Must Reads ↑ Top
Soh

从不同视角探讨证悟、体验与不二体验

(PasserBy/Thusness作于2009年)

AEN,你在这个博客里发布了一些非常有趣且高质量的文章。 我很喜欢阅读它们,就像我喜欢阅读你在TheTaoBums和你的论坛里写的那些帖子一样。 实际上,在你过去两个月发布的那些近期文章中,我最喜欢Rob Burbea的演讲,但不知为何,我并没有“当场想要评论的冲动”,直到Rupert的这篇文章出现。 我不知道为什么,但我会任由这种冲动自己写下来。:)

在阅读这些文章时,我脑海中浮现出几个观点,所以我先把它们记下来,并顺着思路进行展开。

  1. 论体验与证悟
  2. 论放下
  3. 论无明、抽离与解脱
  4. 论不二体验、证悟与无我

1. 论体验与证悟

在阅读了Rob Burbea和Rupert的文章后,我得到的一个直接且即时的回应是,当他们在谈论永恒见证者的体验时,错过了一个至关重要的点——证悟。 他们过于关注体验,却忽略了证悟。 说实话,我不喜欢做这种区分,因为我认为证悟也是一种体验形式。 然而在这个特定的案例中,做此区分似乎是合适的,因为它能更好地阐明我试图传达的内容。 这也与之前的几次情况有关,当时你向我描述了你如虚空般的觉知体验,并问我这是否对应于永恒见证者的第一阶段洞见。尽管你的体验确实存在,但我告诉你“不完全是”,即便你告诉我你清晰地体验到了一种纯粹的临在感。

那么欠缺了什么呢? 你不缺体验,你缺的是证悟。 你可能会有广阔开敞之虚空感的法喜觉受或感觉;你可能会体验到无概念且无所缘境的状态;你可能会体验到如镜般的明晰,但所有这些体验都不是证悟。 那里没有“原来如此”,没有“啊哈”,没有那种你明白了一些无可否认且不可动摇之事的直接而直觉知的顿然了悟瞬间——这是一种极其强大的确信,以至于没有人,甚至连佛陀都无法动摇你对此的证悟,因为修行者如此清晰地看见了它的真相。 这是对“你”的直接且不可动摇的洞见。 这是修行者为了证得禅宗的悟所必须具备的证悟。 你将清楚地理解为什么对于那些修行者来说,放弃这种“我是”之感并接受无我的教义是如此困难。 实际上,并没有对这个“见证者”的放弃,而是洞见的深化,从而将我们光明本性的不二、无基底性以及相互依存性囊括其中。 就像Rob所说,“保持该体验,但完善其知见”。

最后,这种证悟本身并不是终点,它是起点。 如果我们诚实以对,不过度夸大也不被这最初的瞥见冲昏头脑,我们就会意识到,我们并没有从这种证悟中获得解脱;相反,在获得这种证悟之后,我们受的苦更多。 然而,这是一个强大的条件,它激励着修行者踏上寻找真正自由的灵性之旅。:)

(Soh的备注:当John Tan/Thusness在2009年写这篇文章给我时,我当时只是对「我是」有所瞥见。标志着大我证悟的那种对存在(Being)的全然确信,直到隔年(2010年2月)才发生。John之所以说“在获得这种「我是」的证悟之后,我们受的苦更多”,是因为他在证得「我是」之后引发了能量失衡。然而,对我来说,证得「我是」之后的时期是充满法喜且基本上没有问题的,因为我按照John的直指与教导进行修行,从而避免了陷阱或不正确的修行。更多细节请参阅《觉醒于真实:心性指南》中关于应对能量失衡提示的章节。)

2. 论放下

在进一步讨论之前,我必须感谢你付出了巨大努力,将Rob Burbea的整个演讲打字记录下来,并提供了这份文字稿。 它绝对值得一读再读。 在文字稿中有3段关于放下的内容;我将对这几段加一些评论。

现在,一种可能性是通过培养专注力,以一种极其敏锐的方式培养念住,也就是高度聚焦的觉知,非常明亮的专注力,如同显微镜般精细的觉知,并像那样去真正精炼念住。 随后发生的事情是,通过那个镜头向我们展现的实相,是一个极速、快速变化的实相。一切就像屏幕上不断变化的像素,就像沙子落在湖面上,只有变化、变化、变化,生起又灭去,生起又灭去,都包含在那个意识之中。 因此,对意识的感知就是迅速生起的刹那,一个意识的刹那,又一个意识的刹那,在与某物的关系中生起。 你在巴利三藏的注疏中会非常频繁地发现这一点,在佛陀所说的话里也有一点,但主要是在注疏中。 不过再说一次,如果一个人仅仅通过念住的连贯性就能以那种方式培养,那将会非常有用。 在它所带来的东西中,通过看见所有这些无常,(会发现)没有任何东西是可以抓取的。 一切都在从指尖溜走,就像沙子从指缝间滑落,包括意识在内,都无法被攀缘。 于是,放下就伴随着这一切而发生了。 我说这是理论上的,因为实际上有时那种运作模式并不能真正带来放下,但在理论上它能带来放下,并且它绝对具有这种潜能。 所以这又是另一种可能性,并伴随着它的果实。

第三种方法我们在这次系列演讲的过程中已经探讨得比较多,那就是在一种更开放的感知中去修习——于是觉知便敞开,进入整个体验与现象的场域之中。 而修习的这种敞开,有助于生起一种将觉知视为某种极其广阔之物的感觉。 特别是当我们稍微谈及静默的时候。 觉知开始显得不可思议地广阔、浩瀚,浩瀚得难以想象。 如今这实际上可以通过放下来达到。 所以我们在修习中放下的越多,觉知感就越有可能以这种非常美丽的方式敞开。 极其浩瀚的觉知,取决于放下。

那么我们如何放下呢? 我们可以只专注于放下,我们也可以专注于无常然后我们放下,或者我们可以专注于无我——非我、非我所。 这是三种经典的放下方式。 那种浩瀚觉知的感觉,可能也是通过一种放松注意力的修习方式而被发现或达到的。 因此通常我们会关注这个对象和那个对象,接着又是另一个对象,再另一个对象。但实际上,去放松这种习性,对敞开的空间更感兴趣,而不是对空间里的客体或事物感兴趣。 然后我们会说,你可以安住于觉知之中,不再向外攀缘并对客体造作,只需安顿在那个开始敞开的觉知空间里。 这是一件你可以睁着眼睛做,也可以闭着眼睛做的事情,实际上这完全无关紧要。 睁着眼睛修习它,闭着眼睛修习它皆可。

- Rob Burbea

撇开佛教不谈,我想强调的是,我们永远不应低估“放下”的艺术,它很快就会证明是我们生命中最具挑战性的努力。 “放下”往往需要经历人生起起落落后所产生的深刻智慧,即便用一生的时间去修习,我们可能仍然无法理解“放下”的广度与深度。

我的经验是,在对一切现象的无我和空性本性生起洞见之前,“放下”在某种程度上与受苦的程度有关。 很多时候,我们中的许多人需要经历一个极度痛苦的过程,在此之后我们才能真正“放下”。 这似乎是一个先决条件,为了生起那种“愿意”放下的意愿。:)

心不知道如何自我解脱。
通过超越其自身的界限,它体验到松绑。
从深深的迷惘中,它放落了知晓。
从极度的痛苦中,生起了释然。
从彻底的疲惫中,迎来了安息。
所有这些都在循环中永续地重复着,
直至一人证悟万法确已解脱,
作为自无始以来的自然发生。

- Thusness

Rob将在转瞬即逝的现象中看见无常和无我的修习,与脱离认同和抽离联系了起来。 我不赞同;我将在下一节给出我的知见和评论。

3. 论无明、抽离与解脱

你最近发布的文章大多数是关于不二体验以及觉知浩瀚开敞之虚空感的。 我的建议是,不要让自己过度偏向体验的纯粹不二层面而忽略了“无明”,对无明拥有直接的洞见同样重要。 对于不二论者而言,临在遍及一切处,但这对于无明同样适用。 它遍及我们体验的所有层面,那也包含了深度的定境,或是不二的、无概念的、无所缘境的状态。 所以去深深地感受“无明”那惊人的致盲力量,它是潜藏得多深,它是如何塑造和扭曲经验现实的。 我找不到任何比我们固有的二元知见更具有催眠性的神奇咒语了。

如果我们在“致盲咒语”依然强大时去修习观察现象的无常,这种修习的目的似乎就会偏向于离欲、脱离认同以及抽离。 事实上,即使这样理解也完全没问题,但许多人无法停留在离欲和脱离认同上,并完全满足地安顿在无基底性中。 他们不知何故会“凭空变出”一个永恒不变的状态来作为安顿之所。 “非我、非我所”听起来就好像有什么东西是“我的,或者大我的”。 我更希望修行者将“无我”视为“绝对没有任何东西可以被称为是我的,或者是自我”;即使如此,这种“绝对没有任何东西可以被称为是我的,或者是自我”的体证,也不应被误解为对无我的体验性洞见(参见《论无我、空性、摩诃与平凡,以及自然圆满》)。 我已将更强烈的重点放在了这个倾向上,因为在佛教中,没有什么比生起对无我和缘起的洞见更重要的了,因为正是智慧(特别是般若智慧)带来了解脱(既然受苦的起因是无明)。 不要太轻视它。:)

尽管如此,这种进程似乎是相当不可避免的,因为心被无明(二元和执为实有的习性)所统治。 更令人惊奇的是,心可以捏造出这样一个状态,并认为它就是安歇之所、涅槃。 这是所有危险中最危险的,因为就像Rob所说,它是如此美丽,如此完美地契合了执为实有和二元之心的理想模型。 当一个修行者陷入其中时,是很难放下的。

然而,如果无我之洞见生起,我们重新审视观察现象的修习,我们就会意识到,解脱并不需要“这样一个永久的状态,或小我/大我”。 我们只需溶解无明,无常本身就转为自我解脱了。 于是我们所抛弃的,最终证明正是我们的终极目标,而我们为何无法找到解脱的原因也变得显而易见——因为我们正在逃离解脱;同样地,我们为何受苦的原因,是因为我们在主动寻找痛苦。 这正是我在你论坛的以下2段话中所要表达的意思:

“……看起来似乎需要投入大量的努力——但这其实并非实情。 整个修习原来是一个“解构”(undoing)的过程。 这是一个逐渐理解我们本性运作的过程,该本性从一开始就是解脱的,却被这种总是试图保持、保护并永远攀缘的‘小我’感所遮蔽。 整个小我感就是一种‘造作(doing)’。 无论我们做什么,是积极的还是消极的,仍然都是造作。 终极而言,甚至没有一个放下或任其自然,因为已经存在着持续不断的消融与生起,而这不断地消融与生起证明是自我解脱的。 没有了这个‘小我’或‘大我’,就没有‘造作’,只有自然而然的生起。”

- Thusness (来源:不二与业力模式)

“……当一个人无法看见我们本性的真相时,所有的放下无非是另一种经过伪装的抓取。 因此,没有‘洞见’,就没有释然…… 这是一个逐渐深入看清的过程。 当它被看清时,放下是自然而然的。 你无法强迫自己去放弃自我……对我来说,净化始终是这些洞见……不二与空性本性……”

- Thusness

因此,抽离会立即将我们置于二元的立场中,这就是我不赞同Rob的原因。 如果无我之洞见生起,那里没有中心,没有基底,没有主宰者;那里只有缘起之现象,而修行者必须立刻从这种生动生起与消融的直接体验中,生起另一个重要的洞见——这缘起之生动闪耀,本来就是清净且自我解脱的。

最后,我并不是在暗示,为了了悟法印的甚深含义而存在着一个明确的优先顺序;这完全取决于每个修行者的因缘和根基。 但如果可以选择的话,从首先看透无我的真实含义开始,一旦我们对无我的洞见成熟了,我们就会对无常、苦和涅槃产生截然不同的知见。:)

4. 论不二体验、证悟与无我

我刚才随意浏览了你论坛里的一些讨论。 你们有非常具有启发性的讨论,并且很好地呈现了我的七阶段洞见,但尽量不要把它作为一个模型来过度强调;它不应被当作一个有关开悟的绝对模型,你也不应该把它作为一个框架来验证他人的体验和洞见。 就简单地把它当作你灵性之旅的指南即可。

你区分不二体验与不二证悟,以及区分不二证悟与无我之洞见,这是正确的。 我们已经讨论过无数次了。 在我们使用的语境中,不二体验指的是没有能所之分的体验。 这种体验很像把两根蜡烛的火焰放在一起,火焰之间的边界变得无法区分。 它不是一种证悟,而仅仅是一个阶段,一种观察者与被观察者合一的体验,其中用于分割的概念层在定境中被暂时悬置了。 这个你体验过。

另一方面,不二证悟则是一种深度的理解,它来自于看穿能所之分的虚幻本质。 它是一种自然的不二状态,这源于经过严格的参究、质疑以及一段专门以“无我”为核心的长期修习后所生起的洞见。 不知何故,专注于“无我”会对无常和转瞬即逝的现象激发一种神圣感。 那种曾经为绝对界所垄断的神圣感,现在在相对界中也能被发现了。 “无我”这个词就像禅宗公案一样,可能显得隐秘、毫无意义或不合逻辑,但当它被证得时,它实际上是极其清晰、直接且简单的。 这种证悟伴随着一种体验,即一切都被消融为以下两者之一:

  1. 一个终极主体,或者
  2. 仅仅呈现为纯粹的“现象之流”

无论是在哪种情况下,两者都宣告了分离的终结;在体验上不再有二元感,合一的体验最初可能会极其强烈,但最终它会失去其宏伟感,事物会变得相当平凡。 尽管如此,无论这种合一感是源自于“视一切为大我”的体验,还是“仅仅只是显现”的体验,它都是“无我”的起始洞见。 前者被称为一心,而后者被称为无心。

在情形1中,修行者通常会继续以一种极其微妙的方式,甚至在几乎不知不觉中,去拟人化、实体化并推断出一个形而上的本质。 这是因为尽管有了不二证悟,但理解仍然是导向于基于主客二元对立的知见。 因此,这种趋势很难被察觉,修行者会继续踏在他们构建于“基于大我的无我”理解的旅程上。

对于情形2的修行者来说,他们处于一个更有利的位置去欣赏无我的教义。 当无我的洞见生起时,所有体验都隐含地是不二的。 但这种洞见不仅仅是关于看穿分离;它是关于彻底终结实体化,因此会产生一个即时的认出,即那个“主宰者”是多余的,在实际体验中它并不存在。 这是一种即时的证悟,即经验现实向来如此,而一个中心、一个基底、一个根基、一个源头的存在一直以来都是被预设的。

为了成熟这种证悟,即便直接体验到主宰者的缺失也是不够的;知见方面还必须有一个全然的典范转移;我们必须将自己从那种从一个源头、一个本质、一个中心、一个位置、一个主宰者或一个控制者来分析、看待和理解我们刹那生灭之经验现实的想法、需求、冲动和习性中解脱出来,并将自己完全安顿在无我和缘起之上。

因此,这一阶段的洞见并不是在雄辩地赞颂某个终极实在的不二本性;相反,它是在视这个终极实在为无关紧要。 终极实在只对一个被束缚于用执为实有的方式看待事物的心灵来说显得相关,一旦这种习性溶解了,存在一个源头的想法就会被视为是有缺陷和错误的。 因此,为了完全体验无我的广度和深度,修行者必须准备好并愿意放弃整个主客二元的框架,并敞开心扉去消除一切关于“源头”的想法。 Rob在他的演讲中非常巧妙地表达了这一点:

有一次,佛陀来到一群比丘面前,他基本上是告诉他们,不要将觉知视为万物的源头。因此,这种“存在着一个浩瀚的觉知,万法皆从中生起又消融于其中”的体认,尽管十分美妙,但他告诉比丘们,那实际上并不是看待实相的善巧知见。那是一部非常有趣的经文,因为它是极少数在结尾没有提到比丘们对佛陀的话“欢喜信受”的经文之一。

这群比丘不想听这些。他们对那个层次的洞见感到相当满意,因为它是如此迷人,经文里说比丘们对佛陀的话并不欢喜。(笑声)我必须说,同样地,作为一名导师,我也时常遇到这种情况。这个层次是如此诱人,它带有太多某种终极实相的意味,以至于人们往往停滞在那里,变得不可撼动。

- Rob Burbea

那么,在不诉诸于一个“源头”的情况下,佛教所谈论的知见究竟是什么呢? 我认为在你的论坛“What makes Buddhism different(是什么让佛教与众不同)”这篇帖子中,Vajrahridaya的回帖简明扼要地表达了这一知见,写得很好。 话虽如此,确实要记得不断地回溯到这生动显现的当下——作为这生起的思绪,作为这飘逝的香气——空即是色。:)


标签:无我,我是,John Tan,不二,开悟的阶段 |

请参阅 (See Also):

Soh


大家好,

非常高兴地宣布,《觉醒于现实修行指南》(Awakening to Reality Practice Guide)的中文翻译版现已正式发布!

此指南由 Nafis Rahman 汇编与编辑,其内容主要由 John Tan 和 Soh 撰写 。这份指南汇编了我们原版《觉醒于现实:心性指南》(Awakening to Reality: A Guide to the Nature of Mind)中的核心指引与观修练习 。

由于原版指南篇幅浩繁(超过1000页),对于许多读者来说可能稍显沉重且难以消化 。因此,这份经过 Nafis Rahman 精心汇编的修行指南应运而生,旨在为寻求灵性觉醒的同道们提供一份更通俗易懂、更直接的实修手册 。

本指南详细涵盖了从第一阶段“我是”(I AM)的证悟 、到第四阶段“一心” 、第五阶段“无我”(Anatta) ,以及第六阶段“空性”(Emptiness)和“一法究尽”等关键阶段的深刻洞见与具体修法 。

特别感谢 Nafis Rahman 为汇编此指南所付出的巨大努力 。

最后更新:2026年2月18日

简体中文版 (Simplified Chinese):

点击此处下载 PDF: [https://files.awakeningtoreality.com/ChineseAtRPracticeGuide.pdf]
点击此处下载 EPUB: [https://files.awakeningtoreality.com/ChineseAtRPracticeGuide.epub]

繁體中文版 (Traditional Chinese):

点击此处下载 PDF: [ChineseAtRPracticeGuide_TraditionalChinese.pdf]
点击此处下载 EPUB: [ChineseAtRPracticeGuide TraditionalChinese.epub]


[New Release] Chinese Translation of the "Awakening to Reality Practice Guide" Now Available

Hi everyone,

I am very happy to announce that the Chinese translation of the "Awakening to Reality Practice Guide" is now officially released!

This guide was compiled and edited by Nafis Rahman, featuring contents primarily written by John Tan and Soh. It compiles key instructions and contemplative practices from our original "Awakening to Reality: A Guide to the Nature of Mind".

Since the original guide is quite massive (over 1000 pages), it can be somewhat daunting for many readers. Therefore, this condensed practice guide was compiled by Nafis Rahman to serve as a more accessible and direct manual for fellow spiritual seekers.

The guide covers in detail the profound insights and specific practices ranging from Stage 1 "I AM" realization , to Stage 4 "One Mind" , Stage 5 "No-Self" (Anatta) , and Stage 6 "Emptiness" and "Total Exertion".

Special thanks to Nafis Rahman for his tremendous effort in compiling and editing this guide.

Last Updated: 18 February 2026

Simplified Chinese Version:

Download PDF Here: [https://files.awakeningtoreality.com/ChineseAtRPracticeGuide.pdf]
Download EPUB Here: [https://files.awakeningtoreality.com/ChineseAtRPracticeGuide.epub]

Traditional Chinese Version:

Download PDF Here: [ChineseAtRPracticeGuide_TraditionalChinese.pdf]
Download EPUB Here: [ChineseAtRPracticeGuide TraditionalChinese.epub]

Soh

Just a quick note to let everyone know that both the ATR Practice Guide and the Original ATR Guide have been updated.

Please check out the link below to access the latest versions.


The Awakening to Reality Practice Guide and The Original Awakening to Reality Guide

Soh

 

AWAKENING TO THE NATURAL STATE

by

JOHN WHEELER

 

From: Awakening to the Natural State; Chap.1 – Meeting ‘Sailor’ Bob Adamson

I had been on the spiritual path from my teenage years. For about thirty years I had been involved in various paths and practices, including Christianity, Theosophy, the teachings of J. Krishnamurti (I went to his talks in Ojai in the 1980s), Buddhism, Hinduism, and yoga. There were other paths and teachers also, too numerous to mention here. In my mid-twenties, I was introduced to Ramana Maharshi and Nisargadatta Maharaj (through books on their lives and teachings). Something about those great Indian teachers of non-dual spirituality seemed solid and unshakable. I found myself returning to their teachings over the years, even though I can’t say I fully (or even partially) understood or experienced what they were talking about.

Along the way, I did the circuit of many of the contemporary teachers involved in non-dual spirituality. There was undoubtedly a benefit, but I was not fully satisfied for some reason. Either it was my confusion or something was not fully clear in the teachings being presented. Most likely the former! For some reason my destiny was to meet ‘Sailor’ Bob Adamson, one of Nisargadatta Maharaj’s Western students.

What I found was that there was only so much I could get from books and meditating on my own. The growth was there, but it was often slow, and I was not getting much direct experience. I vaguely felt that I was progressing, but if I honestly looked at my experience, I did not fully understand what the teachers were pointing to. Most importantly, my day-to-day life was not free of suffering. I knew the seeking was not over; something was missing. Had I not met Bob Adamson, the seeking might have gone on for decades, or at least until I met someone with a real understanding. Who knows who that might have been or when, but, barring that, I am pretty sure the seeking – and suffering – would have continued for a long time.

At one point, I met some Ramana Maharshi followers who had been on the path of self-inquiry for twenty or thirty years (and still working at it, I might add!). I was nowhere near their level of devotion, so it was pretty much out the picture that that approach would work for me. As I look at this now, it is not so much Ramana’s teaching that is at fault, but the mind’s inevitable tendency to turn any teaching into a practice. Practices, as I eventually learned, usually are interminable. This is because they are often based on false premises.

Intuitively, I felt that it was important for me to meet someone who had realized their true nature, someone whom I could trust, someone whom I could talk with in order to share my doubts and concerns. However, I was unsure which teachers were authentic; none seemed to resonate fully. I used to read Nisargadatta Maharaj’s dialogues frequently. I could not understand his teaching fully, given all the Hindu verbiage and translation issues (he originally spoke in Marathi), but I felt intuitively that he was a free being. Many spiritual seekers, through reading his words, can sense the genuineness of his realization, even if they do not always experience everything he talks about. I used to wonder if there was anyone still living who had met Nisargadatta Maharaj and had really got the experience of self-knowledge. After all those years of searching, I eventually stumbled across Bob Adamson. Something resonated strongly. Even when I read the pages on his website, there was a strong feeling of ‘maybe this is it’.

Just prior to discovering Bob Adamson, I had a vivid dream of Nisargadatta Maharaj, in which he was encouraging me not to give up the search for spiritual understanding. Shortly afterwards, I learned about Bob Adamson. Not wanting to miss the chance of meeting an authentic teacher (having missed the chance to see Nisargadatta Maharaj while he was alive), I decided to visit Bob in person in Australia. You can imagine my motivation (or perhaps desperation!) in going to Australia on the chance that he might be able to clarify my doubts and questions.

What I have found is that the understanding of our true nature almost never comes from reading books or thinking about it. The best books are primarily the records of dialogues that took place between a seeker and a teacher at some point in the past. In reading such books, we are trying to understand an experience that took place in the past (through words and concepts on the page). A book is like a map pointing to something real that was experienced in a dialogue between living people. Usually, we do not have a clear understanding of what is being revealed (at least I didn’t) and we are trying to figure it out in the mind. This is a noble attempt, but as Bob Adamson pointed out within a few minutes of talking to him, ‘The answer can never be found in the mind’. The experience of spiritual understanding and freedom is not forthcoming, so we naturally assume that we are not ‘there’ (wherever ‘there’ is). We think there must be some technique or path involved to get there. But somehow we are not quite sure what it is! The result is that the mind keeps generating the same old bondage and suffering. This is a frustrating cycle, because we intuitively feel a glimmer of light or truth in the readings, but the actual experience eludes us. The majority of seekers that I have met have had a similar experience. Many are driven to try to find a living teacher, in order to get some guidance and assistance on the spiritual path. This was what happened for me.

I met many teachers, but it wasn’t until I met Bob Adamson that I was convinced that I was dealing with someone who had fully realized his true nature. Something radically shifted for me because I came face-to-face with the vitality, the confidence, the energy of that understanding. It was a remarkable experience and quite different from anything I had encountered in my years of seeking. The first day after I arrived, we had a chance to meet and talk. As we sat together, he looked me in the eyes and said point blank, ‘Do you have any doubts or questions? Is there anything you need to know?’ It was somewhat disarming because I realized he was free of doubts and was essentially offering me a chance to have the same experience for myself right then and there. The implication, it seemed to me, was ‘The seeking is over, the reading is over. You are here. Are you ready to go for this completely here and now?’ Fortunately, I jumped at the chance. I cast aside my theoretical knowledge and got down to getting off my chest my real doubts, questions and problems.

Surprisingly, things cleared up very quickly. Being face-to-face with that clarity – coupled with my own desire to be free – allowed things to shift quickly. The basic teaching is very simple, almost too simple. It is so simple the mind overlooks it. What I didn’t realize was that it has nothing to do with reading, meditating, doing something, working something out, stilling the mind, and so on. All of the techniques are looking in the wrong direction. Nisargadatta Maharaj used to say, ‘Understanding is all’. In essence, Bob was saying, ‘Right now in your direct experience see what your real nature is. What are you right now? What have you always been?’ The thinking mind is useless for this because seeing or looking is not a conceptual function at all. It is more like seeing an apple in your hand. You just look, not think.

Right now, as you read this, you exist and you are aware that you exist. You are undoubtedly present and aware. Before the next thought arises, you are absolutely certain of the fact of your own being, your own awareness, your own presence. This awareness is what you are; it is what you always have been. All thoughts, perceptions, sensations and feelings appear within or upon that. This awareness does not move, change or shift at any time. It is always free and completely untouched. However, it is not a thing or an object that you can see or grasp. The mind, being simply thoughts arising in awareness, cannot grasp it or know it or even think about it. Yet, as Bob says, you cannot deny the fact of your own being. It is palpably obvious, and yet, from the time we were born, no one has pointed this out. Once it is pointed out it can be grasped or understood very quickly because it is just a matter of noticing, ‘Oh, that is what I am!’ It is a bright, luminous, empty, presence of awareness; it is absolutely radiant, yet without form; it is seemingly intangible, but the most solid fact in your existence; it is effortlessly here right now, forever untouched. Without taking a step, you have arrived; you are home. No practice can reveal this because practices are in time and in the mind. Practices aim at a result, but you (as presence-awareness) are here already, only you don’t recognize it till it is pointed out. Once seen, you can’t lose it, and you don’t have to practice to exist, to be. This is, in essence, what Bob pointed out to me in the first conversation I had with him

Once I saw this, I felt very clear and free immediately. Later, some thoughts came up, some old personality patterns, some old definitions of who I thought myself to be. I seemed to lose the clear understanding of my nature as presence-awareness. The next day, I talked to Bob about it. He said, ‘Let’s have a look. Do you exist? Are you aware? What is illumining the thought that you have lost it?’ Then I realized that thoughts of suffering were only passing concepts being illumined by the ever-present awareness. I hadn’t lost anything at all. The awareness that we are is never obscured! Suffering seems real because we don’t have a clear understanding of our true nature. Instead, we believe the passing thoughts, such as ‘I am no good,’ ‘I am not there yet,’ ‘I am stuck’ or whatever the thought may be. Eventually we understand that we are not those thoughts. Once our real self is pointed out, the suffering loses its grip.

Bob pointed out that there is no person here at all. The person that we think we are is an imaginary concept. There are thoughts and feelings and perceptions, but they are not a problem. They just rise and fall like dust motes in the light of the presence-awareness that we are.

The closest that the mind can come to representing who we are is the thought ‘I am’. But that thought is not who we really are. Whether that thought is there or not, we still exist. We know the thought ‘I am’. That thought is the start of the false sense of an individual, a separate ‘I’. Because we didn’t know any better, the mind attached other labels to this ‘I’ thought, such as ‘I am good,’ ‘I am bad,’ ‘I have this problem,’ and so on. But those thoughts don’t have anything to do with us, because the very ‘I’ thought itself, the sense of separation, is not actually who we are. Once you see the falseness of the ‘I’ thought, that what we are is not an individual person at all, the identifications and ideas of a lifetime all collapse because they are all based on a false premise.

There is no practice to overcome suffering. It is simply a matter of seeing that the false ‘I’ is an assumption, that the whole mechanism is a conceptual house of cards. Then a lifetime of suffering evaporates. As Bob says, without the cause (the ‘I’), can there be any effects (psychological suffering and bondage)?

As I sat on his couch at one of his talks listening to him say ‘There is no person,’ suddenly it hit me. I looked and saw that right now and here, there is not a separate person in the picture at all. In that moment, all my doubts and confusion evaporated. I realized that all problems and questions stem from the sense of an ‘I’ that was assumed to be there at the centre of my life. Upon actual looking, I discovered it was not there at all. Fifteen years of meditating could not accomplish what occurred in a few moments of direct looking. In that recognition arose a direct and immediate sense of clarity and peace. I intuitively felt that the searching was over. I recall raising my hand and asking Bob, ‘So when you see yourself as the ever-present awareness and that the “I” that we imagined ourselves to be is really non-existent, then there can be no more doubts, questions, or problems. Is that it?’ He confirmed that this was so. From that moment on, I have not felt any serious difficulty or suffering, nor felt the slightest desire or urge to seek, meditate, or pursue any particular spiritual path. The whole landscape shifted and I intuitively knew the seeking was over. The ‘I’ upon which everything was based was not there. However, the shining presence-awareness was still there without effort, the simple fact of our own being.

Finally, Bob pointed out that all things arise in awareness and never exist apart from awareness. It is all one substance, all one light; it is all that; it is non-duality. There is nowhere to go and nothing to obtain. Everything is resolved. We ‘live, move, and have our being’ in that one ocean of light and never, ever move away from that.

This was the understanding that came to me, courtesy of Bob Adamson. It is all words, but maybe a glimmer of something will come through.

How This Understanding Unfolded for Me

The way this understanding unfolded for me was through the following insights. Bob pointed out to me the truth of our nature as presence-awareness or cognizing emptiness. Somehow that clicked for me. It was not so much the words, which I had read countless times before. It was the energy or vitality coming through the words that was potent and impactful. I sensed he was not only saying the words, but also living from that realization. This enabled a resonance to occur. To meet Nisargadatta Maharaj in person and partake in a living dialogue with him would likely have been more potent than reading his book I AM THAT. There was a huge difference between reading the words on paper ‘You are awareness’ and having a direct disciple of Nisargadatta Maharaj tell me in no uncertain terms, ‘You are awareness!’

After having seen this, and feeling some sense of freedom, I still seemed to lose it when contradictory thoughts arose. Bob pointed out that this is, in fact, not possible. You cannot lose your true nature, because it is the substratum of any thinking and perceiving. I realized that we can never leave this. Even if the thought ‘I lost it’ arises, the awareness is there knowing that thought. So the thought  is patently false.

The ‘knock-out blow’ was seeing the absence of a person. There is no such entity in the machine. There are only thoughts, experiences and objects arising and subsiding in awareness. There is no one controlling them and no one affected by them. Once this is seen, everything happens just as before, but the imagined person is removed from the film. The film goes on but there is no person starring in it. There are thoughts, but no thinker; actions, but no actor; choices, but no choice-maker. Basically, there is no difference from before, except the sense of separation is gone, along with the psychological suffering, confusion and doubt that appears along with the belief in a separate ‘I’. There is no one at the controls. Life is happening; thoughts are arising; actions are occurring spontaneously. You, as a separate person, are not doing any of these things. You don’t choose your thoughts, feelings, sensations. As Bob says, ‘You are being lived’.

As a final tying up of loose ends, it was helpful to see the fact that all experiences are just movements in awareness. They are like waves arising and falling in the awareness that we are. It is all one substance. There is only one energy, one substance, one taste. Past, future, there, here, I, you, this, that, and so on, are all just conceptual distinctions. Even concepts are that awareness. So you can’t win.

So what is the result? As the writer Wei Wu Wei once wrote, ‘The only problem is that 99.9% of everything you think, say and do is for yourself – and there isn’t one!’ Coming into alignment with the true state of affairs means that the usual strife, struggle and suffering based on wrong understanding vanishes. Life goes on. It is like a dislocated limb popping back into place. You can hardly say what happened, but suddenly everything feels a lot better! Nisargadatta Maharaj said something to the effect, ‘You can only put it negatively: there is nothing wrong anymore’. There is a distinct recognition that the searching is over. You may read books or visit spiritual teachers but you have the experience that they are saying what you already know.

In actual practice, while this understanding is sinking in, the seeker is often plagued by vestigial doubts, questions, and concerns, in spite of however advanced the intellectual understanding may be. I have seen many (including myself) able to converse on all this with the most incredible precision and verbal acumen. The only test is in day-to-day direct experience at the gut, emotional level. Is there any sense of suffering, separation, anxiety or fear? Am I feeling doubt or metaphysical uncertainty? Is the knowledge of my true nature unshakable? If not, the understanding is not complete. The best course, it seems to me, is to find a living teacher and get your doubts resolved directly. Nisargadatta Maharaj used to say, ‘I am not interested in what you have let go of, but what you are still holding onto’. A good teacher can help us resolve any remaining doubts. Then the understanding simply remains clear and steady and beyond doubt.

Soh

 Received an e-mail from The White Wind Zen Community https://wwzc.org/

Bodhi Leaf

Bodhi Leaf

eMirror Vol 30, No. 6

Friday, February 6th, 2026
Edited by the Practice Council

The White Wind Zen Community:
An international community practising and teaching Dogen’s Zen since 1985.


The phrases “thinking of not thinking” and being “Before Thinking” come from a kien-mondo or encounter dialogue which occurs amongst other places as Sanbyakusoku Shobogenzo Case 129.

Once Master Yaoshan Weiyan was sitting. 
A monastic asked him, “What are you thinking of sitting there, still and balanced like a mountain?” 
The Master said, “Thinking of not thinking.” 
The monastic said, “How can not thinking be thought about?” 
The Master said, “Be before thinking.”
Later, Master Dogen said, “This present mind is already withered away. Non-mind has not yet appeared. This is the livingness of this life: supremely pure.”
On another occasion, Dogen said, “Li and Chang’s thinking of heaven and earth are just about exhausted in steady sitting. Did you know that above the sitting cushions and Zen boards that hell’s hot water in the cauldrons and charcoal in the fires are naturally pure and cool?”     

Some beginning students of Zen think that thinking itself is a problem and that Zen is a kind of state of not thinking and so they try to think their way into not thinking and think that this is Zen. As Sengcan said, they make the mistake of “using the mind to hold the mind” and set themselves against themselves by holding on to the view of a self.  Of course many meditative traditions do indeed have a state of blank consciousness as their goal. In order to escape from the drudgery and inconvenience of existence and the inevitable aches and pains and itches of the body and the incessant din and caterwauling of their thoughts, many religious traditions have made putting an end to thought as their aim and have sometimes even equated a thoughtless and blank state with the realization of a higher existence as atman or Brahma or a contra or anti-existence, which is how the nirvana or cessation that the Buddha taught has often been misunderstood. The Buddha’s nirvana is actually the cessation of conditioned experiencing, going beyond the reference points that are the result of locating Knowing in itself as the mere contraction of a sense of a knower or a self. The Buddha realized that this sense of a knower or self is the cause of sufferings that are interminable unless we cease pretending that the sense of a self, the image of a self, is who we are and what Knowing is. And he Taught an end to these sufferings through the path of practice. The Buddha recognized that these states of intense concentration are ultimately useless in putting an end to the suffering and unsatisfactoriness that beings experience in their lives because the mechanisms of grasping and avoidance are not addressed. He saw instead the need for direct and continuous insight into how attention moves towards and away from what is being experienced. However, this insight cannot be unfolded when attention is congested with discursive and imagistic thinking. It must be a quality of attention itself, it must be how experiences are experienced, and not just a story or an attitude about experiences. And so it is essential to stop propagating discursive thoughts, to see how these thoughts arise from a prior congealing and directing of attention and release this by opening attention to the greater context of whole bodily experience.

- Continuing teisho 8: 2005, in 13 August, 2005 in the series "Wandering on Medicine Mountain" presented by Zen Master Anzan Hoshin at Dainen-ji


The Hatto (for formal sittings)

The Hatto (for formal sittings)

The Zendo (for associate and general sittings)

The Zendo (for associate and general sittings)

Practice Schedule and Upcoming Events

Fusatsu (Renewal of Vows):  February 18th.

Introduction to Zen Workshop Ottawa:
The next  Introduction to Zen Workshop will take place on Saturday, February 7th, at 1:45 p.m.
To register: https://IntroductionToZenWorkshop.eventbrite.ca ; for more information please see https://wwzc.org/introduction-zen-workshop-ottawa 

Nehan O-sesshin
The Seven-day Nehan O-sesshin will begin on Sunday, February 15th at 8:00 p.m. It will end on Sunday, February 22nd at noon. 

A Sitting for Associate and General Students During the Nehan O-sesshin:
A combined sitting for associate and general students will take place in the Zendo on Saturday, February 21st. Arrival time is 9:15 a.m. (in time for First Bell). The sitting ends at 11:30 a.m. Students attending are reminded to remain on the first floor. Seating is limited and registration is required: Register for Combined Sitting

Cancelled Associate Sitting:
The Monday February 16th associate sitting that would normally take place at 7:30 p.m. is cancelled due to the O-sesshin.

Cancelled Associate Sitting:
The Thursday February 19th associate sitting that would normally take place at 7:30 p.m. is cancelled due to the O-sesshin.

A Note to Preliminary and Public Students Concerning O-sesshin:
During an O-sesshin the schedule is such that there is no time to meet face to face with preliminary students or to reply to email correspondence sent by public students. Public students are asked to send their weekly practice journals, as they will be reviewed. But unless there is something that needs an immediate reply, you will not receive an email reply until the week following the O-sesshin.

Nehan:
Commemoration of the Buddha’s Death (Nehan-e) February 15th.

Hermitage:
The Roshi is continuing an extended period of hermitage due to underlying health issues.


Weekly Practice Schedule

Formal Sittings for WWZC Students: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday Mornings. The formal sittings begin at 6:00 a.m. You would need to arrive by 5:45 in time for First Bell. The sitting ends at 7:25 with the Chants. Following that there is a Daruma-kata Aiki review which ends at about 7:50. If you need to leave before the kata, please let us know that in advance by sending an email to [email protected].

Saturday Morning General Sitting for WWZC Students: The general sitting begins at 9:30 a.m. You would need to arrive by 9:15 a.m., in time for First Bell. The sitting ends at 11:45 a.m. Some general students attend the 6:00 a.m. Saturday morning formal sitting, stay for breakfast and then attend the general sitting. If you stay for breakfast, there is a $5 contribution which can be made through Eventbrite: Register for Saturday Breakfast Proceeds from meals go to White Wind Zen Community.

Monday and Thursday Evening Associate Sittings for WWZC Students: The associate sitting begins at 7:30 p.m. You would need to arrive by 7:15 p.m., in time for First Bell. The sitting ends at 9:10 p.m.

Friday (Hosan): There are no formal sittings scheduled at the monastery on Fridays, but you are expected to sit at home if you have committed to sitting zazen daily. Retreats may be scheduled on Fridays.

Sunday Formal Sitting: The Sunday morning formal sittings are reserved for monastics, formal students, and probationary formal students. It starts at 7:00 a.m. and ends at 10:10 a.m. with the chants. Following that there is a Daruma-kata Aiki which ends at about 10:30 a.m.


Long Distance Training Program

For students living an hour or more commuting distance from the monastery in Ottawa, please visit this Web Page: https://wwzc.org/long-distance-training-program 


What to do if you Arrive After the Sitting Begins

If you arrive after the sitting starts and the door is locked, you don't need to turn around and go home. Ring the bell once and then sit on the bench on the front porch. If possible, we will come and unlock the door for you right away. If we are in the middle of the chants or listening to a teisho, we will come to let you in as soon as the teisho finishes.


Congratulations

Congratulations and deep gassho to Onur Onder of Ottawa on being accepted as a general student.


Retreats and Training Sessions

Information About Scheduling Retreats or Training Sessions

General student Julien Jefferson sat a three-day retreat from Saturday, January 31st to Monday, February 2nd at Dainen-ji. Associate student Kathleen Johnson sat a half-day retreat on Thursday, January 29th at Dainen-ji. Associate student Bryan Roh sat a half-day retreat on Saturday, January 31st at Dainen-ji.


Recorded Teachings Schedule

Listening to Recorded Teisho and Dharma Talks

Recorded Teachings Schedule for January 31st to February 7th:February 7th to February 14th:
General sitting Saturday, February 7th: The Primordially Awakened Way: Zen Master Anzan Hoshin's Commentaries on Eihei Dogen zenji's "Kobutsu-shin": Teisho 6: Collapsing, Dropping, Falling (18 minutes)
Formal sitting Sunday, February 8th: "SAkN The Anatomy of Awakening" by Zen Master Anzan Hoshin: Teisho 6: The Matter of Consciousness (23 minutes)
Associate sittings Monday, February 9th and Thursday, February 12th: Flowers and Worms: Zen Master Anzan Hoshin's Commentary on the Maharahulovadasutta: Teisho 1: Introduction: Falling Flowers: a reading of the sutta (16 minutes)
General sitting Saturday, February 14th: The Primordially Awakened Way: Zen Master Anzan Hoshin's Commentaries on Eihei Dogen zenji's "Kobutsu-shin": Teisho 7: The Naked Post (23 minutes)


Recorded Teachings for Public Access

While most of the online Recorded Teachings library is password-protected and only accessible to students of the Lineage of Zen Master Anzan Hoshin, a small selection of MP3 recordings of teisho are accessible to the public at wwzc.org/recorded-teachings Additional recordings will be uploaded periodically. MP3 recordings of four recorded teisho by Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi are currently available:

Dharma Position http://wwzc.org/dharma-position  

Eyes See, Ears Hear http://wwzc.org/eyes-see-ears-hear 

Embarrassment http://wwzc.org/embarrassment 

Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi's reading of his translation of Eihei Dogen zenji's “Bendowa: A Talk on Exerting the Way”: http://wwzc.org/bendowa-talk-exerting-way


Translations and Texts

Photograph of Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi at Daijozan, mid-1980s, by Ven. Shikai Zuiko osho

Photograph of Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi at Daijozan, mid-1980s, by Ven. Shikai Zuiko osho

Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi has recently completed translation work on some shorter texts by Eihei Dogen zenji from the Shobogenzo. The work on these particular texts is based upon the literal translations that he worked on with Joshu Dainen roshi at Hakukaze-ji around 1977-78 followed by many years of putting them down, picking them up, and polishing. Naturally, more essential texts such as Uji, Genjokoan, Shinjin Gakudo and some 40 others were completed first and have been given extensive commentaries by the Roshi. This batch of texts includes Keisei Sanshoku: Sounds of Streams, Forms of Mountains, Baike: Plum Blossoms, Ryugin: Howling Dragon, and Udonge: The Udumbara Blossoming and many others are nearing completion. Annotation details and successfully conveying them across various document formats are the issue at this point.

Work on Bussho: Buddha Nature, a very long and nuanced text by Dogen zenji, is still ongoing.

Roshi also finished an update to the “Saijo Shingi: The Deportment of Radiance”, our manual of monastic training standards which is a supplement to the ancient Eihei Shingi and Keizan Shingi.


White Wind Zen Community Website Update

Dharma Talk: “Embarrassment” 
Dharma Talk presented by Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi on August 25th, 1990. 
https://wwzc.org/embarrassment-0/ 

Teisho: “Practising Without an Edge”
Teisho presented by Ven. Jinmyo Renge sensei on February 19th, 2025
https://wwzc.org/practising-without-an-edge/ 

Teisho: “I Know Who You Are!”
Teisho presented by Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi, presented at Dainen-ji on March 13th, 1999
https://wwzc.org/teisho-i-know-who-you-are/ 

Dharma Assembly: On Karma 
Mondo by Ven. Anzan Hoshin roshi, Presented in April  of 1986, River Road Zendo. 
https://wwzc.org/dharma-assembly-karma/ 


Request for Help to Maintain the Grounds

If you would like to offer time to help with maintenance in the grounds your help will be appreciated. You can offer a regular period of samu or make arrangements with the shissui to come for a single period of caretaking practice. Please write to [email protected] or directly to Saigyo ino at [email protected] if you can assist with this work. Thank you.


Wooden Practice Materials for Sale in Myomaku

Saigyo ino has made a selection of wooden practice materials which are now for sale in Myomaku. These include boxes for storing incense, incense bowls, kneeling benches and kaishaku. He is donating a portion of the proceeds to WWZC. You are welcome to go into myomaku before or after sittings to see what’s available.

Wooden Practice Materials for Sale in Myomaku


Alternate parking for sittings near Dainen-ji

If you need alternate parking near the monastery due to snow parking bans or lack of parking spots you can use the Loblaws car park located at 363 Rideau Street - Parking - Loblaws.

The car park is open until 10:00 p.m and charges $4 per hour. A full day 6:00a.m. to 6:00 p.m. is $10.


Noodles

Office of the Tenzo

Dogen zenji taught in the Tenzo Kyokun: Instructions for the Tenzo (Tenzo kyokun: Instructions for the Tenzo https://wwzc.org/dharma-text/tenzo-kyokun-instructions-tenzo) that the work of preparing and serving meals is "a matter for realized monks who have the mind of the Way“, or by senior disciples who have roused the Way-seeking mind." In alignment with this, part of Zen Master Anzan Hoshin's samu for the Community involves personally overseeing the activities of the ancient Office of Tenzo. Ven. Jinmyo Renge sensei serves as Tenzo and Mishin godo and Saigyo ino offer assistance as tenzo-anja.

The WWZC does not advocate any particular diet. However all meals prepared during practice events, such as Dharma Assemblies, sesshin, or retreats are vegetarian or vegan as most people can eat this. On Tuesday evenings there is an optional meat dish, as some people find that a purely vegetarian diet, especially as they get older, is not sufficient for their health. If you are adhering to a strictly vegan diet, you can write to the tenzo, Jinmyo Renge sensei, at [email protected] a week prior to attending an event to request vegan foods. If you are lactose intolerant or have allergies to foods, you should write to the tenzo about dietary restrictions a week before attending events.

The following meals were prepared this week:

Saturday Breakfast (Mishin godo):
Mayak eggs (Korean marinated eggs): 6-minute soft boiled eggs, peeled and marinated in light shoyu, water, honey, minced red pencil chiles, minced garlic, chopped scallions, minced white onion) garnished with sesame seeds, sesame oil, and chopped scallions, served on a bed of Calrose rice.

Sunday Yakuseki (Mishin godo):
Rigatoni in garlic-butter sauce (minced white onion, minced garlic, chile flakes, butter, olive oil, green peas, cream); black lentil vegetable soup (black beluga lentils, chopped carrots, onion, celery, sweet potato, tomato paste, dried thyme, smoked paprika, salt, black pepper); diced friulano cheese mixed with chopped gherkins and lemon zest. 

Monday Yakuseki (Jinmyo sensei):
Roasted root vegetables (rutabaga, turnips, parsnips, potatoes, carrots cooked with bran oil, vegan butter, salt, pepper and garlic powder); ‘Beyond Burger’ patties; diced carrots with peas and corn, butter, salt and pepper; parsley sauce (roux, vegetable stock, Dijon mustard, pinch of garlic powder, lots of black pepper, chopped parsley); boiled diced carrots, peas, and corn mixed with butter, salt, and pepper. 

Tuesday Yakuseki (Jinmyo sensei):
Mixed grain (calrose short-grain white rice, Thai jasmine rice, arborio rice, basmati rice, long-grain white rice); tonkatsu (pork loin pounded until thin, dipped in a batter made from equal parts of all-purpose flour, corn starch and rice flour seasoned with garlic powder, onion powder, white pepper and salt then coated with panko and deep fried); tonkatsu sauce made from cooked, blended chopped onion, chopped apple, shoyu, Worcestershire sauce, tomato paste, sesame oil; slaw of thinly cut green cabbage, carrots, and white onion dressed with lime juice, salt, and black pepper.

Thursday Yakuseki (Jinmyo sensei)
Warmed naan with butter; dal (toor and masoor dal, cumin and mustard seeds, hing, dried red chillies, green chillies, ginger/garlic paste, chopped tomatoes and onions, garam masala, Kashmiri chilli powder, dried fenugreek leaves, fresh coriander); salad of chopped green butter lettuce, romaine, green leaf lettuce, and radicchio, thinly sliced red onion, and grated carrot with an optional Indian-style dressing of equal parts mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, and apple cider vinegar blended with mango chutney, lime pickle, honey, salt and black pepper.

Also made this week by Jinmyo sensei: Advance meal preparation for the upcoming O-sesshin (toor dal and mango curry to be frozen); apple crisp;  lamb and rabbit cat food.


Hands in gassho, rupa

Thank You

If you would like to thank someone for a contribution they have made, please feel free to send an email to Jinmyo sensei at rengezo@gmail dot com, but be sure to type "eMirror” in the subject line.

From Stacey Loyer:
Thank you to the Roshi for sharing the documentary Dream Window: reflections on the Japanese garden to a group of formal students and monks in 1993, along with providing valuable context around how the Japanese approach to gardens arose. Thank you to Shikai Zuiko osho for describing this film and sharing the Roshi's comments in the Winter 1993 issue of Zanmai, in her Dharma MediaWatch column. I was able to find Dream Window on youtube and really enjoyed it. 

From Julien Jefferson:
Thank you to Roshi for presenting the teisho series "The Primordially Awakened Way" and "Playing With Space", which I have been listening to recently. Thank you to Jinmyo sensei for compiling the Retreat Handbook, in which I can always find exactly what I need to know. Thank you to Mishin godo and Saigyo ino for recent practice interviews. Thank you to the tenzo and tenzo-anja for preparing delicious wintry food during my retreat, especially the pea soup.