 통찰입니다. 단지 비개념성이나 “모름”의 상태에 머무르는 것이 아닙니다.

·

답글

· 14시간 전

딘 로빈슨(Din Robinson)

고맙습니다, 매우 간결했네요.

·

답글

· 12시간 전

소 웨이 유(Soh Wei Yu) 관리자

또한 관련:

https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/.../the-trap-of-non...

비개념성의 덫 (The Trap of Non-Conceptuality)

또한 참조: 비개념성의 질병 (The Disease of Non-Conceptuality)

나에게, 개념성이 덫이라는 생각은 실제로는 영적 수행의 잠재력을 고갈시키는 덫 그 자체이다. 그것은 경험의 매우 타당한 차원을 버리는 것을 수반한다 - 결국, 생각 또한 현실의 일부이다. 그리고 이원성의 환상을 만드는 것이 생각이므로, 환상이 해체되어야 하는 것은 생각의 수준에서이다. "현실"의 수준에서는 아무것도 할 일이 없다.

"관찰하고 보라" [당신이 따르는 유일한 지침이라고 말하는] 또한 무언가를 하는 것이다. 지침 없는 영적인 길은 길이 아니다. 그리고 지침이 있는 순간부터, 수행자에 따라 모든 것이 타당할 수 있다.

신-아드바이타(neo-Advaita)는 길과 해탈의 수단과 관련하여 허무주의적인 경향이 있다는 특징을 가지고 있다. "아무도 없고, 아무것도 할 필요가 없다." 이것은 경험의 본성에 대한 심오한 오해를 드러낸다: 모든 것은 경험 속에서 일어난다, 그것을 수행할 행위자가 없더라도 - 영적인 길도 예외는 아니다.

"생각하지 않음"의 단순함은 우리가 중요하고 귀찮은 질문을 하는 것을 막는 편안한 보금자리이다. 관찰 행위에는 "현존"이 있지만, 그 현존은 그것의 본성을 알리기 위해 조사되어야 한다. 그렇지 않으면, 우리는 하나의 믿음 - 자아에 대한 믿음 -을 다른 믿음 - 어떤 불변하고 영원한 현존에 대한 믿음 -으로 대체하고 있는 것이다. 에고와 현존 모두 그것들을 확립하는 사람들에게는 명백하고 부인할 수 없다.

불교 또한 모든 개념을 용해시키지만, 오직 그것들이 이미 모든 개념을 해체하는 작업을 완료했을 때만 그렇다. 개념성을 너무 빨리 "침묵시키는" 것은 우리가 개념적 무지의 벽을 넘어서기 위해 (분석적 사고의) 사다리를 사용하기 전에 그것을 버리는 것이다.

– 앙드레 A. 파이스(Andre A. Pais)

AWAKENINGTOREALITY.COM

비개념성의 덫 (The Trap of Non-Conceptuality)

비개념성의 덫 (The Trap of Non-Conceptuality)

·

답글

·

미리보기 제거

· 23시간 전

소(Soh)의 논평:

그러므로, 아나트만(무아)의 깨달음은 단지 개념을 중단하는 상태가 아니며, 이는 무지를 종식시키는 반야(般若, prajna) 지혜를 부여하지 않습니다.

"아비드야(avidyā, 무지)를 근절하는 과정은… 단순히 생각을 멈추는 것이 아니라, 무지가 오해하는 것의 반대를 적극적으로 깨닫는 것으로 인식된다. 아비드야는 단순히 지식의 부재가 아니라 특정한 오해이며, 그것의 반대를 깨달음으로써 제거되어야 한다. 이런 맥락에서 총카파(Tsongkhapa)는 어두컴컴한 동굴에 악마가 있다는 생각을 단순히 그것에 대해 생각하지 않으려고 노력함으로써 없앨 수 없는 것처럼, 단순히 개념성을 멈춤으로써 '고유한 존재'라는 오해를 없앨 수 없다고 말한다. 등불을 들고 거기에 악마가 없다는 것을 보아야 하는 것처럼, 무지의 어둠을 걷어내기 위해서는 지혜의 조명이 필요하다." - 내퍼, 엘리자베스 (Napper, Elizabeth), 2003, p. 103"

그것은 마음의 본성을 실제로 보고 깨닫는 통찰, 깨달음, 유레카 순간입니다:

"'스스로 빛나고' '스스로 아는 것'은 현상의 현현을 매개하는 주관적 참조점의 부재를 전달하는 데 사용되는 개념들입니다. 객관적 현상을 '조명'하는 주관적 인지나 아는 이 대신, 우리 인지의 순수한 발현이 항상 그리고 오직 현상 그 자체의 순수한 발현이었다는 것을 깨닫습니다. 또는 오히려 인지와 현상은 그 자체로 어떤 것으로서도 타당하지 않다는 것입니다. 둘 다 단지 조작된 특질이므로, 찾을 때 검증되거나 발견될 수 없습니다. 이것은 주체와 객체의 결합이 아니라, 주체와 객체가 애초에 발생(能生)하지 않았다는 인식입니다 [아드바야, advaya].", "인지는 공(空)합니다. 그것이 마음의 본성[셈니, sems nyid]을 인식한다는 의미입니다. 마음의 명료함[인지]은 공(空)하다고 인식되며, 이는 때때로 명료함과 공의 불가분성, 또는 비이원적 명료함과 공으로 분석됩니다." - 카일 딕슨(Kyle Dixon), 2014

꼬리표: 아나타(Anatta), 비개념성의 질병(Disease of Non-Conceptuality), 비이원(Non Dual) | "


Master Yin Shun: Revealing the Meaning of Emptiness

By

Chinese original from 寶積經講記10 (mahabodhi.org)

English Translation:

Collected Works of Master Yin Shun

Miao Yun Collection, Upper Compilation, Part Two: 'Expository Notes on the Ratnakūṭa Sūtra'

[Return to Main Table of Contents] [Read Next Page] [Read Previous Page]

Original Text:

印順法師佛學著作集

妙雲集上編之二『寶積經講記』

[回總目次][讀取下頁] [讀取前頁]

English Translation:

Second Echelon (戊二): Discerning the Profound Meaning

First Section (己一): Clarifying the Meaning of Emptiness

First Subsection (庚一): Emptiness of Dharmas

『Furthermore, Kāśyapa! One who engages in true contemplation does not, by means of emptiness, make all dharmas empty, but the nature of dharmas is intrinsically empty. One does not, by means of signlessness, make dharmas signless, but dharmas are intrinsically signless. One does not, by means of wishlessness, make dharmas wishless, but dharmas are intrinsically wishless. One does not, by means of non-arising, non-birth, non-grasping, and being without self-nature, make dharmas non-arising, non-grasping, and without self-nature, but dharmas are intrinsically non-arising, non-grasping, and without self-nature. One who contemplates in this way is called [one who engages in] true contemplation.』

Original Text:

戊二 抉擇深義

己一 顯了空義

庚一 法空 『復次,迦葉!真實觀者,不以空故令諸法空,但法性自空。不以無相故令法 無相,但法自無相。不以無願故令法無願,但法自無願。不以無起、無生、無取 、無性故,令法無起、無取、無性,但法自無起、無取、無性。如是觀者,是名 實觀。』

English Translation:

Although the Madhyamaka view has already been taught above, the meaning of emptiness is extremely profound, and it still requires further discernment and clarification to prevent misunderstandings among students. This is further divided into three sections. First, the meaning of emptiness is clarified. Clarification means using language and words to make the meaning of emptiness clearer. This is further explained in terms of the emptiness of dharmas and the emptiness of self.

Original Text:

  上來雖已經開示中觀,但空義是甚深的,還得再加抉擇顯了,以免學者 的誤會。這又分三節,先顯了空義。顯了,是以語言文字,使空義更為明了 ,這又分法空我空來說。

English Translation:

Speaking of this, we should first briefly discuss the distinctions of emptiness. When the Buddha spoke of emptiness, it always pertained to methods of practice, but there are broadly three different types [P116]: First, 'analytical emptiness' (分破空): attaining emptiness through analytical contemplation; in the sūtras, it is called 'dispersing emptiness' (散空), and the Tiantai school calls it 'analytical emptiness' (析空). For example, with material dharmas (色法), one analyzes them part by part until they can no longer be divided, at which point one reaches what is called 'neighboring-emptiness particles' (鄰虛塵), meaning one has reached the verge of emptiness. Proceeding further, the sign of emptiness (空相) will then appear. However, this is an illusory contemplation (假觀) and not a true contemplation (實觀), because such analysis, even if carried down to a ten-millionth or one-hundred-millionth part, still involves existence, still involves materiality. Second, 'contemplation of emptiness' (觀空): for example, the Yogācāra master's mastery in contemplating the mind—when contemplating blue, the sign of blue appears; when contemplating emptiness, the sign of emptiness appears. Because [the appearances] transform according to the mind, they can be known as empty. But this is not yet thorough, because when using the method of contemplating emptiness to contemplate emptiness, the contemplating mind cannot be emptied in any way. In fact, they absolutely do not permit that the mind is also empty. These two kinds of methods were indeed taught by the Buddha and can also dispel many afflictions and distortions, but they are not ultimate. The ultimate is the third, 'emptiness of self-nature' (自性空): it is not that dharmas become empty only after being deconstructed, nor is it that they become empty by transforming with the mind; emptiness is the fundamental nature of all dharmas as such. As the Āgama sūtras also say: "All conditioned phenomena (諸行) are empty: constantly empty... empty of self and what belongs to self; because their nature is intrinsically so (性自爾故)." Therefore, when the Buddha speaks of the emptiness of dharma-nature, it is not about eliminating anything through the power of contemplation, but merely, through contemplation, realizing the original face of all dharmas. It is like the ancient story of 'mistaking the reflection of a bow in a cup for a snake'; because one thought one had swallowed a snake, one became ill with worry and suspicion. Now, if one is made to realize that there was never any snake to begin with, the illness and suffering from worry and suspicion will be cured. Therefore, contemplating emptiness is to dispel delusion and attain the emptiness of the fundamental nature of all dharmas; this is the ultimate meaning of emptiness in Mahāyāna. [P117] Otherwise, sentient beings, bound by emotions and views, cannot thoroughly realize true emptiness and will eventually turn away from emptiness and return to 'existence' (有) to establish themselves and find meaning in life.

Original Text:

  說到這裡,先應略說空的差別。佛說空,都是修行法門,但略有三類不 [P116] 同:一、『分破空』:以分析的觀法來通達空;經中名為散空,天台稱之為 析空。如色法,分分的分析起來,分析到分無可分時,名『鄰虛塵』,即到 了空的邊緣。再進,就有空相現前。但這是假觀而不是實觀,因為這樣的分 析,即使分析到千萬億分之一,也還是有,還是色。二、『觀空』:如瑜伽 師的觀心自在,觀青即青相現前,觀空即空相現前。因為隨心所轉,可知是 空的。但還不徹底,因以觀空的方法來觀空,觀心是怎麼也不能空的。事實 上,他們也決不許心也是空的。這二種法門,佛確也曾說過,也可以祛息許 多煩惱顛倒,但不能究竟,究竟的是第三『自性空』:不是分破了才空,也 不是隨心轉而空;空是一切法的本性如此。如阿含經也說:「諸行空:常空 ……我我所空;性自爾故』。所以,佛說法性空,不是以觀的力量來消滅什 麼,而只是因觀而通達一切法的本來面目。如古人『杯弓蛇影』的故事一樣 ,以為吞了蛇,所以憂疑成病。現在使他自覺到根本沒有蛇,憂疑病苦就好 了。所以,觀空是祛除錯覺,達於一切法的本性空,這才是大乘究竟空義。 [P117] 否則,眾生為情見所縛,不能徹了真空,終於又背空而回到『有』中去安身 立命。

English Translation:

Emptiness is fundamental nature emptiness (本性空), ultimate emptiness (畢竟空) that is free from all conceptual proliferations (戲論). Therefore, to speak of 'emptiness' is to perfectly reveal the Middle Way. However, to adapt to the capacities of beings, it is also spoken of as signlessness (無相) and wishlessness (無願) (anciently translated as 'non-action' 無作); together, these are called the three gates of liberation (三解脫門). Furthermore, it is often said to be non-arising (無起), non-birth (無生) (non-ceasing 無滅), non-grasping (無取), without self-nature (無性), etc., so that sentient beings may all return to the one reality. According to the definitive Mahāyāna teachings, 'emptiness, signlessness, and wishlessness all take reality (實相) as their object.' Being without self-nature, thereby detaching from views, is called emptiness; detaching from signs, thereby ceasing discriminations, is called signlessness; detaching from grasping, thereby ceasing thoughts and aspirations, is called wishlessness. However, it is also permissible to speak from the perspective of predominant aspects: based on 'all dharmas are without self' (諸法無我), it is called emptiness; based on 'Nirvāṇa is quiescent' (涅槃寂靜), it is called signlessness; based on 'all conditioned things are impermanent' (諸行無常), it is called wishlessness. It can also be explained in terms of shallow and profound: by emptying everything, a sign of emptiness (空相) appears (in reality, ultimate emptiness means that even emptiness is unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable), therefore it is called signlessness. Although one realizes that objects are signless, the mind still has attachments, so it is further called wishlessness. But these are all skillful means (方便善巧); the three gates of liberation are equal and of one suchness. 'Arising' (起) is phenomenal arising, 'birth' (生) is arising through production, which is similar to 'arising'; but 'arising' (起) might be deluded, whereas 'birth' (生) is conditioned arising (因緣生). In the original translation [of the sūtra being commented on], after 'non-birth' (無生), there were the two characters 'non-self' (無我). Comparing with other translations, this should be a superfluous addition, so it has been deleted. 'Non-grasping' (無取) means no object of grasping. 'Without nature' (無性) means without self-nature (無自性). Generally speaking, from signlessness to being without nature, [P118] all are different names for emptiness.

Original Text:

  空,是本性空,絕一切戲論的畢竟空,所以說『空』就圓滿的顯示了中 道。但為了適應機宜,又說為無相、無願(古譯為無作),合名三解脫門。 又每說無起、無生(無滅)、無取、無性等,使眾生同歸於一實。依大乘了 義說,『空無相無願,同緣實相』。無自性以離見,名空;離相以息分別, 名無相;離取著以息思願,名無願。但也不妨約偏勝說:依『諸法無我』即 名空,依『涅槃寂靜』即名無相,依『諸行無常』即名無願。也可作淺深說 :空一切而有空相現(其實畢竟空是空也不可得的),所以說無相。雖達境 無相,而心還有所著,所以又說無願。但這都是方便善巧,三解脫門是平等 一如的。起是現起,生是生起,與起相近;但起可能是錯亂,而生是因緣生 。本譯在無生下,還有『無我』二字。參照別譯,這應該是衍文,所以刪去 了。無取,是無所取著。無性,是沒有自性。如總相的說,從無相到無性, [P118] 都是空的異名。

English Translation:

Now, let's explain according to the text. The Buddha said: "Kāśyapa! True contemplation"—the correct contemplation of the Middle Way is like this: it is "not by the contemplative power of emptiness" (空) samādhi that one "makes the" existent nature of "all dharmas" become "empty, but" it is that "the nature of dharmas is intrinsically empty." The fundamental nature is empty; by observing with contemplative insight (觀照), one merely awakens to its original thusness. This is emptiness of fundamental nature, intrinsic emptiness, not emptiness made by another (他空); this is the true and correct contemplation of the Middle Way. From this, it can be seen that contemplation of emptiness, true contemplation, and Madhyamaka contemplation are the same. Similarly, it is "not by the power of signlessness" (無相) samādhi that dharmas are made "signless, but dharmas are intrinsically signless." Also, it is "not by the contemplative power of wishlessness" (無願) that dharmas are made "wishless, but dharmas are intrinsically wishless." Thus, what the Buddha spoke of as "non-arising, non-birth, non-grasping, and without self-nature" are all like this, originally so. To be able to "contemplate thus" the fundamental nature as empty, "this is called true contemplation," and not the gates of contemplation such as analytical emptiness, contemplation of emptiness, or other-emptiness.

Original Text:

  現在依文來解說。佛說:「迦葉!真實觀」──中道正觀是這樣的:並 「不以空」三昧的觀力,「令諸法」的有性成「空,但」是「法性自空」。 本性是空的,以觀照去觀察,只是覺了他的本來如此而已。這是本性空,自 空,不是他空;這才是中道的真實正觀。依此可見,空觀,真實觀,中道觀 ,是一樣的。同樣的,並「不以無相」三昧力,所以諸「法無相,但法自無 相」。也「不以無願」的觀力,所以諸「法無願,但法自無願」。這樣,佛 說的「無起、無生、無取、無性」,都是這樣的本來如此。能「如是觀」本 性空,「是名實觀」,而不是分破空,觀空等他空的觀門。

English Translation:

Second Subsection (庚二): Emptiness of Self

『Furthermore, Kāśyapa! It is not because there is no person that it is called empty, but emptiness [of self] is intrinsically empty. The past is empty, the future is empty, and the present is also empty. One should rely on emptiness, not on a person.』

Original Text:

庚二 人空 『復次,迦葉!非無人故名曰為空,但空自空。前際空,後際空,中際亦空。 當依於空,莫依於人。』

English Translation:

Emptiness of person (人空) is emptiness of self (我空). The meaning of emptiness of self is the same as the emptiness of dharmas discussed above. The Buddha also said: "Kāśyapa! [P119] It is not because there is no person that it is called empty, but emptiness [of self] is intrinsically empty." This means it is not by the power of contemplating non-self (無我觀力 anātman-contemplation) that the person is eliminated and then called empty, but rather that the nature of self (我性) is fundamentally unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable. To explain that this nature of person (self) is fundamentally unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable, it then says: "The past is empty, the future is empty, the present is empty." 際 (jì) means boundary or period. The past period (前際) is the past, extending to the past of the past. The future period (後際) is the future, extending to the future of the future. Between the past and future is called the middle period (中際), which is the present. The person (self) undergoes the cycle of death and rebirth, from past lives to the present, and from the present life to future lives. If the person/self were truly existent, it would certainly be found within these three periods. But upon true observation, the past self is unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable, the present self is unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable, and the future self is also unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable. Seeking the self in the three times, it is unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable; thus it is evident that empty nature inherently means no-self (無我).

Original Text:

  人空,就是我空。我空的意義,與上說的法空一樣。佛又說:「迦葉! [P119] 非無人故名曰為空,但空自空」。這是說,並非以無我觀力,除滅了人才叫 空,而只是我性本來不可得。為了說明這人(我)性本來不可得,所以接著 說:「前際空,後際空,中際空」。際是邊際,前際是過去,一直到過去過 去。後際是未來,一直到未來未來。在過未中間,叫中際,就是現在。人( 我),是死生流轉的,從過去世到現在,又從現生到未來世的。如人我是實 有的,那一定在這三際中。但真實的觀察起來,過去我不可得,現在我不可 得,未來我也不可得。於三世中求我不可得,可見空性是本來無我了。

English Translation:

Most Śrāvakas and some Mahāyāna scholars believe that the emptiness of self and the emptiness of dharmas are different. Therefore, although they may realize the emptiness of self, they may not know the emptiness of dharmas, and even deny the emptiness of dharmas. However, some Śrāvakas and Mahāyāna Madhyamaka practitioners completely disagree with this misunderstanding. The emptiness of self and the emptiness of dharmas only differ in the object upon which the correct contemplation relies; the empty nature (性空) that is illuminated is without difference. For example, with a fire from straw and a fire from coal, regarding the straw and coal that the fire depends on, and the strength of the fire, there may be differences; but regarding the hot nature of fire and its burning function, how can one say there is a difference? Based on this, Śrāvaka teachings often speak of non-self (無我), while Mahāyāna teachings often speak of emptiness (空); these are slight differences in customary terminology, not that the empty nature itself has any difference. According to this correct view, if [P120] a Śrāvaka practitioner realizes the emptiness of self, they may not necessarily go on to contemplate the emptiness of dharmas, but they will definitely not cling to dharmas as truly existent. Because when engaged in true contemplation, however they understand non-self, they will similarly understand the emptiness of dharmas. Conversely, if one clings to dharmas as truly existent and does not believe in the emptiness of dharmas, then they have definitely not truly realized non-self, but are rather arrogant individuals (增上慢人) who merely believe themselves to have attained fruition. Therefore, the Mahāprajñāpāramitā Sūtra clearly states: Srotāpannas (first fruition) and Arhats will definitely believe in and understand the emptiness of dharmas. The Diamond Sūtra even more clearly states: 'If one grasps the sign of dharmas (法相), one thereby clings to a self, a person, a sentient being, and a life-span. If one grasps the sign of non-dharmas (非法相), one thereby clings to a self, a person, a sentient being, and a life-span.' This sūtra (the Ratnakūṭa) explains the emptiness of dharmas based on the emptiness of fundamental nature, and also explains the emptiness of self based on the emptiness of fundamental nature. From this, it can be seen that the correct view of Madhyamaka practitioners is a full understanding of the true meaning of Mahāyāna's correct contemplation.

Original Text:

  多數聲聞及一分大乘學者、以為我空與法空不同,所以雖通達我空,卻 可以不知道法空,甚至否認法空的。但一分聲聞及大乘中觀者,完全不同意 這種誤解。我空及法空,只是正觀所依的對象不同,而照見的性空,並無差 別。如稻草火與煤炭火,約火所依的草及炭說,火力的強弱說,雖有不同; 而約火熱性,燒用說,怎能說有不同?依此,聲聞法多說無我,大乘法多說 空,是習用的名詞多少不同,而非性空有什麼不同。據這樣的正見來說,如 [P120] 聲聞者證得我空,他可以不再觀法空,但決不會執法實有。因為如作真實觀 時,他怎樣了解無我,就會同樣的了解法空。反之,如執法實有,不信法空 ,那他決沒有真正通達無我,而是增上慢人,自以為證果而已。所以大般若 經明說:須陀洹(初果)及阿羅漢,一定會信解法空的。金剛經更顯然說: 『若取法相,即著我人眾生壽者。若取非法相,即著我人眾生壽者』。本經 依本性空明法空,也依本性空來明人空,這可見中觀者的正見,是充分了解 大乘正觀的真義。

English Translation:

Finally, the Buddha also said: "One should rely on emptiness, not on a person." These two sentences seem very abrupt, but are in fact extremely important! The 'emptiness' here refers to empty nature (空性) (the sign of emptiness 空相, thusness 真如, etc.). The correct contemplation taught by the Buddha must be cultivated and realized by relying on this empty nature; one must absolutely not rely on a 'person' for faith, understanding, cultivation, and realization. Originally, Indian Brahmanism believed that to attain liberation, one must possess the wisdom of a true self (真我). Only by realizing the true self can one attain liberation. The distinctive teaching of Śākyamuni Buddha is the complete negation of this metaphysical theory of a true self. He consistently taught: 'Because of impermanence, there is suffering; because of suffering, there is non-self (無我); because of non-self, there is nothing belonging to a self (無我所); thus, Nirvāṇa is attained.' In other words, only by thoroughly seeing through the illusion of a true, permanent self can one attain liberation. Therefore, at the time of direct realization (現證) by Buddha's disciples, [P121] it is often said: 'Knowing the Dharma, entering the Dharma, one sees only the Dharma, not the self.' The Dharma is the true Dharma (Sublime Dharma, i.e., Dharma-nature 法性, Nirvāṇa); in the realization of awakening, one directly experiences the true Dharma, and fundamentally there is no self to be seen or obtained. Ordinary Buddhist students, not knowing what the 'self' of the non-Buddhists (外道) is like, assume that what they cultivate and realize is different from the 'self' of the non-Buddhists. Actually, the difference in cultivation and realization between Buddhism and non-Buddhist paths (non-Buddhists also have practices, religious experiences, and also believe themselves to have attained awakening and liberation) is very subtle in its explanation. For example, if one says that one has directly experienced: the true, the permanent, the pure, the blissful, the unborn and unceasing, the non-dual and non-differentiated, the inconceivable. The meanings of these phrases all make it difficult to show the difference between non-Buddhist paths and Buddhadharma. However, with such an experience, non-Buddhists will definitely say, this is the true self (or call it God). This is to say, it has a volitional nature. Therefore, they describe their own religious experience as a life-subject, absolutely subjective; or deify it as the true ruler of the universe—such as Jehovah, Brahmā, etc. But the experience of Buddha's disciples is different from that of non-Buddhists; it is 'seeing only the Dharma, not seeing a person/self.' Therefore, in conventional designations and explanations, although it is said that [reality and] wisdom are non-dual (如智不二), it is only spoken of as the nature of all dharmas, unborn and unceasing, and is not endowed with volitional characteristics; naturally, it is not called a true self, nor imagined as a creator God. When this sūtra explains that the nature of self is fundamentally empty, it specially states: 'One should rely on emptiness, not on a person/self'—this is truly of utmost importance! However, sentient beings since beginningless time have had their minds permeated by self-view (我見), so it is [P122] inevitable that even some Buddhist disciples are still [trying to] directly experience a true self, believing themselves to have reached the ultimate!

Original Text:

  末了,佛又說:「當依於空,莫依於人」。這兩句,似乎很突然,但實 在非常重要!這裡的空,是空性(空相、真如等)。佛所開示的正觀,要依 此空性而修證,切莫依人而信解修證。原來印度的婆羅門教,以為要得解脫 ,非有真我的智慧不可。能通達真我,才能得解脫。釋迦佛的特法,就是全 盤否定了這種形而上的真我論。始終說:『無常故苦,苦故無我,無我故無 我所,則得涅槃』。換言之,非徹底照破了真常我,才能解脫。所以在佛弟 [P121] 子的現證時,每說:『知法、入法,但見於法,不見於我』。法是正法(妙 法,即法性,涅槃),在覺證中,但是體見正法,根本沒有我可見可得。一 般學佛者,不知外道的我是怎樣的,就自以為所修所證,與外道的我不同; 其實,佛與外道的修證(外道也有修行,宗教經驗,也自以為證悟得解脫的 )不同,在說明上是很希微的。如說:體見到:真的、常的、清淨的、安樂 的、不生不滅的、無二無別的、不可思議的。這些句義,都難於顯出外道與 佛法的不同。但這樣的經驗,外道一定說,這是真我(或者說是神)。這是 說,這是有意志性的。所以把自己的宗教經驗,描寫為生命主體,絕對主觀 ;或者神化為宇宙的真宰──耶和華、梵天等。但佛弟子的體驗,與外道不 同,是『但見於法,不見於人』的。所以在世俗的安立說明中,雖說如智不 二,而但說為一切法性,不生不滅,而沒有給與意志的特性,當然也不稱為 真我,不想像為創造神了。本經在說明我性本空時,特別說到:『當依於空 ,莫依於人』,真是切要之極!不過,眾生從無始以來,我見熏心,所以也 [P122]

不免有佛弟子,還在體見真我,自以為究竟呢!

English Translation:

Second Section (己二): Dispelling Emotional and Conceptual Fabrications

First Subsection (庚一): Grasping the Sign of Perfected Reality

『If, by attaining emptiness, one then relies on emptiness, this is a regression in the Buddhadharma. Thus, Kāśyapa! It is better to give rise to a self-view piled up as high as Mount Sumeru, than to develop arrogance based on a view of emptiness. Why is this? All views are liberated through emptiness. If one gives rise to a view of emptiness [as a thing to be clung to], then it cannot be eliminated.』

Original Text:

己二 遣除情計

庚一 取圓成實相 『若以得空便依於空,是於佛法則為退墮。如是迦葉!寧起我見積若須彌,非 以空見起增上慢。所以者何?一切諸見,以空得脫,若起空見,則不可除。』

English Translation:

In the cultivation and study of the correct contemplation of the Middle Way, if one is not skillful, whether one clings to emptiness or is attached to existence, both are not in accord with the Middle Way. Therefore, the Buddha uses parables to speak—about dispelling emotional attachments by means of the three natures (三性). First, it speaks of grasping the sign of perfected reality (圓成實相).

Original Text:

  於中道正觀的修學,如不能善巧,或執空,或著有,都是不契中道的。 所以佛舉譬喻來說──約三性以遣情執。先說取圓成實相。

English Translation:

The perfected reality (圓成實相 pariniṣpanna-svabhāva) is precisely the emptiness of dharmas (法空) (Thusness 真如, Dharma-nature 法性, etc.). In the past, there were two schools: 'the twofold emptiness is itself the truth (真)' and 'the truth is what is revealed by the twofold emptiness.' In the sūtras, the Buddha sometimes calls it emptiness (空), sometimes empty nature (空性), or the sign of emptiness (空相); therefore, from the perspective of conventional designation and speech, these are all acceptable. Emptiness has the function of detaching from emotional clinging. However, if one exclusively takes negation (遮破) as emptiness, that is incorrect, because emptiness also implies that which is revealed through negation. But the nature revealed by emptiness is absolutely free from all conceptual proliferations (戲論 prapañca), transcending relative and dependent designations. What can it be called? Although it is not inappropriate to 'use provisional terms to detach from clinging, calling it 'existence' (有),' this is ultimately in accordance with the conventional. 'Using provisional terms to detach from clinging, calling it 'emptiness' (空),' isn't this more in accordance with the ultimate truth (勝義)? Therefore, the different explanations of 'the twofold emptiness is itself the truth' and 'the truth is what is revealed by the twofold emptiness' [P123] can be explained according to the Saṃdhinirmocana Sūtra: For people who are complete in the five aspects,<sup>1</sup> the Buddha directly teaches the emptiness of being without self-nature (無自性空), non-arising and non-ceasing, to inspire their contemplative practice to enter into self-realization; [for them,] emptiness is in accordance with the ultimate truth. But for people who are not complete in the five aspects, to lead them to generate an understanding of emptiness, so they do not fear emptiness or cling one-sidedly to emptiness, [the Buddha] therefore accords with convention and speaks of the nature revealed by emptiness (空所顯性).

Original Text:

  圓成實相,就是法空(真如、法性等)。古來有『二空即真』,『二空 所顯』二宗。佛在經中,或稱為空,或稱為空性,空相,所以在安立言說邊 ,這都是可以的。空以離情執為用,但如專以遮破為空,那是不對的,因為 空也意味那因遮而顯的。但空所顯性,是絕無戲論的,超越相待安立的,能 稱之為什麼呢!雖不妨『離執寄詮,稱之為有』,但到底是順於世俗的。『 寄詮離執,稱之為空』,不更順於勝義嗎?所以二空即真,及二空所顯的不 [P123] 同說明,可依解深密經來解說:為五事具足的人,佛直說無自性空,不生不 滅,策發觀行以趣入自證,空是順於勝義的。但為五事不具足的人,使他引 生空解,不致於畏空及偏執空,所以順俗而說空所顯性。

Footnotes/Annotations:

<sup>1</sup> "Complete in the five aspects" (五事具足 wǔ shì jùzú) refers to individuals possessing the necessary faculties or conditions conducive to understanding profound Dharma, such as the five spiritual faculties (pañca indriyāṇi): faith (信 śraddhā), vigor (進 vīrya), mindfulness (念 smṛti), concentration (定 samādhi), and wisdom (慧 prajñā).

English Translation:

Regardless of whether 'the twofold emptiness is itself the truth' or 'the nature revealed by emptiness,' if one grasps and clings to the perfected-reality-emptiness (圓成實空) (or empty nature 空性), then the fault is extremely great! Therefore, following on from the [teaching of] the intrinsic emptiness of self and dharmas, the Buddha said: "If, by attaining emptiness, one then relies on (clings to) emptiness, this is a regression in the Buddhadharma." 'Attaining emptiness' (得空) means there is an emptiness that can be obtained or realized. 'Relying on emptiness' (依空) here means clinging to emptiness (this is different in meaning from the 'rely on emptiness' [當依於空] in the previous passage). This means: when a practitioner is in non-discriminating contemplation (無分別觀), the signs of arising and ceasing (生滅相) cease, and a sign of emptiness (空相) appears. If one takes this as the realization of the perfected reality (圓成實相), then that is mistaken! Furthermore, for those who cultivate non-discriminating concentration (無分別定), directly detaching from all thoughts (念), a sign of emptiness (空相) appears. At that time, it is like empty space, bright and pure, tranquil and clear; one feels an ethereal emptiness (空靈), clarity (明顯), and bliss (安樂), and then grasps and clings to it. This, with regard to the Buddhadharma, not only obstructs further progress but also leads to regression. Because if one clings to such a contemplative (or meditative) state for a long time, the diligent and courageous mind will gradually be lost, and one will pass this life in a dazed and unproductive state (兀兀騰騰). Some even fail to distinguish between good and evil, and still consider themselves to have realized the sameness of Buddha and Māra!

Original Text:

  不問是二空即真,空所顯性,如於圓成實空(或空性)而有所取著,那 過失是非常大的!所以佛承上我法自性空而說:「若以得空,便依於空,是 於佛法則為退墮」。得空,是有空可得可證。依空,是依著於空(這與上文 『但依於空』的依義不同)。這是說:行者在無分別觀中,生滅相息而空相 現。如以此為證得圓成實相,那就錯了!還有,修無分別定的,直下離一切 念,有空相現。那時,如虛空明淨,湛然皎潔;自覺得空靈,明顯,安樂, 就於中取著。這對於佛法,不但障礙了進修,而且還要退失。因為這樣的觀 (或定)境,如取著久了,勤勇心就漸漸失去,兀兀騰騰,了此一生。有的 善惡不分,還自以為佛魔一如呢!

English Translation:

The fault of clinging to the sign of emptiness (空相) is too great, so the Buddha instructed Kāśyapa, saying: 'It is "better" to give "rise to a self-view (我見), accumulated" [P124] as high "as Mount Sumeru," than "to develop arrogance based on a view of emptiness (空見)."' Not having attained, not having realized, yet believing oneself to have attained and realized, is called arrogance (增上慢). Grasping the sign of emptiness is a view of emptiness (空見), and mistakenly taking this view of emptiness as the realization of the perfected-reality-emptiness (圓成實空) is such a grave error! Such a comparison of gain and loss is not an exaggeration. Because with self-view, although one cannot attain liberation, it does not prevent one from extensively cultivating wholesome karma leading to rebirth as humans or devas. But clinging to emptiness leads to no longer being courageous in doing good, and ultimately to regression. Moreover, no matter how great the self-view is, it can still be transformed and eradicated by emptiness, leading to the self-realization of emptiness. But a view of emptiness [as a thing to be clung to] cannot [be so easily dealt with], because "all views are liberated through emptiness (空)," which means detaching from all views through the contemplation of emptiness (空觀). If one misunderstands the Buddhadharma and perversely gives "rise to a view of emptiness [as a thing to be clung to], then it cannot be eliminated." Having already clung to emptiness, one certainly cannot use emptiness again to transform and release it. Nor can one use [a view of] existence (有) to resolve the view of emptiness; existence would only further increase emotional clinging. Therefore, Nāgārjuna's Madhyamakaśāstra (中觀論), based on this, states: 'The Tathāgata teaches the Dharma of emptiness in order to enable detachment from all views. If one furthermore entertains a view of [there being] emptiness, such a person is unteachable by all Buddhas.'<sup>2</sup> Piṅgala's (青目) commentary uses an analogy: water can extinguish fire, but if fire arises within the water itself, then there is no way to extinguish it.<sup>3</sup>

Original Text:

  執著空相的過失太大了,所以佛開示迦葉說:「寧」可生「起我見,積 [P124] 」聚得「若須彌」山那樣,也決「非以空見起增上慢」。沒有得,沒有證, 自以為得了證了,叫增上慢。取著空相是空見,而誤取空見為證得圓成實空 ,那是何等的錯誤!這樣的比較得失,並非過甚其辭。因為有了我見,雖不 能解脫,但不妨廣修人天善業。而執空是不再勇於為善,終歸於退失。而且 ,我見無論怎麼大,還可以空來化導破除,引入空的自證。空見卻不行了, 因為「一切諸見,以空得(解)脫」,也就是以空觀而離一切見。如錯會佛 法,而顛倒的生「起空見,則不可除」了。已經著空,當然不能再以空來化 導解除。也不能以有來解除空見,有只是更增長情執而已。所以龍樹中觀論 ,據此而說:『如來說空法,為離諸見故。若復見有空,諸佛所不化」。青 目釋比喻為:水能滅火,如水中又起火,就無法可滅了。

Footnotes/Annotations:

<sup>2</sup> This quote is from Nāgārjuna's Mūlamadhyamakakārikā (Fundamental Verses on the Middle Way), Chapter 13, Verse 8: "The victorious ones have proclaimed emptiness as the relinquishing of all views. Those who hold emptiness as a view are said to be incurable." ( सर्वदृष्टिप्रहाणाय यः सद्धर्ममदेशयत् । अनुकम्पामुपादाय तं नमस्यामि गौतमम् ॥ śūnyatā sarvadṛṣṭīnāṃ proktā niḥsaraṇaṃ jinaiḥ yeṣāṃ tu śūnyatādṛṣtis tān asādhyān babhāṣire ||). The Chinese translation provided is slightly different but conveys the same meaning.

<sup>3</sup> Piṅgala (青目 Qīngmù) was a commentator on Nāgārjuna's Mūlamadhyamakakārikā. This analogy is found in his commentary on the aforementioned verse.

English Translation:

Madhyamaka and Yogācāra masters, regarding the appearance of the sign of emptiness (空相現前), both do not permit it to be grasped or attained. When the noble ones (聖者 ārya) of the Two Vehicles realize emptiness, that is unblemished prajñā (無漏般若), directly realizing (現證) the non-discriminating Dharma-nature (無分別法性); even more so, one cannot speak of grasping or clinging. Therefore, those who [believe there is] an emptiness that can be obtained, and who cling to emptiness, are arrogant individuals (增上慢人) who are cultivating contemplation or concentration but lack skillful means (方便). [P125]

Original Text:

  中觀與瑜伽論師,對於空相現前,都不許為可取可得的。二乘聖者證空 ,那是無漏般若,現證無分別法性,更不能說取著。所以有空可得,依著於 空的,那是修觀或修定,而沒有方便的增上慢人。 [P125]

English Translation: [Continued from previous message]

The Tathāgata again uses a parable to illustrate the fault of clinging to emptiness: "Kāśyapa! Suppose a physician administers medicine" for a patient to take. Due to the medicine's strength, it "causes the illness to be agitated"; influenced by the medicine's power, the severity of the illness is reduced, and the patient gradually recovers. Suppose those "medicines" that are continually taken remain "inside and are not" expelled. Kāśyapa! Do you think "this patient's" illness could possibly be completely cured? "差 (chài)," same as 瘥 (chài), means the illness is cured. Kāśyapa said to the Buddha: No, it won't. "If the medicine is not expelled," "their illness" not only will not get better but will instead "worsen." This is called 'the old illness is not yet cured, and the medicine itself turns into an illness.' Having said this, the Buddha then applied the parable, saying: "Thus, Kāśyapa, all views can only be extinguished by emptiness," just as all illnesses can only be cured by taking medicine. "If one gives rise to a view of emptiness [as a thing to be clung to], then it cannot be eliminated," just like medicine remaining in the body without being expelled, causing side effects and worsening the illness instead; then it becomes incurable.

Original Text:   如來又舉譬喻來說明著空的過失:「迦葉!譬如醫師,授藥」給病人服 下。由於藥力,「令病擾動」;受藥力影響,減殺病勢而逐漸好轉。假使不 斷服下的那些「藥」,一直「在內而不」排洩「出」來。迦葉!你以為「是 病人」的病,可能會全愈嗎?「差」,與瘥同,是病好了的意思。迦葉對佛 說:不會的。「是藥不出」來,「其病」不但不會好,反而要「轉增」的。 這就叫『舊病未愈,藥反成病』了。說到這裡,佛才合譬喻說:「如是迦葉 ,一切諸見,唯空能滅」,如一切病,唯有服藥才能治愈一樣。「若起空見 ,則不可除」,如藥留在體內不出來,起副作用,反而增病一樣,那才無藥 可治了。

English Translation: Second Subsection (庚二): Fear of the Emptiness of the Dependent Nature [P126] 『Suppose there is a person who is terrified of empty space, wailing<sup>1</sup> and beating their chest, saying these words: "I want to abandon empty space!" What do you think? Can this empty space be abandoned or left behind?』 『No, World-Honored One!』 『Thus, Kāśyapa! If someone fears the Dharma of emptiness, I say this person is crazed and has lost their mind. Why is this? They constantly function within emptiness yet are afraid of emptiness.』

Original Text: 庚二 怖依他性空 [P126] 『譬如有人怖畏虛空,悲!2筥椎胸,作如是言:我捨虛空。於意云何?是虛空者 可捨離不』?『不也,世尊』!『如是迦葉!若畏空法,我說是人狂亂失心。所 以者何?常行空中而畏於空。』 Footnotes/Annotations: <sup>1</sup> The original text has "悲!2筥椎胸". The character "筥" (jǔ) means a round bamboo basket. Based on the context and common expressions of distress, "!2筥" is likely a corruption of "號" (háo), meaning "to wail" or "cry loudly". The commentary later confirms this interpretation by stating "與號同" (same as 號).

English Translation: The sign of dependent arising (依他起相 paratantra-lakṣaṇa) is dependently arisen dharmas (因緣所生法 pratītyasamutpanna-dharma). (Yogācāra scholars, who take Mind-Only (唯識 Vijñaptimātra) as their tenet, say that dependent arising refers to mind and mental factors 心心所法 citta-caitta). "Dependently arisen dharmas, I say are ultimately empty (畢竟空 atyanta-śūnya)." This is stated in the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra (華手經 Huāshǒu jīng)<sup>2</sup> and expresses the essential meaning of Mahāyāna sūtras such as the Prajñāpāramitā. Here, one should distinguish: First, if one says that dependently arisen dharmas are empty and thereby completely negates dependently arisen dharmas, thinking them to be like turtle hair or rabbit horns, that is the deluded clinging of the Vaipulya practitioners (方廣道人)—those who advocate the emptiness of mere names (空假名論者). Second, if one says that the dharma-nature (法性) of dependent arising is empty, but the signs/characteristics of dependently arisen dharmas (緣起法相) are not empty, that is [the view of] those who advocate that mere names are not empty (假名不空論者). The former is the 'going too far' faction, the latter is the 'not going far enough' faction. The ultimate, definitive meaning of emptiness is: dependently arisen dharmas are merely designated names (假名 prajñapti), therefore they are ultimately empty; but ultimate emptiness does not obstruct dependently arisen phenomena [from appearing] like illusions (如幻 māyopama). This is the Middle Way where emptiness and existence are non-obstructing. However, from some Hīnayāna to some Mahāyāna schools (those close to the 'non-emptiness' proponents), all find that 'hearing of ultimate emptiness is like a knife stabbing the heart,' difficult to endure. Because according to the views of these substantialists (實有論者), 'the illusory must depend on the real (假必依實)'; how can one say that everything is merely a designated name, ultimately empty? If everything is merely illusory/designated, then everything is empty, which means everything is non-existent (they take emptiness to mean nothingness), then even designated names would not be possible! Since one cannot say [P127] that everything is merely a designated name, then naturally, what is established by designated names, being without self-nature (無自性), can be said to be empty; but that which is established by its own characteristics (自相安立) and exists, cannot be said to be empty. Therefore, they fear true emptiness and go against true emptiness. Or they revise the teaching of true emptiness, saying: that all dharmas are empty is not the definitive meaning (不了義 neyārtha); in reality, some things are empty, and some things are not empty. In [the view of] everything being merely designated names, everything being ultimately empty, they feel they have no ground to stand on and cannot establish any dharmas of saṃsāra or Nirvāṇa. Therefore, they insist on seeking something non-empty outside of emptiness in order to establish saṃsāra and Nirvāṇa, and in order to give rise to the aspiration to practice and proceed towards the Buddhist path. Sentient beings have always been obscured by the view of self-nature (自性見), and thus have always loved existence and hated emptiness. For these people (those not complete in the five aspects), the Buddha sometimes has no choice but to use skillful means (方便 upāya) and provisional teachings (假說), concealing emptiness and speaking of existence, in order to guide and transform them.

Original Text:   依他起相,就是因緣所生法(唯識學者以唯識為宗,所以說依他起是心 心所法)。『因緣所生法,我說畢竟空』,是華手經所說,而表達了般若等 大乘經的要義。這裡,應該分別:一、如說緣起法空,而徹底否定了緣起法 ,以為如龜毛兔角那樣,那是方廣道人──空假名論者的妄執。二、如說緣 起的法性空,而緣起法相不空,那是假名不空論者。前是太過派,這是不及 派。空的究竟了義是:緣起法唯是假名,所以是畢竟空;但畢竟空不礙緣起 如幻,才是空有無礙的中道。然而從小乘到一分大乘(近於不空論者),都 是『聞畢竟空,如刀傷心』,難以忍受的。因為照這些實有論者的見地,『 假必依實』,怎麼能說一切都是假名,畢竟空呢!如一切唯假,也就一切皆 空,那一切都沒有(他們是以空為沒有的)了,假名也不可能呀!既不能說 [P127] 一切唯假名,當然假名安立的,沒有自性,可以說空,而自相安立的有,不 可以說空了。所以他們怖畏真空,違逆真空。或者修正真空說:一切法空, 是不了義的;其實某些是空的,某些是不空的。在一切唯假名,一切畢竟空 中,他們就感到沒有著落,不能成立生死涅槃一切法。所以非要在空的以外 ,求到一些不空的,才能成立生死與涅槃,才能發心修行而向佛道。眾生一 向為自性見所蒙昧,也就一向是愛有惡空。佛對於這些(五事不具足的), 有時也不得不方便假說,隱空說有,以化導他們呢! Footnotes/Annotations: <sup>2</sup> The phrase "因緣所生法,我說畢竟空" (Dependently arisen dharmas, I say are ultimately empty) is a well-known formulation closely associated with Nāgārjuna and Madhyamaka philosophy, appearing in works like the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā. While "華手經" (Huāshǒu Jīng, literally "Flower-Hand Sūtra") can sometimes refer to the Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra or the Hastikakṣyā Sūtra (Elephant's Armpit Sūtra), pinpointing the exact sūtra Master Yin Shun refers to here for this specific phrasing would require further research into his works. The Vimalakīrti Nirdeśa Sūtra does discuss emptiness extensively. The core idea is central to Prajñāpāramitā literature.

English Translation: For such practitioners who fear that dependently arisen dharmas are ultimately of an empty nature, and who wish to seek something non-empty outside of emptiness, the Buddha, from the standpoint of the ultimate, definitive meaning, rebukes them with a parable, saying: 'Suppose there is a person who is terrified of empty space,' wailing loudly (悲號 bēiháo, as confirmed by the commentary '與號同' - same as 號), beating their 'chest with their hands, and saying these words: I' want to 'abandon empty space,' and go to a place where there is no empty space. The Buddha asked Kāśyapa: What do you think? 'Can this empty space be abandoned or left behind?' Kāśyapa said: 'No,' it is not possible. Empty space pervades all places; it is a characteristic of material existence. Wherever there is matter, there is empty space. How can one leave empty space and go to a place where there is no empty space? Then the Buddha applied the Dharma to the parable, saying: 'Thus, [P128] Kāśyapa!' Those who hear that all dharmas are ultimately empty and are 'afraid of the Dharma of emptiness,' insisting on establishing all dharmas in something non-empty—are they not like this foolish person who wants to escape from empty space? 'I say this person'—one who cannot accept with faith and patience that all dharmas are ultimately empty, but wants to establish something non-empty—is a 'crazed and deranged' neurotic! This is a person who has been obscured by the view of self-nature (自性見) since beginningless time and lacks correct knowledge and views (正知見). Why is this said? That all dharmas are ultimately empty is the fundamental nature of all dharmas. Sentient beings since beginningless time—whether giving rise to delusion, creating karma, receiving retribution, or even giving rise to aspiration and cultivating practice—everything has always been ultimately empty. They have always 'constantly functioned within emptiness,' illusorily arising and illusorily ceasing without knowing it themselves, yet instead, they 'are afraid of emptiness' and seek to obtain non-empty dharmas. Is this not being inverted and having lost one's mind?

Original Text:   像這種怖畏因緣生法,畢竟性空,而想在空外別求不空的行人,佛在究 竟了義的立場,以譬喻來呵斥他們說:「譬如有人,怖畏虛空」,大聲「悲 !2筥」(與號同),以手自己「椎胸,而作是言:我」要「捨虛空」,而到沒 有虛空的所在。佛問迦葉:你覺得怎樣?「是虛空可捨離」嗎?迦葉說:「 不」可能的。虛空遍一切處,是物質存在的特性;那裡有物質,那裡就有虛 空,怎麼能離卻虛空,而到沒有虛空的所在呢!佛這才以法合譬說:「如是 [P128] 迦葉」!那些聽說一切法畢竟空,怖「畏空法」,一定要在不空中安立一切 法的,不就像這想逃避虛空的愚人嗎?「我說是人」──不能信忍一切法畢 竟空,而要安立不空的人,是「狂亂失心」的神經病者!是為無始以來,自 性見所蒙昧,而沒有正知見的人。為什麼這樣說呢?一切法畢竟空,是一切 法的本性如此。眾生無始以來,起惑也好,造業也好,受報也好,就是發心 也好,修行也好,什麼都從來就是畢竟空的。一向「常行空中」,幻生幻滅 而不自知,反「而畏於空」,要求得不空法,這不是顛倒失心嗎?

English Translation:

[Continued from previous message]

Third Subsection (庚三): Clinging to What is Merely Conceived as Existent

『Suppose a painter, with his own hands, paints an image of a yakṣa ghost. Having seen it, he becomes terrified, faints, and falls to the ground. All ordinary beings (凡夫 pṛthagjana) are also like this. Because they themselves create forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and tangible objects, they transmigrate through birth and death, experiencing all kinds of suffering, without self-awareness [of the true nature of things].』

Original Text:

庚三 著遍計執有 『譬如畫師,自手畫作夜叉鬼像,見已怖畏,迷悶躄地。一切凡夫亦復如是, 自造色、聲、香、味、觸故,往來生死,受諸苦惱,而不自覺。』

English Translation:

To illustrate the deluded clinging of sentient beings to what is merely conceived (遍計 parikalpita), the parable of painting a ghost is told. "Suppose a painter, with his own hands, paints an image of a yakṣa ghost." A yakṣa is a swift and powerful ghost, with a very ferocious appearance. But since he painted it himself, no matter what, he should not be afraid of it. However, sentient beings are foolish! Because the painting is so lifelike, it looks just like a real [P129] one. When he "sees" it himself, he cannot help but be moved. The more he looks, the more afraid he becomes, until he is "terrified," faints from fright, and "falls" "to the ground." This is truly pitiful! "All ordinary beings are also like this," pitiful! They themselves give rise to delusions and create karma, thereby incurring this current body and mind, as well as various external sense objects. These are all "self-created" "forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and tangible objects," etc. These illusorily arisen dharmas, conditioned by karma, are by fundamental nature empty and quiescent (空寂). But due to the permeation of past deluded clinging, when they arise, they appear to have a self-nature (so some scholars say they are established by their own characteristics 自相安立) – which is precisely a deluded, conceptually proliferated sign (戲論相). Internally, the sensory faculties and body, and externally, the sense objects, also truly seem as if they are real; in the perception of sentient beings, they are naturally and intuitively taken as real, as not empty. Therefore, they further give rise to deluded clinging, grasping them as truly existent. The more they grasp, the more deluded they become, continuously creating karma and receiving its retribution. Alas! Birth and death are fundamentally of empty nature, yet sentient beings "transmigrate through birth and death," unable to end birth and death. Forms, sounds, etc., are fundamentally of empty nature, yet sentient beings are bound by the signs of objects, and thus in this life and future lives, they continuously "experience all kinds of suffering." Within this illusory, ultimate emptiness, they suffer endlessly, are born endlessly, "without self-awareness" that [all this] is of empty nature and that they can attain liberation from emptiness. Isn't this just like that painter who painted the ghost?

Original Text:

  為了顯示眾生的遍計妄執,所以又說畫鬼喻。「譬如畫師,自手畫作夜 叉鬼像」。夜叉,是捷疾有力的大力鬼,相貌非常兇惡。但是自己畫的,無 論怎麼樣,也不應該怕他。可是眾生是愚癡的!由於畫得太像了,活像是真 [P129] 的一樣。自己「見」了,也不免動心。越看越怕,竟然「怖畏」起來,嚇得 昏迷過去,「迷悶躄」倒在「地」。這真太可憐了!「一切凡夫,亦復如是 」可憐!自己起惑造業,招感到這一期身心,以及外在的種種塵境。這都是 「自造」的「色、聲、香、味、觸」等。從業所感的如幻緣起法,本性空寂 。但由於過去的妄執熏習,生起時有自性相現(所以一分學者,說是自相安 立),就是錯亂的戲論相。內而根身,外而塵境,也真活像是實有的;在眾 生的認識中,自然的直覺為實有的,不空的。因此更起妄執,執為實有,愈 執愈迷,一直造業受報下去。唉!生死本來性空,而眾生卻「往來生死」, 生死不了。色聲等本來性空,而眾生為境相所縛,於是今生後世,不斷的「 受諸苦惱」。在如幻畢竟空中,苦苦不已,生生不已,「而不自覺」為性空 ,從空得解脫,這豈不像那畫鬼的畫師嗎?

English Translation:

Third Section (己三): Skillful Wisdom and Severance

First Subsection (庚一): Wisdom [P130]

Original Text:

己三 善巧智斷

庚一 智 [P130]

English Translation:

First Echelon (辛一): Contemplating Both Subject and Object as Empty

『Suppose a magician, having created illusory people, then himself harms and devours them. A monastic practitioner is also like this: whatever dharma is contemplated is all empty, all quiescent, without any solidity; that contemplation is also empty.』

Original Text:

辛一 觀俱境空 『譬如幻師,作幻人已,還自殘食。行道比丘亦復如是,有所觀法,皆空皆寂 無有堅固,是觀亦空。』

English Translation:

After proclaiming and clarifying the empty nature and refuting emotional and conceptual fabrications, the Tathāgata then speaks on the topic of skillful wisdom and severance. This is because dispelling clinging and revealing emptiness cannot be accomplished without wisdom. With wisdom, one can certainly sever delusions and karma. However, sentient beings have shallow wisdom and meager blessings; regarding wisdom and severance, they also lack skillfulness and are prone to distorted clinging, which contravenes the profound meaning of the Buddha's teaching. Therefore, a clear discernment is also indispensable.

Original Text:

  在宣說顯了空性,遮遣情計以後,如來又接著說善巧智斷一科。因為遣 執顯空,是非智慧不辦的。有了智慧,就一定能斷除惑業。但眾生的智淺福 薄,對於智與斷,也不能善巧,易於顛倒執著,違害了佛的深義,所以也非 明確的抉擇不可。

English Translation:

First, let us speak of wisdom. The directly realized wisdom of thusness (如實智) arises from contemplative insight (觀慧), which means that the prajñā of the true aspect (實相般若) arises from the prajñā of contemplative illumination (觀照般若). Ordinary foolish people who do not understand the meaning of emptiness have two great deluded attachments concerning this issue. First, some believe that the contemplated object is empty, but the contemplating mind is not empty. They say: Contemplating all dharmas as empty, all dharmas are empty, but one surely cannot say that the contemplating mind is also empty! If contemplative insight were also empty, then there would be no contemplative insight, and thus no contemplation. In this way, they establish the theory that the mind exists while objects are empty (心有境空論). This is like the Western philosopher Descartes, who initially doubted everything but finally felt that the 'I' who doubts is ultimately indubitable. If 'I' were also doubtable, then one could not doubt everything. [P131] Thus, he established his philosophy on the reality of 'I think, therefore I am' (我思故我在). Such understanding entirely follows the thought patterns of the world and does not accord with the profound meaning of the Buddha's transcendent, liberating Dharma. To refute this deluded attachment that objects are empty but the mind is not, a parable is given: "Suppose a magician," using spells and the like, conjures "illusory" "people," lions, tigers, etc. Although these are all illusory, empty in nature and without reality, yet they "still harm" and devour "each other." Illusion harms illusion, illusion devours illusion, and all returns to unobtainability/unfindability/ungraspability. "A monastic practitioner (行道比丘) is also like this." The monastic is like the magician; the contemplated object and the contemplating mind that arise are like the illusory people, tigers, etc. This contemplating subject and contemplated object are all illusory and empty in nature. Therefore, it is said: whatever "dharma is contemplated, all" are by nature "empty," "quiescent," and "without any solidity"; the "contemplation is also empty." Although everything is illusory and empty in nature, the contemplated object and the contemplating subject are all established. Therefore, with contemplative insight that is itself empty, one contemplates the objective realm that is itself empty; the object is empty and quiescent, and the contemplation is also empty and quiescent. How then can one perversely cling to the object as empty but the contemplating mind as not empty? The main root of this attachment is still the belief that emptiness means non-existence; if it is non-existence, how can one contemplate? Not understanding the meaning of emptiness, deluded attachments thus arise.

Original Text:

  先說智。現證的如實智,從觀慧生,也就是從觀照般若而起現證的實相 般若。一般不明空義的凡愚,對這問題,起二大妄執。第一、有的以為:所 觀境是空的,觀心是不空的。他們說:觀一切法空,一切法是空的,但總不 能說觀心也是空呀!如觀慧也是空的,那就沒有觀慧,也就不能觀了。這樣 ,他們成立心有境空論。這如西哲笛卡兒一樣,起初懷疑一切,而最後覺得 ,能懷疑的我,到底是不容懷疑的。如我也是可懷疑的,那就不能懷疑一切 [P131] 了。這樣,他又從『我思故我在』的實在上,建立他的哲學。這樣的理解, 盡是世間的思想路數,與佛出世解脫的深義不合。為了破斥這境空心不空的 妄執,所以舉喻說:「譬如幻師」,以咒術等,變化「作幻」化的「人」、 獅、虎等。這些雖都是幻化的,性空無實的,但彼此卻「還自殘」害,噉「 食」。以幻害幻,以幻食幻,而歸於不可得。這樣「行道比丘,亦復如是」 。比丘如幻師;所起的觀境、觀心,如幻化的人、虎等一樣。這能觀所觀, 一切都是如幻性空的,所以說:凡「有所觀法,皆」是性「空」,「寂」滅 ,都是「無有堅固」;能「觀亦空」。雖一切如幻性空,而所觀、能觀,一 切成立。所以,以即空的觀慧,觀即空的觀境;境空寂,觀也空寂,怎麼倒 執境空而觀心不空呢!這一執著的主要根源,還是以為空是沒有;沒有,怎 麼能觀呢!不解空義,妄執就由此而起了。

English Translation:

Second Echelon (辛二): When Wisdom Arises, Contemplation Ceases

『Kāśyapa! Suppose two pieces of wood are rubbed together, then fire is produced, which in turn burns up these pieces of wood. Similarly, Kāśyapa! Through true contemplation, holy wisdom arises. [P132] Once holy wisdom has arisen, it in turn burns up the true contemplation.』

Original Text:

辛二 智起觀息 『迦葉!譬如兩木相磨,便有火生,還燒是木。如是迦葉!真實觀故生聖智慧 [P132] ,聖智生已,還燒實觀。』

English Translation:

Second, some believe that unblemished holy wisdom (無漏聖智 anāsrava-ārya-jñāna)—directly realized prajñā—is wisdom of suchness (如如智 tathatā-jñāna), non-discriminating wisdom (無分別智 nirvikalpa-jñāna). Therefore, they think that discriminative contemplation (分別觀), which has deluded discrimination (虛妄分別 vikalpa) (deluded consciousness 妄識) as its nature, can in no way give rise to holy wisdom. Not only can it not, but it is instead an obstacle! This is because it is adding delusion upon delusion, increasing discrimination within discrimination, like washing water with water, or extinguishing fire with fire; it is forever impossible to achieve the self-realization that is free from delusion and discrimination. This is why they advocate directly experiencing the true mind (直體真心), being without any discrimination in the present moment, and taking no-thought (無念) and freedom from thought (離念) as the skillful means. This can be said to completely undermine the Tathāgata's boundless skillful means! The Buddha taught contemplation (觀) in addition to cessation (止 śamatha), and wisdom (慧 prajñā) in addition to concentration (定 samādhi). It is through hearing (聞 śruta), thinking (思 cintā), and then giving rise to the wisdom of cultivation (修慧 bhāvanāmayī-prajñā) (contemplation 觀) that one can proceed towards true realization. How can one say that discriminative contemplation is useless? Here, the Buddha gives a parable to dispel these deluded attachments. The Buddha calls out, "Kāśyapa," saying: "Suppose two pieces of wood are rubbed together." Do not think that one piece of wood plus one piece of wood makes more wood. If rubbing two pieces of wood together is taken as a skillful means, after a long time, warmth is generated, and subsequently, "fire is produced." When the fire has arisen, it in turn "burns up these pieces of wood," and the wood is all consumed. This is like how, due to "true contemplation"—contemplating all dharmas as empty—"holy wisdom is thereby generated." Once holy wisdom has arisen, not only are the signs of objects extinguished, but it in turn "burns up" this contemplating "true contemplation." Thus, one reaches the state where objects are empty and the mind is quiescent, and the wisdom of suchness, non-discriminating wisdom, manifests. [P133]

Original Text:

  第二、有的以為:無漏聖智──現證般若,是如如智,是無分別智,所 以虛妄分別(妄識)為性的分別觀,是怎麼也不能引發聖智的。不但不能, 反而是障礙了!因為這是妄上加妄,分別中增分別,如以水洗水,以火滅火 一樣,永不可能達成離妄離分別的自證。這所以,主張直體真心,當下都無 分別,以無念離念為方便。這對於如來的無邊善巧方便,可說是完全失壞了 !佛於止外說觀,定外說慧,經聞、思而起修慧(觀),才能趨入真證,怎 麼說分別觀無用呢?這裡,佛就說一譬喻,來除滅這些妄執。佛呼「迦葉」 說:「譬如兩木相磨」,不要以為一木加一木,木更多了。如以兩木相磨為 方便,久久生暖,接著「便有火生」。等到火生起時,反「還燒是木」,而 木都被燒去了。這如由於「真實觀」的觀一切法空,「故生聖智慧」。等聖 智生起了,不但境相寂滅,反「還燒」了這能觀的真「實觀」。這就達到了 境空心寂,如如無分別智現前。 [P133]

English Translation:

What is this "true contemplation" here? It is discriminative contemplative insight (分別觀慧). In terms of its essential nature (體性), it is blemished (有漏 sāsrava) and deluded (虛妄). How then can it be called "true"? One must know that there are two kinds of discriminative contemplative insight: 1. Conventional contemplative insight (世俗觀慧): such as contemplating the blue-black (青瘀), purulent (膿爛), etc. [stages of a decomposing corpse], or the purity and adornment of the dependent (依報) and primary (正報) aspects of Buddha-lands. These all take 'signs of images with discrimination' (有分別影像相) as their object. 2. Ultimate-truth contemplation (勝義觀), which is also true contemplation. This is contemplating all dharmas as being without self-nature, empty, non-arising and non-ceasing, etc. Although this is discriminative, it can contemplate that the self-nature of all discriminations is unobtainable/unfindable/ungraspable; it takes 'signs of images without discrimination' (無分別影像相) as its object. This kind of discriminative contemplation is in accordance with the ultimate truth (勝義 paramārtha); it is discrimination that can destroy discrimination. Sūtras and śāstras speak of parables such as 'using sound to stop sound' (聲止聲) (like telling everyone not to talk), or 'using one wedge to remove another' (以楔出楔), to show the excellent function of non-discriminating contemplation (無分別觀). When unblemished holy wisdom is generated, this non-discriminating contemplation, which is discriminative by nature, also ceases to arise. To use discriminative contemplation to cease discriminative clinging is a great skillful means, a wondrous expedient! Such true contemplation has the wondrous function of contemplation without any grasping. When awakening to the true nature, one cannot be without such true contemplation—Madhyamaka contemplation.

Original Text:

  這裡的真實觀,是什麼呢?是分別觀慧。論體性,是有漏的虛妄的,那 怎麼說是真實呢?要知分別的觀慧有二:一、世俗觀慧:如觀青瘀膿爛等, 佛土的依正嚴淨等,這都以『有分別影像相』為境。二、勝義觀,也就是真 實觀。觀一切法無自性空,不生不滅等。這雖是分別的,而能觀一切分別自 性不可得,是以『無分別影像相』為境的。這樣的分別觀,是順於勝義的, 是分別而能破分別的。經論中說有以『聲止聲』(如說大家不要講話),『 以楔出楔」等譬喻,來顯示無分別觀的勝用。等到引發無漏聖智,這樣分別 為性的無分別觀,也就不起了。以分別觀,息分別執,是大善巧,妙方便! 這樣的真實觀,有觀的妙用而沒有取著。在悟入真實性時,是不能沒有這樣 的真實觀──中道觀的。

English Translation:

Second Subsection (庚二): Severance

First Echelon (辛一): Eradicating Non-Wisdom

『Suppose a lamp is lit, then all darkness is naturally gone; it comes from nowhere and goes nowhere. It does not come from the east, nor does it go to the [P134] south, west, north, the four intermediate directions, above, or below. It does not come from there, nor does it go there. And this lamplight has no such thought: "I can extinguish darkness." But because of the lamplight, it is the nature of dharma that there is no darkness. Light and darkness are both empty, without action, without grasping. Similarly, Kāśyapa! When true wisdom arises, non-wisdom (ignorance) then ceases. Wisdom and non-wisdom, the signs of both, are empty, without action, without grasping.』

Original Text:

庚二 斷

辛一 破無智 『譬如然燈,一切黑闇皆自無有,無所從來,去無所至。非東方來,去亦不至 [P134] 南西北方四維上下。不從彼來,去亦不至。而此燈明無有是念:我能滅闇。但因 燈明法自無闇,明闇俱空,無作無取。如是迦葉!實智慧生,無智便滅。智與無 智,二相俱空,無作無取。』

English Translation:

Wisdom can contemplate the empty nature of dharmas and realize the true nature, and it can also sever delusions and karma. Delusion (惑) is another name for affliction (煩惱 kleśa), with ignorance (無明 avidyā) as its general characteristic. What is called ignorance? Generally speaking, it is not knowing the Middle Way of dependent origination and empty nature. Specifically speaking, it is not knowing suffering, not knowing its arising, not knowing its cessation, not knowing the path; not knowing nature, not knowing signs, not knowing essence, function, cause, and effect, etc. Therefore, ignorance is also called non-wisdom (無智); and prajñā, which can eradicate ignorance, can also be called clarity (明了). That wisdom arises and delusion ceases is certain, but if one grasps the true nature, believing that there is a real prajñā that can arise and a real ignorance that can be eradicated, then that itself is non-wisdom and affliction. Therefore, the Buddha again uses a parable to illustrate: "Suppose a lamp is lit (然 means 'to burn' 燃)," and the lamp is truly lit, then "all darkness is naturally gone." Where does the light come from? And where does the darkness go? If light and darkness are taken as having real self-nature, then the light should have a definite place of origin, yet light "comes from nowhere." The darkness should definitely go somewhere, yet darkness "goes nowhere." Generally, light and darkness are considered to be material in nature, and matter should occupy space. If they have spatial properties, then shouldn't light come from one of the ten directions, [P135] and darkness go towards one of the ten directions? The Buddha uses concise phrasing to say: light "does not come from the east"; the "going" of darkness "also does not reach the south, west, north, the four intermediate directions (southeast, southwest, northeast, northwest are called the four intermediate directions 四維), above, or below." From this, it can be seen that lamplight "does not come from there," and the "going" of darkness "also does not reach" anywhere. When light arises and darkness ceases, isn't it just this coming from nowhere and going nowhere? Not only is there no place of coming or going, but light also has no real function of eradicating darkness. Therefore, it is said: "Lamplight has no such thought: 'I can extinguish darkness.'" That the lamplight does not have this thought indicates that lamplight has no real function of eradicating darkness. If one believes it has real nature and real function, then let me ask: does lamplight eradicate darkness by contacting (及) darkness, or without contacting darkness? If light and darkness do not contact each other, light being in the place of light, and darkness in the place of darkness, then how can light eradicate darkness? If light can eradicate darkness without contacting it, then the lamplight in one room should eradicate all the darkness in the ten directions! If one says that light and darkness do contact each other, then isn't there darkness in light, and light in darkness? If light eradicates darkness, then darkness should also obstruct light! From this, it can be seen that light and darkness are illusory, as extensively explained in the chapter on "Contemplation of the Burner and the Burnable" (觀然可然品) in the Madhyamakaśāstra (中論). Therefore, it is said: it is not that lamplight can truly eradicate darkness, but only "because of the lamplight, it is the nature of dharma (法爾)" that it is so; when lamplight appears, there is "naturally no darkness." "Light and darkness are both empty," like illusions, like transformations. There is no self-natured function of eradicating darkness, so it is said to be "without action (無作)." There is not the slightest bit of self-nature that can be grasped, so it is said to be "without grasping (無取)." [P136]

Original Text:

  智慧,能觀法性空而證實性,又能斷除惑業。惑是煩惱的別名,以無明 為總相。什麼叫無明?總相的說,是不知緣起性空的中道。別相的說,是不 知苦,不知集,不知滅,不知道;不知性,不知相,不知體用因果等。所以 無明又叫無智;而能破無明的般若,也可以稱為明了。智生惑滅,是一定的 ,但如取著實性,以為實有般若可生,實有無明可破,那就是無智煩惱了。 所以佛又舉喻來顯示:「譬如然(就是燃燒的燃字)燈」,燈真的點亮了, 那「一切黑闇,皆自」然的「無有」了。光明從那裡來的?黑闇又向那裡去 了?如以明闇為實有自性的,那光明應有一確定的來處,然而光明是「無所 從來」的。黑闇應確定到那裡去,而黑闇又是「去無所至」的。一般以為明 闇是物質性,那物質應佔有空間。如有空間性,那光明不是應從十方的那一 [P135] 方來,黑闇應向十方的那一方去嗎?佛以簡要的句法來說:光明「非東方來 」;黑闇的「去,亦不至南西北方,四維(東南、西南、東北、西北,叫四 維)上下」。這可見燈明「不從彼來」,黑闇的「去,亦不至」什麼地方了 。明生闇滅,不是這樣的不來不去嗎?不僅沒有來去的處所,光明也沒有破 闇的實用。所以說:「燈明無有是念:我能滅闇」。燈明的不作此想,即表 示燈明沒有破闇的實用。如以為有實性實用,那試問:燈明是及(接觸到) 闇而破闇呢?不及闇而破闇呢?如明闇不相及,明在明處,闇在闇處,那明 怎能破闇?如明不及闇而能破闇,那一室的燈明,應盡破十方的黑闇了!如 說明闇相及,那不是明中有闇,闇中有明嗎?明既破闇,闇也應障明了!這 可見明闇如幻,如中論的觀然可然品廣說。所以說:不是燈明實能破闇,而 只「因燈明法」爾如此,燈明現起,「自」然「無闇」。「明闇俱空」,如 幻如化的。沒有自性的破闇作用,所以說「無作」。沒有一毫的自性可取著 ,所以說「無取」。 [P136]

English Translation:

Wisdom is like lamplight, and ignorance is like darkness. Based on the preceding explanation of light and darkness, one can also analogously understand the meaning of prajñā eradicating ignorance. The Buddha then told "Kāśyapa"! Thus, "when true wisdom arises, non-wisdom (ignorance) then ceases." This is not only non-arising and non-ceasing, not coming and not going, but prajñā also has no self-natured, real function of eradicating delusions. This is merely that "wisdom and non-wisdom, the signs of both, are empty, without action, without grasping"; it is the nature of dharma (法爾如是) that wisdom arises and delusion ceases.

Original Text:

  智慧如燈明,無明如黑闇。根據上說的明闇,也可以比知般若破無明的 意義了。佛這才告訴「迦葉」!這樣,「實智慧生,無智便滅」。這不但不 生不滅,不來不去,而般若也沒有破惑的自性實用,這只是「智與無智,二 相俱空,無作無取」,法爾如是的智生惑滅而已。

English Translation:

Second Echelon (辛二): Extinguishing Binding Karma

『Kāśyapa! Suppose there is a dark room that has been in darkness for a thousand years and has never seen light. If a lamp is lit at that time, what do you think? Would the darkness have the thought, "I have lived here for a long time and do not wish to leave?"』『No, World-Honored One! If a lamp is lit at that time, the darkness has no power [to remain] and does not wish to leave; it will surely be eradicated.』『Similarly, Kāśyapa! Binding karma (結業) that has been accumulated for hundreds of thousands of millions of kalpas, through one true contemplation, is immediately all extinguished. The lamplight is holy wisdom. The darkness is all the binding karma.』

Original Text:

辛二 滅結業 『迦葉!譬如千歲冥室,未曾見明,若然燈時,於意云何?闇寧有念,我久住 此不欲去耶』?『不也,世尊!若然燈時,是闇無力而不欲去,必當磨滅』。『 如是迦葉!百千萬劫久習結業,以一實觀,即皆消滅。其燈明者,聖智慧是。其 黑闇者,諸結業是。』

English Translation:

"Binding karma" (結業) can be explained in two ways: First, "binding" (結 saṃyojana) refers to afflictions, such as the three fetters, five fetters, etc. They bind people to birth and death, preventing liberation, hence they are called "fetters." "Karma" (業) refers to the actions of body, speech, and mind; from manifest karma (表業), unmanifest karma (無表業 avijñapti-rūpa) arises, which becomes the cause and condition for experiencing various pleasant and painful fruitions (異熟 vipāka). The preceding discussion of "non-wisdom" (無智) concerned the general aspect of afflictions; here, "binding karma" refers to various afflictions and karma. Second, "binding karma" refers to karma that binds one to the three realms, such as karma binding to the desire realm (欲界繫業), karma binding to the form realm (色界繫業), and karma binding to the formless realm (無色界繫業). In this [P137] way, the previous passage spoke of afflictions, while this passage speaks of karma.

Original Text:

  結業,可作二說:一、結是煩惱,如三結、五結等。能繫人於生死而不 得解脫,所以名為結。業是身口意的動作;由表業而起無表業,為招感種種 苦樂異熟的因緣。上說無智,約煩惱的通相說;這裡的結業,約種種煩惱與 業說。二、結業是繫屬三界的業,如欲界繫業,色界繫業,無色界繫業。這 [P137] 樣,上文約煩惱說,這裡約業說。

English Translation:

That wisdom arises and binding karma is extinguished is the same as wisdom arising and non-wisdom being extinguished. Therefore, the Tathāgata still uses the analogy of lamplight dispelling darkness. The only difference is that the previous analogy concerned space (the ten directions), while this one concerns time. The Buddha said: "Kāśyapa! Suppose there is a pitch-black 'dark room' that has been so for a thousand years," having "never seen" "light." This darkness could practically be called the master of the dark room. "If a lamp is lit at that time," and light is about to enter, what do you think? Could the "darkness" of the dark room possibly "have" such a "thought"—"I have lived here for a long time," this is my old home, "I do not wish to leave?" Kāśyapa, upon hearing this, said: "No," it would not! "World-Honored One! If a lamp is lit at that time, the darkness has no power" to want to continue staying "and does not wish to leave." Because as soon as light comes, this darkness naturally disappears, and "will surely be eradicated." The Buddha said: "Similarly, Kāśyapa!" In the same way, the boundless "binding karma" that sentient beings have "accumulated" through "hundreds of thousands of millions of kalpas" since beginningless time, although it has been so long, yet "through one true contemplation's" illumination, the binding karma is also "immediately all extinguished," just like darkness. Therefore, the conclusion is that the "lamplight" mentioned above is "holy wisdom"; and the "darkness" is all the "binding karma"!

Original Text:

  智慧生而結業滅,與智生而無智滅一樣,所以如來還是舉燈明破闇作比 喻。所不同的,上約空間說(十方),今約時間說而已。佛說:「迦葉!譬 如千歲」來烏黑的「冥室」,從來「未曾見」過光「明」,這黑闇,簡直可 說是冥室中的主人了。「若然燈時」,光明要來了,你的意思如何?冥室的 黑「闇」,可能「有」這樣的意「念」──「我久住此」間,這是我的老家 ,我「不欲去」嗎?迦葉聽了說:「不」會的!「世尊!若然燈時,是闇無 力」,想繼續住下「而不欲去」的。因為光明一來,這黑闇是自然的消失, 「必當磨滅」。佛說:「如是迦葉」!同樣的,眾生無始以來,「百千萬劫 ,久習」而成的無邊「結業」,雖這麼久了,但「以一實觀」的照明,結業 也就「即皆消滅」,如黑闇一樣。所以結論說,上面說的「燈明」,就是「 聖智慧」;而「黑闇」也就是一切「結業」了!

The AtR Dharma Library

Must Reads

New here? Begin with Seven Stages, then On Anatta. Explore the full collection below.

View full list on page →

New in the AtR library

Latest posts

Up to 20 recent articles, newest publication first.

Browse more posts below.

Browse more posts →

AtR Library

Browse books, articles, recordings and ways to follow AtR.

Continue reading

Your unfinished long articles on this device.

    Start Here →Recommended readings and the free AtR guides John Tan’s Website
    Free Books
      View section on page →
      Featured Articles
        View section on page →
        Audio & Video
          View section on page →
          Further Reading
            View section on page →
            Follow Awakening to Reality
              View section on page →
              Full library on page

              Search AtR

              Examples: anatta · I AM · emptiness · dependent origination · Zen · Mahamudra · Dzogchen

              Try Google for broader results

              Google searches this site in a new tab.