Skip to main content

自然状态的至简之境

By

这篇文章的缘起

从开车时的随想,到一篇文章

这篇文章源于有一天开车时,我随口录下的一些感想。当时并不是在作正式讲座,也没有事先拟好提纲,只是想到什么就说什么:有时围绕一个问题反复思索,有时顺着一个念头说下去,又突然想起还有什么要补充。录音里自然少不了重复、没说完的句子,以及需要进一步说明的地方。

我也想借自己的录音,试试我开发的Cosmic Transcriber:它能把我口头说的话转写得多准确?录音转成文字后,我再用 AI 协助整理成一篇完整的文章,删去重复的解释,理顺行文,并把需要澄清的地方展开。因此,下面是一篇根据口述感想编辑、扩充而成的文章,并非逐字稿。

写成这篇文章时,我主要只用了一条提示词,让 AI 在保留原意的前提下,把转写稿整理成一篇条理连贯、排版得当的文章。随后,我又简单要求它审阅全文,改了几处措辞,并补上一项参考资料。整个过程基本就是这样,并没有经过一长串精心设计的写作提示词。

Cosmic Transcriber:音频转文字。这是我开发的 Windows 应用,利用你自己的 OpenAI API 账号把录音转成文字。它支持长录音、批量处理、断点续转,并能导出 TXT 或 Markdown,适合讲座、访谈,也适合整理像这次这样的随手笔记。

CloudScribe Pro:文字转语音。这是另一款配套的 Windows 应用,使用你自己的 Google Cloud 文字转语音凭据,把审核过的文字合成为 MP3 旁白。两款程序正好构成一套流程:文章、译文或转写稿写好后,还能转换成音频供人聆听。

两款应用都可以免费下载,但所使用的 API 服务会另行按用量收费。下载链接、源代码及设置说明见:Cosmic Transcriber + CloudScribe Pro。

这些录音始终围绕着一个朴素的问题:如果解脱本来就是自然、无造作的状态,为什么修行之路有时显得如此复杂?下面这些思考,便是要探讨这个看似矛盾的问题,以及为什么认出光明性、证悟无我和透彻空性,不能混为一谈。

关于知见、证悟与修行的随想

极致的简单:解脱之路为何在于卸除,而非建造

从自我的紧缩、显现的光明,到使执取得以松脱的智慧。

本文目录
  1. 我们不是在建造一座金色城堡
  2. 无明如何造成紧缩
  3. 为什么光靠意愿无法终止轮回
  4. 整个经验都松开了
  5. 为什么“放轻松就好”还不够
  6. 于所见唯有所见
  7. 光明就是显现本身
  8. 无我不只是没有造作者
  9. 从见证者到无边的同一临在
  10. 当光明成了另一道心结
  11. 光明性可以充满喜乐,空性使人解脱
  12. 缘起而无自性生
  13. 如来被称为“如是者”
  14. 知见、体验、证悟与修行
  15. 我所说的自然状态
  16. 从百般执取归于零

一、我们不是在建造一座金色城堡

许多人把修行想成一项极其复杂的工程:要打坐好几年,甚至几十年;要跟随老师学习、研读经典、参加闭关,慢慢积累足够多的体验,才或许有机会瞥见开悟。仿佛远方有某种辉煌的成就等着我们,而我们的任务,就是一步步开辟通往它的路。

这种想法并非毫无道理。修行确实需要投入,根深蒂固的种种制约也未必能很快松脱。但它很容易让我们误解修行究竟在做什么。我们会以为解脱是一项必须亲手建造的伟大工程,就像一砖一瓦砌起一座金色城堡,等建好了才搬进去。

我并不这样理解。我们不是在制造经验本具的明与空,也不是要把一个本来实有的凡夫,塑造成一个新造出来、同样实有的佛。修行所做的,是破除无明与执取,不再错认经验本来的样子。

经验的本性不会因为我们用功修行才变得光明,也不是打坐之后才开始无自性。不过,这并不意味着我们在实际生活中已经摆脱遮障。经验的本性,与我们对本性的证悟,必须分清楚。否则,“本来如此”就容易成为借口,让我们忽略那些仍使我们受缚的种种制约。

我说我们的本性本来圆满、无边无际、没有中心,并不是指显现背后藏着某种无限的实体。我是说:根本找不到一个独立自存的中心或自我,而经验的鲜明呈现也从来不需要这样一个中心。并不是修行之后才变得没有一个自性成立的我;需要止息的是那个认定有我、又紧抓不放的无明。

我们并不是要替自我盖一座更壮观的住所,而是要看穿那种不断替自我安家立足的执取。

因此,修行过程可以持续精进,究竟的成果却被形容为简单、无执、离于造作。用功是为了培育理解和解脱所需的因缘,而不是制造一种名叫“解脱”的终极实体。

二、无明如何造成紧缩

那么,究竟要卸除什么?根本就在无明:我们错认了心、意识以及种种显现。对于本来无自性的事物,却把它们想成各自独立存在;对于依缘而起的过程,却以为其中有一个自我在坐镇。

这个想象出来的我,仿佛是知晓背后的知者、体验背后的体验者、行动背后的造作者。它似乎能独立于因缘的展开,站在某个私密的立足点俯视一切。于是便有了“我在里面”,看着“外面的世界”。

接下来就很容易生起占有和认取:这是我的身体、我的心、我的家、我的伴侣、我的成就、我的未来。事情顺心时,便觉得安心;不如意时,那个假定的中心就像受到了威胁。于是我们抓取、抗拒、比较、防卫,也害怕失去。

与此同时,世界也被我们看成由一个个仿佛独立自存的对象组成。每个东西似乎都有自己独立的核心,仿佛其生起、存续、消失都不依赖其他条件。主客两端相互强化:一个被当成真实的观察者,对着一群同样被当成真实的事物。

我所说的“实体化”,就是把人和现象认作从自身方面就真实成立。这不只是措辞的问题。日常说一句“我要回家”,本身并没有什么错。问题在于,我们往往在不自觉中,深信这个“我”和所遇到的东西,都具有自己赋予它们的那种独立实在性。

这也是我所说的“紧缩”。它不只是肌肉绷紧,或心情不佳,而是整个经验围绕一个想象中的中心组织起来,并由此生出种种抓取和抗拒。身体可能随之紧绷,但问题远比身体放松与否更深。

我们并不是某天早上坐下来,决定要制造这一套结构。没有人会有意识地选择:“今天我要缩成一个分离的我,明天再停下来。”在我们察觉之前,这个习惯模式就已经运转着。所以即使有人好心地劝我们“别再认同自我”,也未必触及问题的根源。

无明不是靠那个由无明虚构出来的中心,再下达一道命令就能消除的。唯有智慧,才能看清:我们认作独立实有的东西,从来就不曾以那种方式存在。

三、为什么光靠意愿无法终止轮回

十二缘起支的常见讲法,以无明为首:缘无明而有行,缘行而有识,继而有名色、六入、触、受、爱、取、有、生,乃至老死,以及随之而来的种种苦。经典也指出,相关因缘止息,这一连串苦的过程便随之止息。 [1]

这里说的“为首”,不是指宇宙历史上的第一个事件。也不能把这套公式中的“识”直接译成“二元意识”:经文明确说到六类识。我要强调的是,无明如何令我们认取、错认经验,又如何使束缚延续。

按照传统佛教的说法,问题并不只关乎这一生遭遇的种种不如意。无明、渴爱与业力维系着生死轮回,使众生在六道中反复受生。贪、嗔、痴推动不善业;善业可以带来较好的境遇。但即使投生善趣,也不等于已经出离轮回。

有人说自己宁愿继续留在轮回中。但这种愿望可能忽略了教法真正指出的问题:轮回不只是我们熟悉的快乐,还意味着有为生命的脆弱、不断失去,以及无法保证业力将把自己带往何处。传统经论记述佛陀忆念宿世,使我们从远远超出今生记忆的漫长尺度,来看待这个问题。

愿望和意图当然也是因缘,会产生作用;但它们不是某个站在因果之外、拥有绝对主宰权的自我所颁下的命令。想过怎样的生活,不等于能够毫无限制地选择来世;希望苦止息,也不等于苦因已经断除。

在大乘的论述中,还要分清:一种是受烦恼驱使的投生,另一种是高地菩萨凭智慧与愿力展开的慈悲事业。我在口述时特别想到第八地。相关描述强调菩萨不动摇的境界,以及由先前誓愿所支持的任运事业。关于化现和不再被业烦恼逼迫受生的说法,属于那种高深的菩萨道背景,不能拿来当成普通人已经自由选择了自己每一段人生的证明。 [2]

我们不能按一下按钮,就让这套模式戛然而止。但这也不是宿命论。既然束缚依因缘而起,就可以从因缘着手。闻法、思惟、持戒、禅修和洞见之所以重要,正是因为它们能够参与并推动这种转变。

能够从根本上破除无明的智慧,不是会背诵一句“万法皆空”就够了。理智上的理解能指引方向,严谨的推理也能揭示我们假设中的矛盾;但知见必须成为直接明见的事实。我们必须亲自看穿那个一直被视为理所当然的自我,以及事物所谓的自性实有。

四、整个经验都松开了

还有一个更简单的比喻:紧握的拳头。想象你长年牢牢抓住某样东西,握得太久,连紧绷感都成了习惯。到了后来,你甚至不再察觉自己正在抓紧,只觉得手本来就是这样。

当拳头张开时,并不需要再往手里添什么珍宝,紧绷自然松开了。解脱也类似:不是往经验中安置什么神奇的东西,而是放下那种让整个经验变成挣扎的执取。

这个比喻想表达的,是仿佛整个经验都松开了。对身体、心、意识、自我以及种种现象的执取松脱;不必再执意树立一个中心、保卫它,再围着它建立一个必须守住的世界。

这远不只是决定不再在意某个人或某样财物。“以前我很执着这段关系,现在放下了”,也许确实意味着一种有益的改变,却未必触及那个仍站在一旁、宣称“我已经放下”的人。

就连“我存在”的我慢——asmi-māna——也必须舍离。我们不能把一个终极自我偷偷安置在五蕴之内、五蕴之外,或把它保留成五蕴永恒不变的背景。放下寻常的贪恋,却护着一个不受伤害的灵性身份,并没有完成修行。

也可以想象手里握着一块烧红的炭。显而易见的建议是:放手!但如果抓紧早已根深蒂固,连怎么松手都不知道呢?反复说“放下”,可能只是说出了想达到的结果,却没有指出真正放下需要什么条件。

关键的因缘是智慧。当那个想象中的抓取者,以及它赖以寻求安全感的立足点,都被看穿时,松手就不再只是一个自我试图管理执着的行为。执取的整个结构开始瓦解。

五、为什么“放轻松就好”还不够

入睡也是个很有用的比喻。对于平时容易入睡的人来说,睡着可以是完全不费力的事。条件合适、身体也准备好了,躺下便顺着身体的自然节律进入睡眠。不必一块块地“造”出睡眠,也不用监督入睡的过程,更无需一遍遍命令自己睡着。

甚至可能连刻意“放下”这个动作都没有。他们不会在心里盘算:“现在先放开这个念头,再松掉那种感觉,然后让自己入睡。”整个过程无需额外操控,自会展开。焦虑地想让自己睡着时,入睡可能难到近乎不可能;可自然睡着时,又是再平常不过的事。

我用睡眠来比喻自然状态,正是看中这种简单:事情自然发生,无须另有一个主宰者负责制造或维持。在自然状态中,一切显现都是清净觉知的光明,随因缘的规律自然展开,毫不费力。看、听、感受、思考,都不需要额外的自我或真我躲在背后维持这场显现;它们的光明性并不是一件需要努力完成的事。

这个比喻所指的是离于造作,并不是说睡着就等于自然状态或解脱。睡眠不能连根拔除无明,醒来后旧有的执取也可能照样出现。自然状态,是自然临在:明与空不可分的本然显现,一切相都依缘起毫不费力地展开。明,是显现作为清净觉知的鲜活光辉;空,则是显现本身无自性,连任何被认作实有的意识也不例外。明空就在当下显现中不可分割,没有主宰者,没有自我或真我,也没有终极的背景。我们不需要刻意把“纯粹临在”或“明知”撑在那里。自然状态与睡眠相似的,是不费造作的自然展开,而不是说觉醒等于睡着。

可如果有人失眠,你对他说:“放轻松,别想太多,让自己睡着就好。”这番话可能几乎帮不上忙。道理说来简单,所指的状态却不是想要就能立刻做到。越努力逼自己放松,有时只会多添一层警觉与紧张。

修行中也会发生类似的事。我们听到“无须努力的觉知”或“自然状态”,便努力想让自己不再努力。一个细微的管理者仍忙着检查:“我够放松了吗?够临在了吗?已经停止执取了吗?”这种监督松脱的努力,反而延续了原本想要卸除的紧缩。

身体的自然节律同样是有条件的。作息、环境、摄入的物质、压力及身体状况等许多因素,都会影响睡眠。 [3]

所以,自然发生的事情,并不一定能够通过意志直接发动。简单并不代表障碍只是幻想,也不代表一句“放轻松”就能把障碍消除。

同样,解脱虽简单,却不表示可以不靠洞见。我们必须理解并看透那些使我们不断认取经验的条件与习惯模式。否则,我们听到“自然一点就好”,仍会带着那些旧有的假设去理解,并按照它们去做。

“不强求”或无为(wu wei)的说法,可以帮助我们理解离于造作。但在佛法中,要真正从根本上离于造作,仍须破除对自我与诸法本性的无明。令无执成为可能的,是解脱的智慧。

六、于所见唯有所见

佛陀对婆希耶(Bāhiya)的教导,是最清楚的指引之一。佛陀教他这样训练:于所见唯有所见,于所闻唯有所闻,于所觉与所知,也同样如此。更关键的是,经文紧接着指出:就这些经验而言,并没有一个“你”。经中记载,婆希耶闻法之后,当下获得解脱。 [4]

这绝不能简化成一种高度专注的技巧。不是盯着一个视觉对象,拼命排除其他干扰:“我只许自己专注眼前所见;别和我说话!我的注意力不能跑到别处。”

这种练习或许涉及定力,但一个高度集中的观察者,依然可以完好无损地留在那里。内心仍可能强烈感觉:“我在这边,努力把注意力锁定在那个对象上。”主客结构只是被收窄、稳定下来,并没有被看穿。

这段教导指向更根本的事实:看见不需要背后另有一个看者,听见也不需要另有一个听者站在声音之外。要证悟的,是经验从来不需要一个独立的主宰者、一个分离的自我,或一个在背后支撑它的终极真我。

我们习惯在经验上添上一层认取:“我看见这个;这是我的;它威胁到我;我必须紧抓不放。”我们还会加上一个站在所见背后的体验者。当这层实体化消失时,看见的鲜活性并不会减弱;消失的是想象中的隔阂。

无须把云朵变得更奇特,把声音变得更神圣,或让平常景色比原来更加耀眼。也不必压制念头,因为教导也涵盖了“所知”。念头同样可以如实被认识,而不必在背后另外安放一个思想者、主宰者、自我或真我。

关键的区别是:专注于显现,不等于证悟显现的本性。注意力可以极其稳定,而“有个独立观察者”的假设仍丝毫未动。

经文说的是“应当这样训练”。所以,“本来如此”不是取消修行的理由。修行帮助我们证悟:一个自性成立的观察者,从来就不存在;而不是在本来真实存在的观察者身上,暂时造出一个让它消失的状态。

七、光明就是显现本身

这就说到光明性(luminosity)了。我说的“明”,不是万物在视觉上突然更亮,也不是世界背后出现一道神秘的光。我指的是经验本身作为清净觉知的鲜活、明知的特质——颜色、声音、感受和念头当下鲜明呈现。这就是本性无心的心:明明了了,却没有一个自性成立的心、独立的知者,或自我/真我。清净觉知不是藏在显现背后的实体,也不是终极背景;它正是显现本身的鲜活明晰,与空性不可分。

但不能把这种光明变成一个“照明者”。并没有一盏叫作“觉知”的无形灯,躲在显现背后,去照亮那些被设想为若无此灯便毫无生气的对象;也没有一个意识的储存池,让各种显现从中涌出、之后再回到其中。

一切显现,都是清净觉知的光明。这种光明就是显现本身,不是由另一个源头放射出来,也不是由背景中的觉知照亮。颜色、声音、感觉和念头,就是本性无心之心的鲜活呈现——明而空,没有独立的主宰者,也没有自我或真我。颜色鲜明显现,与颜色被知晓并不是两件事;声音也不必等第二个隐藏的觉知动作随后到来,才得以显现。

一切显现都是清净觉知的自然光明,依因缘规律自然而毫不费力地展开。没有主宰者在指挥,也不需要自我或真我另外用力,让它们显现或被知晓。鲜活的显现本就是因缘的运作,不是某个人必须点亮、维持的灯光。自发显现与缘起的条件性不可分离。

所以,我有时会说“显现即是自明自知”,或“云朵本身就是自明的”。这只是描述直接体验的简便说法,不是说物质的云朵各有一个私人心灵,也不是说每个东西里面都住着一个小观察者。它所指的,是显现与知晓之间并没有一道隔阂。

“自明自知”也不是一个东西回过头来检视自身。这里没有独立的知者,没有额外的一次认知动作,也没有站在经验之外、负责替经验盖章认证的立足点。但这鲜活的显现绝非死寂、毫无明知。我们当下直接亲证并确认:意识——心——正是这鲜活的生起本身。所以我才说显现“自明自知”:它的显现本身就是清净觉知、纯粹的明知,并没有一个与之分离的知者。

有人听到“于所见唯有所见”,便以为这不过是把注意力放在眼前的普通景象上,少一点杂念、少一点分心。但关键绝不只是“有一幅景象出现了”,或“注意力很稳定”。真正关键的是直接证悟心:心的澄澈明晰、明知与光辉,就在当下的看、听、感受和思考中,除此之外别无他物。景象在视觉上不必变得奇特;所亲证的是显现本身明而知的本性,没有另外一个意识藏在后面。

如果没有直接亲证心的这份鲜活明晰,光是反复念着“唯有所见”,并不叫作证悟。而如果没有证悟并亲自确认:这份鲜活明晰就是一切显现,而不是一个与显现分开的临在,那么也谈不上真正证悟无我。定境可以使注意力收摄;短暂的不二体验可以让主客之间的界限暂时变淡。但两者本身都不能确立这种洞见。如果谈论不二,却抽掉了心当下活生生的明知,只剩下一套干巴巴的说法,就恰恰错过了真正需要直接证悟的要点。

但与此同时,“纯粹的明知”也不能成了某种精致实体的名字。它不是知者,不是背后的镜子,也不是容纳万物的场域。即使说“明知与显现不二”,如果我们心里仍想象有一个不变的本体在显现成种种形态,也还是暗中保留了实体化的想法。鲜活的明知必须亲证,它的空性也必须透彻:没有自性成立的意识,没有自性成立的诸法,没有主宰者,也没有自我/真我。

心并不是站在现象之外,去映照现象;心就是现象本身鲜活、明知的显现。声音不是呈给某个隐藏觉知的倒影;声音响起的当下,就是清净觉知的光明。这就是本性无心之心:明而空,依缘起自然而然地显现。

因此,亲证心与松脱实体化执取,原本就密不可分。明知全然现前,却不被确立为背景、容器或本体;种种显现自然展开,无须任何人去照亮、维系或加强它们的光明。它们的自然临在,正是明空不二。

看清意识无自性时,显露出来的并不是一片空白。想象中的主体不可寻得,颜色、声音、感受和念头却依然鲜明现前。空性没有抹去光明性,反而使光明性不再被错认成实体或自我。

在这里,说“显现之外没有另一个意识”,是否定某个分离的背景实体,而不是说万物都由一种叫作“意识”的形而上实体制成。后者不过是把正在被审视的那个终极根基,重新偷偷安了回来。

因此,我在这里使用“清净觉知”或“佛性”一类说法,是为了指向明空不二,而不是替某个终极的“人”、宇宙见证者或恒常本体命名。

八、无我不只是没有造作者

许多人说自己体验过“无我”,实际上所认出的,只是“没有造作者”:行动自然发生,念头自己生起,反应依条件展开,仿佛根本没有一个操控者。人可能强烈感受到,一切都自行发生。

这可以是很重要的突破。但没有操控者,不等于没有观察者。人仍可能觉得:“这些事都不是我造成的,我只是那个看着一切展开的觉知。”

这样一来,自我的某个角色虽然弱化了,另一个角色却仍在。造作者受到了质疑,体验者仍守在背景中。所以,单单体验到“没有造作者”,还不能涵盖无我的全部。

我在这里所说的证悟无我,是直接看见:鲜活显现背后,根本没有另一个独立的知者或体验者。意识被直接亲证为显现当下的鲜活明晰,而不是一个“拥有”种种显现的实体。

这不只是自我安静下来、在禅修中消散,或暂时失去边界感,而是认出:那个被假定的主体,从来就不是一个独立自存的实体。洞见所触及的是经验的本性,不只是某种感觉暂时不见了。

而看穿操控者,也不等于否定世俗层面的责任。意图、行动及其后果,仍依因缘发挥作用;不存在的,只是一个站在因缘之外、从别处发号施令的独立主宰者。

这也正好把John Tan 关于无我的两首偈颂贯通起来。第一首揭示:有活动,却没有活动背后的主宰者;第二首揭示:显现本身就是明知,不另有一个体验者。两者合起来,显出不需要操控者、也不需要见证者的光明。第一首所指的,绝不只是“被动看着事情发生”的感觉。两首都在破除对自我/真我的执取;而这份证悟,也必须进一步深入诸法空性。

这个区别很重要,因为人可能把局部的突破误当成全程的圆满。如果没有质疑那个观照者,即使一切看似自然发生,经验仍可能围绕一个极细微的中心组织起来。

九、从见证者到无边的同一临在

要理解为什么一次深刻的灵性证悟,仍可能留下执取,就需要区分人们认出光明性的不同方式。把“我是”(I AM)、不二临在、无我与空性分清,整个脉络便更清楚。

“我是”(I AM)的确定无疑

人可以直接、毫无疑惑地认出临在:在把自己认同为特定念头或身体描述之前,正在觉知这一事实已无可否认。这不只是重复一套关于觉知的观念;那份直接性可能极其强烈,令人震撼。

但人也可能把它理解成经验背后永恒不变的见证者。念头、感受和世界,仿佛都在无边无形的临在中生灭,而那份临在本身似乎不受影响。常见的比喻是:“我是大海,不是波浪。”浪起浪落,大海却被认作“我之所是”的恒常实在。

虽然原本那种“自己只是一个渺小个体”的感觉,已被浩瀚无边的体验取代,背景与前景之分却仍可能存在。觉知被当成容器,显现则成了容器中的内容。见证者即使感觉无穷广大,仍保留了一个从中知晓经验的立足点。

不二临在,仍被认作自性实有

更进一步的突破,可以让这种距离感消融。波浪不再与大海分离;万物都仿佛是同一光明临在的显现或变化。不再只是见证者站在世界之外;整个世界都被体验为同一份临在。

这与一个抽离的观察者相比,确实有重大不同。但对这种体验的理解,仍可能保留某种自性成立的本体:一个浩瀚无边的存在,化现为万事万物,却在自身本性上始终不变。

执取只是变得更微细了。不再是“我是这副有限的身心”,而是“我是显现为一切的唯一实相”。身份认同被无限放大,但“必有某个究竟成立之物”的假设,不一定已经被穿透。

无我,以及进一步透彻空性

无我不需要用一个广大真我来取代狭小的小我。显现背后没有知者,也无须把鲜活的明知归结成一种永恒实体。于所见唯有所见,于所闻唯有所闻。

然而,即使分离的主体已被看穿,人仍可能微细地把现象、临在,乃至“显现”本身实体化。因此,还必须看清一切现象的空性。不二体验、无我的证悟,以及彻底证悟人法二空,不应该被当成可以互换的名称。

我这样区分,并不是贬低任何真实的突破,而是要弄清楚:每一次突破究竟揭示了什么,又可能留下什么未被检视的假设。否则,证悟的强大震撼,很容易使我们误以为,随之而来的所有解释都不容质疑。

十、当光明成了另一道心结

光明的临在可能充满极深的喜乐。粗重的心念躁动可能平息,人也可能感到许多日常挂虑都放下了。但单凭喜乐,不能证明执取的根已经断尽。

如果把临在当成最终的身份根基,人便可能强烈地想一直安住其中。起初,这也许是刻意为之:一次又一次回到见证者的位置,维持那份觉知感,努力不让它消失。

后来,这种习惯可能不再让人觉得是刻意的。安住于其中的惯性太强,甚至仿佛停不下来。心里不一定一直想着“我必须维持觉知”,但整个身心仍围绕着保护那个微细中心而运转。

因此,不能仅仅因为感觉不到有意识地用力,就认定一种修行已经毫不费力。习惯也可以自动运作。一种执取模式可以根深蒂固,却未必会表现为明确的意图。

实际修行时,这可能被体验为一个“结”:人微细地执着于临在的强度,有时伴随着身体紧绷、压迫感、头痛、躁动,或难以入睡。有些修行人把这些感受称作“能量失衡”。抓紧觉知本身,也可能成为压力的来源。

试图整夜维持见证者的状态,就是个例子。如果人相信那个见证者才是自己的终极身份,那么稍微放松这个姿态,便仿佛会失去某种不可或缺的东西。原本让人摆脱寻常身份认同的证悟,反倒可能变成另一种持续警戒。

不二临在也可能如此。即使觉知与显现之间已经没有分隔感,人仍可能紧抓体验的强烈程度,把它视为究竟实相。紧缩未必再围绕一个微小的观察者,反而可能围绕着“有一个涵盖万有的本体”这份确信。

体验有多强烈,并不是衡量解脱的标准。一次体验可以广大、喜乐,甚至感觉比任何事物都更真实,却仍可能被当成自我身份的依据,或被抓成一个安住的根基。

不能仅仅因为执着的对象是觉知,就把那份执着误认成自然状态。

答案也不是要压制光明性。问题不在临在太鲜明,而在于无明把这种鲜明当成自性实有、必须拥有、保护和维持的东西。

十一、光明性可以充满喜乐,空性使人解脱

所以我总是回到这个区分:光明性可以充满喜乐,但能使人从执取中解脱的,是空性。这里必须说清楚:我并不是把“明”和“空”分成两个各自独立的实相,而是要指出,当人已经认出光明性,却仍把它实体化时,究竟缺少了什么。

临在的体验无论多么广大、多么确定,它有自性吗?真能找到一个独立成立的觉知吗?显现真的从自身方面就存在,还是我们把它的鲜活明晰误认为某种实体?

当它的空性被看清,光明性就不必再成为一个供人立足的地方。无须拿它作为“我是谁”的最终答案,也无须把它想成种种变化背后永远存续的实在。

这不会让经验变得呆滞。无自性的显现,照样可以无比鲜明。没有的,只是执取拼命想要抓住的那个想象中的本体。

不过,仅仅在头脑中理解空性,也同样不够。我们可能因此较少固执己见、不再那么紧抓固定的描述,或更愿意质疑自己的假设。这些都很有益,但不能与直接证悟明空不二画上等号。

如果空性始终只是一个与当下经验隔着距离的结论,那么一个知者面对世界的那套结构,可能仍几乎没有被触动。我们可以把“无自性”讲得头头是道,生活中却依然从一个未经检视的中心出发。

所以,关键既不是单独的光明性,也不是抽象的空性理论,而是直接证悟,让经验的鲜活明知与其无自性,同时清楚现前。

这才是我所说的真正证悟本性。以往被当成身份根基的那份鲜活明晰,如今无从执取。其背后没有什么可以占有;它的显现中,也没有一个能够独立成立的本体。

这份松脱,比一遍遍告诫自己“不要执着”更深。我们已经看穿一个根本的错认。过去那个被视为自身核心、似乎非得保护不可的东西,如今已无法再以我们原先想象的方式找到。

十二、缘起而无自性生

理解空性,还必须与缘起一并理解。否则,我们容易在两种错误之间摇摆:要么把显现看成独立自存的东西,要么以为空性否定了显现及其一切作用。

缘起不是说,先有一些各自成立的坚实实体,再由它们建立关系、相互产生。那样反而保留了原本要质疑的假设。就算把“独立的东西”换成一张被视为根本实在的关系网络,也没有解决问题。因缘条件和关系本身,同样无自性。

AtR 在《正确理解缘起》及《空性不是关系本体论:没有自存关系项的关系》两篇文章中,都讨论过这个区别。条件性不能被偷换成另一种实体。说某物依缘假立,并不等于就能确立一个虽依赖条件、却仍有自性核心的“实有物”。

龙树在《中论》中考察“生”,破斥从自、从他、从自他两者,以及无因而生这四种自性生的主张。他对缘起、空性与依缘假立的说明,并不是要在日常因果作用背后,另立一套隐秘的形而上机制。 [5]

在世俗层面,因缘条件确实发挥作用。行为有后果,不同条件也会带来不同的经验;从究竟观察,却找不到一个独立自存的能生者、生起过程或所生之物。这里不是两套互相竞争的说法,更不是说空性最后会取消因缘条件的作用。

这里说的“依规律展开”,只是指依因缘条件而起,并没有一个自性成立的法则制定者,也没有操控万物的心。包括修行在内的有意努力,也都是依因缘发挥作用,并不需要一个独立的主宰者。

镜中倒影或幻术的比喻,在这里很有帮助。显现可以清清楚楚地在眼前,却找不到一个以显现所暗示的方式真实成立的东西。镜中确有影像,但并没有一个实实在在的人走进镜子里。

同样,“不生”不是说一切都不显现,也不是说世俗层面根本没有事件发生,而是指没有任何现象能够凭自性而生。我们不能先设想有一个自性实有的东西生起,再试图在稍后某个时刻把它“变空”。

显现的当下就是空;依缘而起的当下,就没有自性生。无须另外再做一个动作,去剥除某种所谓的自性。

即便是最崇高的意识体验,也不例外。无论它感觉多么宇宙般广大、如海无边,或确凿得令人无法否认,鲜明的体验都不能使它免于空性。若要寻找它自性成立的本体,依然不可得;它就像鲜明却如幻的倒影,也像转瞬即散的薄雾。

所以,我们无法从经验中提炼出一个最终可以安住的实有根基,但也无须逃离经验、退入空白。显现与空性不可分,缘起与空性不可分。二谛说的不是两个各自实有的世界。

十三、如来被称为“如是者”

《迦罗迦经》(Kāḷaka Sutta)又提供了一个重要指引。经中描述,如来知晓所见、所闻、所觉、所知,却不执取它们,不把相应对象妄计为已经成立的“所见”或“所知”,也不妄立一个看者或知者。经文称如来为“如是者”(Such)。 [6]

这并不是在描述无知无觉。经文没有把知晓换成一片空白;所止息的,是那种借经验虚构自我、建立固定立场的分别妄计与执取。

所谓“如是”,就是鲜明显现,却不再妄立一个自性实有的知者,或一个自性实有的所知。

云朵出现时,不需要背后另有一个“我”站着观看;也不必把云朵确立成独立自存的对象。景象依然鲜明,却没有主客两端那种被虚构出来的实体性。

若把这一切称为“存在”的极致简单,听起来颇有吸引力;但“存在”一词又可能让人联想到我们本来就要破除的实有。我宁愿说:显现本身极其简单——清晰现前,却没有任何自性核心可供抓取。

我们不是要改善云朵、完善声音,也不是把眼前景色变得更有“灵性”。真正松脱的,是那种把自我与世界分立为两个自性成立之端的执取。

就连“如是”,也不能被当成隐藏实体的名字。它不是在一般对象消解后,又补上一个更精致的形而上对象;重点恰恰是止息那种非要找个最终立足点的冲动。

十四、知见、体验、证悟与修行

如果解脱就是破除原有的无明与执取,那是不是就不需要修行了?当然不是。仅仅在概念上理解、认同这些道理,还不足以消融根深蒂固的习气。

有纪律的禅修十分重要,持戒、认真思惟,以及愿意检视那些我们原本倾向于维护的假设,也同样重要。修行必须具备相应的因缘,使教法变成亲自明见的事实,而不只是一些令我们赞叹的描述。

但修行的强度,不等于智慧的深度。人可以长时间打坐,进入殊胜定境,把专注力练得很深,却依然不曾触动“有一个实有见证者”的假设。修行甚至可能让人更认同某种精细的境界。

说到这里,我想起圣严法师在《开悟的经验》(Experiences of Awakening)中的讨论,以及 John Tan 对它的评论。圣严法师谈到,禅定深入时,身心与世界之间平常的界限似乎会消失,带来深刻的合一感。然而,即使是无边意识与喜乐的体验,也仍可能受到微细我执的制约。这种广大的体验,反而可能把我执放大到宇宙尺度,而不是从根本上断除它。只要这种执取仍在,定境就不等于解脱的觉醒。

John Tan/Thusness:“这段说得很好。你必须学会在那样的心境中,种下无我、缘起(DO)和空性的种子,而不是种下我见。” [7]

这里的 DO 指 dependent origination(缘起)。John 强调的,是把无我、缘起与空性的知见,带入那些原本可能强化我见的境界。我们既不必否定体验,也不应把体验有多强烈,当成已经究竟证悟的证明。

对我来说,这又回到了如何把正见与直接体验贯通起来的问题。一次非凡清晰的体验,并不会因为它很不寻常,就自动得到正确的解释。如果我们把它的鲜明当成实有真我的证据,禅修反而会加固这种确信。把正见带进直接经验,就是要去审视这项假设,让清晰成为洞见的契机,而不是又一种身份认同。

正见为我们指明方向,帮助我们辨认错认发生在哪里、该检视什么。直接体验让原本停留在概念中的道理,有了切身的鲜活性。证悟则是真正看穿某项根本错认。通过持续修行,这份洞见可以逐渐得到整合,其深层含义也得以展开。

它们彼此相关,却不能混为一谈。强烈的体验可能过去了,基本知见却没有改变;真正的证悟已经发生,旧有反应和更细微的遮障却仍可能存在。至于把术语说得正确,更不代表已经有了体验或证悟。

即便“我是”(I AM)的证悟,也说明为什么这些区分不可少。那可以是对光明性真实、毫无疑惑的认出;但如果把光明性解释成终极真我,就可能形成新的束缚。确实证悟了某个面向,不代表围绕它产生的一切假设也都正确。

反过来说,能够解释为什么真我不能成立,也不等于已经穿透心中那个分离观察者的感觉结构。我们需要让知见与当下直接经验相会。

这也说明,努力与不费力必须放在具体情境中看。有些努力有助于深入探究、稳定心念,以及在面对境遇时作出合乎伦理的回应,因而是有益的;但若一再把觉知实体化成终极背景,就可能让问题更深。不能单凭用了多少力,判断修行的方向是否正确。

真正要问的是:究竟有什么变得更清楚了?修行是在揭露认取,还是只把被认取的对象磨得更精致?空性是否越来越清楚地显现在当下经验中,还是始终只是一套哲学信念,与一个未经质疑的灵性身份并存?

十五、我所说的自然状态

“自然状态”这几个字很容易被说得太轻率。有人稍稍瞥见临在,或经历一次深刻的不二突破,便立刻认为再也没有什么需要做了。然而,他仍可能把那份体验抓成一个自性实有的根基。

自然状态就是自然临在:明与空不可分,在依缘而起的种种显现中全然呈现。一切显现都是清净觉知的光明,而这份光明本身无自性。没有另外独立成立的觉知,没有自性实有的显现,也没有主宰者、自我或真我在指挥整个过程。

这里说的“明空不可分”,不是把两个原本各自独立存在的东西结合在一起。显现本身就是明而空的;它们自然展开,就是因缘的作用,并没有一个内在实有的源头藏在背后。证悟让那种把明知或显现抓成实体的执取松脱。所以,“自然”不是努力维持纯粹临在,而是因证悟明空不二而离于造作。

要认出自然状态,必须证悟人法二空:自我无自性,诸法也无自性。

而认出,也必须与彻底圆满区分。一次瞥见,不代表所有烦恼习气和所知障都已止息;即使有重大证悟,也不能因此把后来仍起作用的种种习气和因缘制约,都当作无关紧要。

烦恼障涉及令众生受苦受缚的种种模式;所知障则包括更微细的错认习气,妨碍圆满遍知。执我与执法密切相关,却不能完全等同;它们可以先后松脱。人可能已经看穿分离的自我,却仍把诸法执为自性实有;后者还须进一步透彻。

所以,粗重的个人“我”感变弱,仍然不够。人可能继续认为诸法自性成立,生灭真实成立,或存在一个称作“觉知”的终极实相。这些微细的假设,同样必须被看穿。

我说自然状态彻底圆满现前、烦恼障与所知障都毫无剩余时,指的是成佛。我并没有把初次证悟无我、不费力的临在体验,或一段不二定境,等同于佛果的圆满成就。

分清这一点,才能认真看待自然临在与自解脱,而不把它们当作跳过洞见与成熟过程的口号。自解脱也不是说有一个自我,变得特别擅长逐个放下眼前的显现。

真正的关键在于:显现不再被抓成某个自性实有、必须占有或排斥的东西。因为它无自性,执取就找不到实在的立足点。如果一面宣称“自解脱”,一面仍把觉知视为永恒背景,或把诸法认作自性实有,那只是借用了果位的语言,却没有穿透那些实体化的错认。

不能只靠学会描述修行成果的词汇,就跳过不可或缺的洞见。把一种体验称为“自然状态”,不会自动消除其中尚存的实体化执取。

每个人的修行道路,未必都依照一模一样的机械顺序展开;但无明必须真正被破除,这一点无法绕过。不论这样的认出如何展开,还必须证知:所认出的光明性本身无自性。

十六、从百般执取归于零

我们常把修行想成从一走向一百:知识更多、体验更多、力量更大、把握更足,对灵性身份的认同也越来越强。但也许更贴切的比喻,是从百般执取,一点一点归于零。

这里的“零”,不是虚无,不是脑中空白、显现消失,或失去知晓与回应的能力;它是说,附加在经验上的执取、认取和实体化,不再主导整个经验。

显露出来的,并不是一个被削弱的世界,而恰恰是当下鲜活的展开:明而空,没有独立的主宰者,也没有一个作为中心或背景而成立的自我/真我。

拳头张开了,热炭放下了,金色城堡也不必再建。睡眠的比喻所提示的那份自然,不再被误解成必须用力制造的状态。不过,解脱与睡眠不同:解脱依靠智慧,而不是暂时忘了心头的种种挂虑。

这就是我想表达的悖论:解脱极其简单,但遮蔽这份简单的无明,却深受因缘条件制约。我们不能单靠重复正确的话,就在头脑里把自己“想”进解脱;也不能只凭加大体验强度,就硬把自己“逼”进解脱。

我们需要正见、直接证悟,并通过修行不断整合这份证悟。我们需要光明性的鲜活,却不能把它抓成真我;需要空性的解脱智慧,却不能把它降为抽象观念或一片虚无。

因此,所谓“卸除”的修行之路,并不是逐步毁掉生命,而是松开那种一直错认、执取生命的方式。

从百般执取归于零——而这个“零”,原来就是经验明而空的鲜活展开:没有独立主宰者,没有自我/真我,也没有一个自性实有的根基可供攀附。

于所见唯有所见,于所闻唯有所闻。显现背后没有另一个知者,显现之中没有自性实有的东西,显现之下也没有隐藏的源头。极致的简单,从来不需要我们费力制造;真正需要卸除的,是那个使我们不断执取的无明。

参考资料与延伸阅读

  1. 缘起:《SN 12.2:缘起分析》,Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu(坦尼沙罗尊者)英译。本文引用的十二支公式、六类识及还灭次第,均可参看此经;经中以不知四圣谛来界定无明。
  2. 菩萨第八地:《轮状之道:阿底峡〈入菩萨行论〉注释》,尤其是“第八地:不动地”部分,可参照其中关于任运事业与先前誓愿的讨论。
  3. 影响睡眠的条件:美国国家心肺血液研究所:失眠的原因与风险因素。概述影响睡眠的各类条件。
  4. 佛陀对婆希耶的教导:《自说经》1.10《婆希耶经》,Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu 英译。经文不只说“于所见唯有所见”,还联系到其中并无一个“你”,并明确说要这样训练。
  5. 空性与生起:龙树,《中论》(选章),Geshe Kelsang Wangmo 译;特别参见第一品与第二十四品(包括 24.18)。另可参阅 AtR 的《正确理解缘起》及《空性不是关系本体论:没有自存关系项的关系》。
  6. 明知而不妄立知者:《增支部》AN 4.24《迦罗迦经》,Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu 英译。
  7. 禅定、我见与解脱的洞见:《开悟的经验——圣严法师》,2022 年 9 月 12 日刊于 Awakening to Reality。第 14 节概述圣严法师的教导,并收录 John Tan 的完整相关评论(英文略经编辑)。DO 指 dependent origination,即缘起。

AtR 相关阅读:《论无我、空性、摩诃(大)、平常与自然圆成》;《辨析 I AM、一心、无心与无我》。

本次转写实验使用的工具:Cosmic Transcriber + CloudScribe Pro:下载与使用指南。

John Tan on Emptiness, Dependent Arising, Right View, and Non-Meditation

By
John Tan · Emptiness · Dependent Arising

John Tan on Emptiness, Dependent Arising, Right View, and Non-Meditation

A comprehensive synopsis of the 27 June 2026 Zoom meeting

Edited, source-faithful synopsis · Research references verify named texts and concepts, not John Tan’s realization claims

Editorial and attribution note

This synopsis was reconciled from multiple supplied transcript witnesses. No single machine transcript is treated as controlling. Wording is resolved by convergence across witnesses, contextual and grammatical fit, Buddhist/technical-term coherence, and speaker continuity; the fine-grained diarized version is especially useful for turn boundaries and attribution, but is not assumed to be more accurate word-for-word.

The high-confidence John Tan mapping is: Parts 1–13, Speaker A; Part 14, Speaker B; Part 15, Speaker A; Parts 16–17, Speaker B; Part 18, Speaker A; Part 19, Speaker B; and Part 20, Speaker A. The strongest internal checks include “John Tan’s mosquito” being addressed to Part 15 Speaker A, and Part 16 Speaker A referring to “John” immediately before Speaker B answers in the first person about choosing the five core logics.

This synopsis distinguishes John’s statements from other participants’ remarks, personal interpretations, traditional anecdotes, speculative comparisons, and independently verifiable textual context. At the author’s request, other participants are not named except in the dedicated translation-prompts section.

Where the user directly re-listened to a disputed phrase, that audio check is treated as stronger phonetic evidence than conflicting ASR for that phrase. This applies especially to John’s colloquial “half-boiled-egg / half-egged” wording and to “mine” rather than “mind” in the MMK chapter-18 discussion. Speaker identity itself is established separately through diarization, direct address, autobiographical/topic continuity, and cross-Part handoffs.

Later authorial context — John Tan’s new, as-yet-unreleased book manuscript:

A methodological note from John’s new manuscript explains that the larger project is organized in five parts: Part One develops the sustained argument from the collapse of the observer through dependent designation and causality; Part Two, Three Formations, applies the logic contemplatively through the mountain, flower, and space; Part Three, Nothing to Find, Nothing Missing, is a shorter introductory companion; Part Four, Science and the Dharma, places the argument beside modern physics and cognitive science while distinguishing resonance from proof; and an Appendix develops the formal and linguistic scaffolding, including how ordinary grammar can reconstruct substance.

The same note explicitly describes the book as a personal philosophical synthesis developed in continuity with Madhyamaka and Dzogchen—not a translation, commentary, or scholarly exposition of Nāgārjuna, Candrakīrti, Tsongkhapa, Mipham, Dōgen, or Dzogchen as a whole. The local notes below therefore matter: they identify which recurring distinctions are John’s own pedagogical or organizing devices rather than classical categories he is claiming to reproduce verbatim.

The central argument

John is not presenting luminous nonduality or anatta as the endpoint. A practitioner can have radiance, seamlessness, anatta, and total-exertion experiences while the framework used to analyse those experiences still treats objects, space, time, consciousness, or even fluid process in an inherent way.

The later work is to bring experience and right view into alignment while understanding why empty phenomena remain conventionally valid, appearing, and functional. Emptiness is not blank absence: John argues that essence or a core would make arising, interaction, communication, and appearance impossible.

Detailed contents
  1. The universality of emptiness and genuine non-meditation
  2. Signs of maturation and the distinction between phases five and six
  3. The desynchronization between experience and view
  4. Spiritual bypassing: saying “empty” without understanding why
  5. What John actually says about Longchenpa and judging masters
  6. John’s own gap after anatta and total exertion
  7. Conceptual designation and dependent designation
  8. The apple as a multidimensional designation
  9. Designation without naming and labelling
  10. AI as a research interlocutor, not an authority
  11. Relation without independently existing relata
  12. Why phase six is analytical
  13. Why anatta and noun-to-verb fluidity are not the endpoint
  14. Why essence would make arising and interaction impossible
  15. The “half-boiled-egg” / “half-egged” view
  16. Arising, ceasing, and the analysis of time
  17. Three criteria for investigating a phenomenon
  18. Why John insists on the two truths
  19. Hidden inherent views concerning space and time
  20. Deconstructing “I” and “mine”: possessive mineness and possession
  21. How John uses the MMK tetralemma to expose inherent thinking
  22. The danger of relentless negation and attachment to groundlessness
  23. Causal efficacy without inherent causal power
  24. Conventionality becomes crucial when no substrate remains
  25. Conceptuality, pure perception, and non-meditation
  26. What continues to drive John’s practice
  27. His reaction to Soh’s translation prompts
  28. Refining right view so that experience can open further
  29. Mipham, Tsongkhapa, translation, and traditional anecdotes
  30. John’s qualified suggestion for using AI with difficult books
  31. John’s selection of five core logics
  32. Infinite regress, scientific “stuff,” and designation upon characteristics
  33. Niels Bohr and Karen Barad: corrected names, comparison, and conjecture
  34. The organization of John’s video material and its AI-oriented component
  35. His reservations about public circulation of the videos

Part I · From Nondual Experience to the Need for Emptiness

1. The universality of emptiness and genuine non-meditation

John begins from the universality of emptiness. He says emptiness is not restricted to one domain: all phenomena are empty. When that is seen universally, there is “no entry” and “no exit,” no distance to be crossed, and no special effort by which one moves into a separate meditative state.

John explicitly includes appearances divided as inside and outside and gives the examples of wind and a blower: all are empty and dependently originated.

He explicitly qualifies this as his own perspective: it may not be the perspective of Mahāmudrā, Dzogchen, or other practices. His concern is that, without realizing emptiness, it is very difficult to go beyond construing luminosity as consciousness or luminous clarity.

Seeing every appearance as empty is therefore, in his view, what allows one to speak of genuine non-meditation. Even so, John says he still meditates although he considers himself to be in a state of non-meditation.

Back to top

2. Signs of maturation and the distinction between phases five and six

Asked how someone recognizes deepening insight, John says there may be signs, although the practitioner ultimately knows through growing confidence and an opening of insight. One sign he gives is simply that “everything” is seen as “very light.” He does not define that phrase further at that point, so it is best left as his experiential description rather than turned into a more technical criterion.

He then distinguishes phase-five and phase-six insight. Phase five is characterized by radiance, nonduality, direct clarity, and recurring moments of what he calls “mini total exertion.” His example is ordinary: when a door opens or an MRT train moves, the vibration, the train, and “everything” can be experienced as one presentation.

This can be a profound opening, but the experiential taste may be far stronger than the practitioner’s view. Phase six addresses precisely that imbalance by investigating the framework through which experience is understood.

Back to top

3. The desynchronization between experience and view

John describes a fundamental desynchronization among direct experience, insight, and the framework used to analyse and articulate that experience. Someone may experience seamlessness and anatta while ordinary analysis continues to treat the computer, phone, and other appearances as isolated external objects. Later in the meeting he exposes additional inherited assumptions concerning space, time, relation, and substrate.

Nondual experience does not automatically remove those assumptions. John’s point is that the analysis itself can continue to operate through the old framework even when the experiential taste of seamlessness or anatta is present. The framework therefore has to be examined and retrained rather than assumed to disappear through experience alone.

He does not dogmatically claim that explicit analysis is the only conceivable route. Vajrayāna and other approaches may operate in ways he does not claim to assess completely. His narrower point is autobiographical and practical: in his own experience, it is extremely difficult to move beyond the residual framework without investigating it directly.

Later unreleased-book clarification — “desynchronization” is John’s own diagnostic framework:

John’s manuscript says that the underlying phenomenon—realization and conceptual view developing at different rates—is recognized in various forms across contemplative traditions, but the specific framing as a “desynchronization of view, experience, and insight” is his own construction.

He uses it as the organizing engine of the book: direct contemplative experience such as anatta or total exertion can be complete while the conceptual framework interpreting it remains, unnoticed, substantialist. He offers this formulation because he finds it clarifying and accurate to how the process unfolds, not because “desynchronization” is a classical technical term.

Back to top

4. Spiritual bypassing: saying “empty” without understanding why

John repeatedly criticizes spiritual bypassing. Here the problem is claiming to understand because one can repeat that “everything is empty,” while the underlying analysis and framework have never been penetrated. His recurring challenge is concrete: if one says everything or all conditions are empty, can one actually explain why?

His immediate test is simple: if one says that everything is empty, why is it empty? Why are conditions empty? If one cannot investigate that and the analysis, logic, interpretation, and understanding are not integrated, John says the claim may amount to something memorized rather than penetrated.

The recurring practical standard is sincerity: recognize where experience is present but understanding is not, and investigate rather than bypassing the unresolved point.

Back to top

5. What John actually says about Longchenpa and judging masters

John first singles Malcolm out as someone who has tried very hard to articulate these matters clearly. He then reports that Malcolm had quoted or interpreted Longchenpa as treating external reality as true. Another participant reacts by saying they would not dare conclude from this that Longchenpa did not understand emptiness. John agrees that it is extremely difficult to comment on masters such as Longchenpa, Tsongkhapa, and Mipham without deep practice and a clear understanding of deconstruction.

John does not resolve the textual dispute or accuse Longchenpa of substantialism. He redirects the discussion to the practitioner’s own understanding: even if one can repeat that Longchenpa or another master said something, does one actually see why phenomena and conditions are empty? Merely citing an authority is not a substitute for integrating experience, reasoning, and view.

Later, John gives his personal assessment that Candrakīrti, Mipham, and Tsongkhapa express Nāgārjuna’s meaning with exceptional clarity. This is his evaluation, not a neutral ranking across Buddhist traditions.

Back to top

Part II · Dependent Designation and the Reconstruction of View

6. John’s own gap after anatta and total exertion

John uses his own development as the central example. For several years after anatta, he experienced repeated moments of mini-total-exertion. Later, total exertion itself became very clear. He had the taste and the direct insight, but knew that his view had not caught up.

When he encountered the chariot exchange between Nāgasena and King Milinda, he immediately recognized a connection with total exertion. Yet he could not initially explain the view underlying it. His response was not to pretend that intuitive recognition amounted to understanding. He knew the teaching was pointing toward something correct, that it corresponded to his experience, and that it supplied a missing element—but he also knew he did not yet understand why.

The question that seized him was not merely whether the chariot had a referent. It was more specific: why must the designation be said to depend upon the parts? That question became a doorway into his later investigation.

John says he kept pursuing the discrepancy rather than treating the chariot passage as understood. He recalls asking Andre and others on Facebook why the label is not simply referring to the object itself and why, instead, the label must be said to be designated upon parts.

Textual verification: In the Milindapañha, “chariot” is explained as a conventional designation used in dependence upon the pole, axle, wheels, body, and other constituents, rather than as an additional entity separate from them. See SuttaCentral, Mil 3.1.1.
Later unreleased-book clarification — the “logic of the single stroke” is an organizing device of John’s own:

In the manuscript John says that reading Nāgasena’s chariot as containing the later argument in miniature—no residue, exhaustive conditionality, mutual dependence, full function without essence, and no independent core—is his own way of organizing the material.

He explicitly does not present this as a claim about how the chariot dialogue was originally intended or how it has traditionally been read. It is a reading he has found illuminating and uses to structure the subsequent argument.

Back to top

7. Conceptual designation and dependent designation

In ordinary life, people do not consciously think that they designate things upon parts and conditions. When someone says “apple,” the ordinary assumption is that a complete apple already exists, the mind sees it, and the word is then attached to that object. The same model is applied to a mouse, controller, train, or body.

John calls the ordinary model conceptual designation: the object is taken to be there as a whole and the label is then “slapped onto” it. What he is trying to understand under dependent designation is different: designation is spoken of in dependence upon bases such as parts, causes and conditions, rather than upon a self-established whole that is already there.

John emphasizes how radical this shift would be. He says that ordinarily “we never think this way”; if one truly saw phenomena in terms of parts, causes, and conditions in the way he is describing, one would already be seeing dependent arising. He rhetorically adds that one would be “already enlightened,” provided one truly understood it.

John initially recognized dependent designation through total exertion—the entirety of conditions presenting as this particular event—but he knew that this experiential recognition did not yet explain the mechanism completely.

Context: Nāgārjuna’s analysis is widely interpreted as rejecting an ontological foundation beneath dependently arisen phenomena. MMK 24.18 famously links dependent arising, emptiness, and dependent designation, although its precise interpretation is debated. See the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Nāgārjuna and a recent Journal of Indian Philosophy study.
Later unreleased-book clarification — “conceptual designation versus dependent designation” is a pedagogical distinction, not a classical Madhyamaka division:

John’s manuscript states this very plainly: classical Madhyamaka does not separate “conceptual designation” and “dependent designation” into two rival categories. Its position is that all designation is dependent designation.

The contrast used throughout John’s book—“thing first, label second” versus a structure in which the thing and its designation arise dependently—is therefore his own pedagogical separation, designed to help a reader approach the insight. He does not claim that Nāgārjuna or Candrakīrti formulated this two-category scheme themselves.

What he regards as continuous with the classical conclusion is the endpoint toward which the distinction is meant to lead: there is no self-established thing to which a label is subsequently attached; designation is dependent.

Back to top

8. The apple as a multidimensional designation

John develops the distinction through an apple. Ordinary cognition treats the apple as a single whole object standing outside the observer. In his account, however, what is called “apple” presents through multiple experiential dimensions: colour and visual consciousness, bodily sensation, taste, and the other streams of sensory consciousness involved in the encounter.

John says these sensory dimensions form bases of designation. His contrast is with the ordinary way of taking the apple as a complete object that is already there and then attaching the label to that whole object.

The example therefore returns to his central question: why does Madhyamaka speak of designation upon bases, parts, causes, and conditions when ordinary cognition feels as though it simply encounters a whole object and names it? Merely moving the analysis down to atoms would not by itself answer that question.

Back to top

9. Designation without naming and labelling

A further trigger came when John was reading Tsongkhapa and encountered Tibetan Buddhist language about conceptuality and freedom from conceptual elaboration in connection with emptiness. He says this came as a shock because he had been understanding designation in the ordinary sense of conceptual labelling. It forced a more basic question: what does “designation” mean in Tibetan Buddhism, and if there is no naming or labelling, is there still designation?

John’s next question was whether designation can operate without verbal naming or deliberate labelling. He imagines a world in which everything is blue. Without contrast, blue is not distinguished as a particular feature. When green appears, the contrast becomes manifest immediately, even before anyone invents or applies the words “blue” and “green.”

The important point for John is simply that difference and structure are already manifest before verbal naming. He calls this “designation without naming and labelling.” In this article the phrase is treated as John’s own analytical formulation in the meeting, not as a standardized technical translation.

Designation therefore cannot simply mean consciously attaching a word. This is why he challenged the idea that removing conceptual labelling by itself would amount to enlightenment.

John treats this as foundational rather than peripheral: “without understanding all these, you cannot understand dependent origination.”

Later unreleased-book clarification — “designation by relation” is also John’s personal synthesis:

The manuscript distinguishes designation-by-thought from designation-by-relation and proposes that structural, non-conceptual individuation can operate prior to explicit conceptual labelling. John explicitly says that this does not appear as a formal division in classical Madhyamaka sources.

He presents it as a personal synthesis in continuity with the tradition, not as orthodox doctrine. The unreleased manuscript describes this with a blue-and-yellow contrast; in the 27 June meeting summarized above, his spoken example uses blue and green. The difference is retained rather than silently harmonized.

Back to top

10. AI as a research interlocutor, not an authority

John says he kept these questions largely within his own investigation and contemplation. He says they were not things he could simply find settled in books or go to teachers and ask to have resolved for him; they were part of his personal investigation. Much of the inquiry remained in contemplation and notes without being fully put into words because he found verification difficult.

When more capable AI systems appeared, he began questioning them repeatedly: telling them to search as widely as they could, challenging the answers, and checking again and again what “designation” meant in Tibetan Buddhist usage. He says the distinction gradually became clearer, including the point that designation need not mean verbal naming.

In this part of the meeting AI functions as a tool for searching and checking an inquiry that John had already been contemplating; he does not present the AI’s first answer as authoritative.

Back to top

11. Relation without independently existing relata

A further problem then arose: if independently existing things cannot be found, how are dependence and relation possible? The ordinary model assumes that entity A exists, entity B exists, and a relation subsequently connects them. John challenges the assumption that A and B are already fully constituted before the relation.

John’s formulation is that “you,” “I,” “this,” and “that” come about in the meeting or relation itself rather than first standing there as fully established things and only later entering interaction. He compares this with Karen Barad’s language of intra-action, where the relata are not assumed to pre-exist the relation.

He explicitly limits this discussion to the conventional level. He is not proposing relation as a new ultimate ground; at the ultimate level, he says, it is emptiness.

Comparison verified: Barad’s “intra-action” is explicitly contrasted with interaction because interaction presumes independently existing relata. A concise scholarly explanation is available from Cultural Anthropology.
Back to top

12. Why phase six is analytical

John calls phase six analytical because, after anatta and total exertion, one has to challenge the existing framework of understanding and find out more exactly what dependent arising and emptiness mean.

The surrounding examples that feed this phase-six inquiry include dependent designation, designation without naming and labelling, relation without independently established relata, and later causal efficacy without intrinsic causal power. John’s emphasis is that these are not merely new concepts to collect; they expose something fundamentally wrong in the way the old framework analyses experience.

For him, this is why Madhyamaka goes deeper than the initial anatta insight. The experience may already be nondual, but the framework can still visualize reality inherently unless it too is penetrated.

Back to top

Part III · Beyond Anatta, Fluidity, and Hidden Substrates

13. Why anatta and noun-to-verb fluidity are not the endpoint

John illustrates the comparatively direct anatta point with examples such as: there is no wind apart from blowing—the blowing is the wind; there is no lightning apart from flashing—the flashing is the lightning; and there is no separate listener behind sound.

His warning is that even after anatta and total exertion, a practitioner without clear view can still imagine reality as something fluid—like water, or like wind flowing. John says this is still an inherent view.

So the move from noun to verb is not yet enough. The flowing or fluid process must not become the new substrate. John’s “ninety-nine percent” remark is rhetorical emphasis, not a measured statistic.

Back to top

14. Why essence would make arising and interaction impossible

John says the practitioner has to become clear that if there were essence or a core, it would be impossible for something to arise, interact, communicate, or even appear.

His argument is deliberately functional: an independently fixed essence would be incompatible with the dependent arising and interaction that are actually being discussed. He repeatedly asks how anything could arise at all if it had such a core.

This is why he treats the absence of essence not as the destruction of functioning, but as inseparable from the possibility of dependent arising and interaction. He wants this to become a clear conviction rather than a slogan.

Later, John restates the issue in terms of appearance itself. He says it is “very difficult to understand the nature of what appears”: when sound appears, its nature is a lack of essence, yet this is difficult to see as long as the inherent framework and its logic continue to govern the analysis.

Later unreleased-book extension — spontaneous presence and dependent arising:

John’s later manuscript goes beyond the specific argument made in this Zoom section. It argues that Dzogchen’s spontaneous presence (lhun grub) and Madhyamaka’s dependent arising are the same nature under two descriptions, and that Dzogchen direct introduction can be understood as the experiential actualization of what Madhyamaka analysis points toward.

Crucially, John himself labels this a confident personal synthesis rather than settled cross-tradition doctrine. He notes that other lineages and commentators regard Dzogchen as its own resultant vehicle and do not reduce it to, or regard it as guaranteed by, Madhyamaka analysis alone.

Back to top

15. The “half-boiled-egg” / “half-egged” view

John uses a colloquial metaphor for a mixed, only partly worked-out view. After the user’s direct re-listening of the recording, the preferred reading is “half-boiled-egg view,” also shortened in John’s speech to “half-egged.” The automatic transcripts disagree sharply, producing forms such as “half boy,” “half-egot,” and the earlier editorial normalization “half-void, half-ego.”

John immediately explains what he means: partly we take things as inherent, and partly as non-inherent. The metaphor therefore describes a view that is only half-formed or “half-cooked”: the practitioner has some insight into emptiness while the old inherent framework continues operating.

His point is not a contrast between “void” and “ego.” It is the inconsistency of simultaneously relying on inherent assumptions and non-inherent insight. Until ultimate analysis is applied clearly, he says, we do not really understand how reality differs from the way we habitually imagine it.

Transcription note: Because the ASR witnesses conflict, this wording is retained as an audio-relisten correction rather than claimed from the machine transcripts themselves. John’s immediately following explanation—partly inherent, partly non-inherent—fits the “half-cooked” metaphor.
Back to top

16. Arising, ceasing, and the analysis of time

John uses the question: “A moment ceases as it arises. Does it arise, or does it cease?” The question exposes the instability of ordinary categories. He connects it with Nāgārjuna’s examination of time: the past is gone, the future has not arrived, and the present appears to remain.

But if the present has duration, it can be divided into earlier and later portions. If it has no duration, in what sense can a present moment be established? Likewise, if a moment ceases in the very act of arising, should it be classified as arising or as ceasing?

John explicitly says Nāgārjuna is not saying that nothing exists. His point is that there is a fundamental problem with the way ordinary language and analysis frame time and phenomena. He then moves directly from this problem into the three criteria for understanding a phenomenon in the next section.

John also gives this question an autobiographical history: he says he had posed it to a participant roughly twenty years earlier and had asked it repeatedly over the years. He uses the long-running exchange to emphasize his practical point that hearing a Madhyamaka question is not the same as actually investigating it.

Back to top

17. Three criteria for investigating a phenomenon

John offers three connected criteria for penetrating a phenomenon:

  1. Do not begin by demanding “What is it?” John says that in a completely substrateless world, the very demand for a final “what” is already conditioned by the framework.
  2. It is unfindable. His wording here is that it cannot be found in conception or perception; nevertheless, there is appearance.
  3. It does not originate without conditions. Whatever appears is not independent of conditions.

John says these three points must be penetrated together; from there, one can understand the phenomenon through the two truths.

John then gives a revealing example of how a question can already carry the framework it is supposed to investigate: when one asks “Who am I?”, the question is already conditioned by the assumption of a “who.” He uses this to illustrate his broader point that analysis is often shaped in advance by the framework through which the question is asked.

Back to top

18. Why John insists on the two truths

John says that penetrating those three criteria leads into the two truths, and he states that he is “very against one truth.” His own emphasis is functional: ultimately phenomena are empty, while conventionally they appear, are valid, and function.

For John, emptiness therefore cannot be separated from dependent arising. If everything is empty, one must also see how conventional appearances arise and function rather than stopping at negation.

Doctrinal context: Scholarly treatments of Madhyamaka distinguish conventional truth—dependently arisen, transactionally effective phenomena—from ultimate analysis, which finds them empty of intrinsic nature. See the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on the two truths in India.
Back to top

19. Hidden inherent views concerning space and time

John insists that people do think inherently even when they say they do not. His concrete examples are space and time: we imagine space as an absolute container holding objects, and time as a large stream in which we are situated and which flows in one direction.

Because these assumptions feel obvious, simply denying that we hold inherent views prevents learning. John says they have to be exposed and worked through.

John then groups several of his own formulations together—“relation without relata,” “designation without naming,” and “causal efficacy without causal power”—and explicitly calls them important understandings of dependent arising. They are his explanatory formulations rather than standard translations of fixed classical expressions.

John also returns to hearer and sound. He says there is hearer and sound and that they “dependently originate”; one cannot have sound without hearer. He notes that the MMK analysis and the language of anatta may initially sound different, but says they are pointing to the same thing or the same experience. He then adds that the initial experience of anatta is not yet total.

Later manuscript perspective on these formulations:

The unreleased manuscript reinforces the caution already used in this synopsis: expressions such as “designation without naming,” “designation by relation,” and the wider architecture connecting these analyses are John’s own explanatory constructions. Their purpose is to articulate dependent arising without smuggling an independently existing entity back into the relation; they should not be mistaken for standardized classical category labels.

Back to top

20. Deconstructing “I” and “mine”: possessive mineness and possession

John recalls an earlier exchange in which his intended statement was: “I don’t have an ‘I,’ but I have ‘mine.’” Some automatic transcripts render the last word as mind, but the surrounding discussion repeatedly returns to “I and mine” and “the possession.” The coherent reading—and the user’s audio correction—is mine, not mind.

The issue is therefore possessive mineness or possession, not a residual entity called mind. John then connects this with MMK chapter 18, where he understands freedom or deconstruction of “I” and “mine” as connected with freedom from grasping and conceptual elaboration.

What struck John was precisely that further connection. He says, “That part I still don’t quite understand,” and takes the discrepancy as evidence that his own taste and insight of anatta were not complete. The point should therefore not be reduced to a claim that one specific remaining possession had simply been identified and solved; the unresolved relation between “I/mine,” grasping, and conceptual elaboration is what drove the inquiry.

Textual verification: Niisaku’s study of MMK 18.2 renders the relevant expression as freedom from the sense of “mine” and the sense of “I” through the calming of the self and what belongs to the self. See Yoshiaki Niisaku, “Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, Chapter 18, Verse 2 and the Prasannapadā’s Commentary Thereon”.
Back to top

Part IV · Reading Nāgārjuna Without Falling into Negation

21. How John uses the MMK tetralemma to expose inherent thinking

John says the MMK is difficult and that its logic has to be understood as a challenge to inherent thinking. In this part of the meeting, another participant supplies the specific comparison with being accustomed to textbooks; John’s own contribution is the explanation of what the fourfold analysis is doing.

John says that if inherent production is pushed to its logical extreme, the possibilities are exhausted by a fourfold analysis. In his own audible list he mentions production from self, from other, neither self nor other, and random/uncaused production; elsewhere in the exchange another participant gives the familiar self/other/both/neither formulation. John’s key example is self-production: if something were produced from itself, production would be unnecessary.

He stresses that Nāgārjuna is not negating causal efficacy. The analysis is meant to show that something is wrong with the way inherent thinking understands production. If none of the four inherent alternatives works, John says one has to question how functioning actually occurs rather than simply invent another hidden kind of 'stuff'.

John later summarizes the scope of the MMK challenge in his own words: it challenges “self, element, condition, noble truth, all sorts of things… identity.” His point is that the inherent framework is not being questioned only in one philosophical corner; the same style of analysis is applied across many kinds of phenomena.

John separately says that studying the MMK is not easy and depends on each person’s affinity (各自的缘分). He says this understanding can take many years because it is gradual rather than like an insight that suddenly lands all at once; once one has gone through it, however, many things become clearer and smoother.

Back to top

22. The danger of relentless negation and attachment to groundlessness

John explicitly calls this a problem with modern non-implicative negation. It is easy, he says, to see that relation is empty, self is empty, entities are empty, and objects are empty; then whenever something is formulated, one simply says not to attach to it because that too is empty.

He calls treating relentless negation as the way “incurable,” linking the warning to what he calls the emptiness of emptiness.

Repeated this way, one can wrongly treat groundlessness as emptiness. John says people can turn emptiness into an “ultimate solvent” for dissolving every attachment. After another participant asks whether this is nihilistic, John answers that it is nihilistic and “very, very dangerous.” For him, this is only half the story: attachment to mere negation means one is not seeing dependent arising.

The difficult part, he says, is seeing the formation itself and knowing that the formation is empty—not merely negating each thing that appears.

Back to top

23. Causal efficacy without inherent causal power

John connects causal efficacy with the objection in MMK chapter 24 that emptiness would make the Noble Truths and functioning impossible. His response is the reverse: because things are empty, they can function and interact.

He illustrates this with two phantom-like figures fighting, where one phantom can apparently hurt the other even though both phenomena lack essence. This is what he means by causal efficacy without an intrinsic causal power.

Text-title caution: John’s spoken title for the phantom example is garbled in the transcripts (one witness hears something like “dispelling of the truth”). The source list therefore includes Jan Westerhoff’s Oxford University Press edition of Nāgārjuna’s Vigrahavyāvartanī (The Dispeller of Disputes) only as a plausible textual comparison/identification, not as a certain reconstruction of the audio title.
Back to top

24. Conventionality becomes crucial when no substrate remains

John asks what becomes most important if there is no ultimate reality, substrate, thing, or essence. His answer is conventionality, and he immediately links this with the importance of the two truths.

He explicitly rejects the dismissive response, “Oh, it is just conventional.” Because everything is empty, he says, conventionality becomes very important; in that discussion he also uses the phrase “of equal status.” The point is that conventional validity is not a disposable remainder after emptiness has been established.

He describes conventions as valid, appearing, and functioning. The shift in view is from taking something as concretely true to seeing something that appears and is unfindable: empty ultimately, while valid, functional, and appearing conventionally.

John describes the work as emptying conventional appearance—whether perception or conception—of inherence. Ignorance, in his formulation, projects onto the conventional something that is not there: inherentness.

Because there is no ultimate reality, he says, “the basis of the conventional reality is still conventionality” and “there’s no ending to it.” He says Tsongkhapa puts this emphasis on conventionality very clearly, while also stressing the depth of both Tsongkhapa and Mipham.

Back to top

25. Conceptuality, pure perception, and non-meditation

John says that once conventionality is understood this way, one is no longer worried about either conceptual conventionalities or pure perception—the luminous clarity free from conceptual or symbolic layering. His wording is that “it doesn’t matter anymore.”

He connects this directly with non-meditation: once conceptual conventionalities and pure perception no longer pose this problem, he says one can be in a state of non-meditation.

Back to top

Part V · Practice, Study, AI, and Publication Responsibility

26. What continues to drive John’s practice

Asked what he is trying to better or maintain, John answers directly: “I’m not trying to better or maintain anything.” He says his phases of insight are driven by what he does not understand.

He says a practitioner must be sincere, avoid spiritual bypassing, and open oneself. Asked what “open up” means, he answers: open the body-mind, thoughts, and attachments. He calls opening oneself “the toughest thing in the world” and “the greatest art.”

Going deeply into what remains unresolved leads him to say that “there’s no ending” and “life has no ending.” He contrasts this with a modern tendency to treat some practice or realization in this life as though everything were finished. As his view became clearer and his experience opened, he says he practised even harder.

The same deepening produces greater respect rather than greater license to pronounce on Buddhism. John says his confidence in the Buddha, Nāgārjuna, Tsongkhapa, Mipham, and other masters becomes very high because he is struck by how deeply they saw and how they were able to express it. He warns against speaking arrogantly or irresponsibly about what Buddhism is.

Back to top

27. His reaction to Soh’s translation prompts

Near the end, John says that he likes Soh’s translation prompt and thinks it must have been developed over years.

Across the exchange, John variously describes the prompt as ten or twenty pages, “like a whole book,” more than or almost one hundred pages, and says he has never seen a prompt of that length. He also speculates about or asks whether it is auto-self-generating, rather than asserting that point as a settled fact. See the translation-prompt page.

Comment by Soh: My automated AI workflow is doing work for me 24/7 even when I am away from the computer.

John’s substantive assessment is positive toward the translation work: he says the blog should focus on translation, notes that the developed prompt can do good translations, and contrasts this with publicly circulating his unfinished video material.

Other participants supply most of the jokes about whether an AI can tolerate such an instruction, being treated like a feelingless robot, and the water and energy consumed by extensive AI use. The final encouragement to meditate and rest is also spoken by another participant after John says that he has to leave; it should not be attributed to John.

Back to top

28. Refining right view so that experience can open further

In the later discussion, John tells a participant to refine the view and let the view open. He says that once one is able to see more clearly, experience itself changes.

He explains why he considers this important: the ordinary view is dualistic and inherent, and because that view is harboured, experience appears through it and is easily misinterpreted. As understanding and confidence in right view grow, the mind opens and one sees more clearly.

John therefore warns against jumping prematurely to “no view”: first understand right view and develop confidence in it. He tells the participant that experiences and dreams of clarity are already present, but the view is weak; refining and opening the view is what he says will allow the experience to go further.

He recommends beginning with Mipham, while emphasizing that Mipham is not easy to understand and that the Madhyamaka polemics themselves had given him many insights.

Back to top

29. Mipham, Tsongkhapa, translation, and traditional anecdotes

John recommends serious engagement with Mipham and says that Mipham’s writings and the Madhyamaka polemics gave him many insights. During the exchange, the participants identify Karma Phuntsho’s Mipham’s Dialectics and the Debates on Emptiness and Mipham’s Beacon of Certainty; the full book title is supplied by another participant while John recognizes and discusses the works.

John describes his own engagement with these polemics as long-running rather than casual: he says he underlined the passages and kept thinking through what the disputants were talking about over many years, roughly the past decade, because the texts are very difficult to understand without discussion.

John warns against casually calling Mipham a substantialist and says that how a passage sounds can depend heavily on the translator. He says Mipham knows the MMK “inside out.” Later he contrasts the Nyingma emphasis, which integrates luminous clarity, with Tsongkhapa’s presentation, while stressing the profundity of both.

The extraordinary anecdotes are jointly produced and must not be assigned wholesale to John. Another participant makes the strong claim that Mipham could fly and leave footprints in stone. John explicitly qualifies this—“I don’t know whether he can fly or not”—and then relates a traditional story about Mipham’s master travelling to another realm and returning with an unfamiliar flower. John also recalls Mipham producing or translating many important works in remarkably short periods, speaking of days or weeks. The Natural History Museum joke and most of the ensuing Tsongkhapa retreat narrative come from the other participant.

Because these are conversational recollections without documentary support in the meeting, they should be presented as traditional anecdotes, not as verified historical findings.

Book verification: Karma Phuntsho’s official title is Mipham’s Dialectics and the Debates on Emptiness: To Be, Not to Be or Neither. The other work is singular, Mipham’s Beacon of Certainty.
Back to top

30. John’s qualified suggestion for using AI with difficult books

John—not another participant—suggests using Gemini or ChatGPT with a difficult book: upload the whole work and ask for a summary of a chapter or its main points. When asked whether the AI will do it properly, he immediately qualifies the suggestion: it cannot do the work very well, but it may provide enough initial understanding for the reader to proceed slowly into the text.

Another participant immediately raises the concern that an AI might downplay something important and says it is better to read the text directly. John’s own suggestion is therefore best understood as a preliminary aid, not a replacement for the book.

The surrounding jokes about ADHD, medication, dating, and reading one chapter a day are divided between John and another participant. They should not be converted into a single polished instructional method or attributed entirely to either speaker.

Back to top

31. John’s selection of five core logics

John explains that his “five core logics” are a pedagogical selection from patterns running through the twenty-seven chapters of the MMK. He refers to a common grouping involving chapters 1, 2, 15, 18, and 24, then says he changed two selections in order to emphasize identity and infinite regress.

He clearly mentions chapter 10 and says the other changed selection concerns infinite regress, but that second chapter number is not recoverable with confidence from the meeting transcripts. A later garbled line mentions “chapter five” in connection with svabhāva, but the audio is not available here to resolve that machine reading.

John’s pedagogical reason is clearer than the exact list. Earlier phases of his framework already address presence and anatta, including the issues associated with chapter 18. He therefore wants the later analytical material to bring out additional problems of inherent identity and infinite regress rather than merely repeat the earlier emphasis.

External corroboration: The current companion video index independently identifies John’s published five core-logic sequence as MMK chapters 1, 10, 2, 7, and 24, with Infinite Regress assigned to chapter 7. This helps identify his later formalized scheme, but it is not used to pretend that the meeting audio itself was unambiguous. See the current John Tan video/audio index.
Back to top

32. Infinite regress, scientific “stuff,” and designation upon characteristics

Before developing the regress example, John criticizes what he sees as a continuing “stuff” framework in modern scientific explanation: even when the proposed fundamental level becomes subtler, one still imagines some fundamental stuff—sometimes spoken of as having consciousness-like as well as matter-like characteristics. His objection is to the assumption that explanation ultimately requires such stuff.

John says infinite regress is a problem for substantialists, not for a non-substantialist view that is already groundless. He explains the regress through the movement from atoms to electrons, protons and neutrons, then to quarks and further levels: if the explanation is always pushed one level down, it has not actually explained anything.

He then asks what these particle names are actually talking about and answers: different behaviours and characteristics. The name can designate those characteristics; one does not need a separate thing that 'houses' them.

In the exchange, measurement is also emphasized: what is encountered are characteristics through interaction with the measuring device and observer. John treats those characteristics as dependently arisen and uses the example to illustrate why another underlying 'stuff' is unnecessary. This remains a philosophical illustration, not a complete technical theory of physics.

Back to top

33. Niels Bohr and Karen Barad: corrected names, comparison, and conjecture

John speculates that Niels Bohr may have studied emptiness because he associates Bohr’s account of indeterminacy with the denial of intrinsic characteristics. Nothing in the transcript witnesses or the sources reviewed establishes that historical claim, so it must remain explicitly John’s conjecture.

He then connects the discussion with Karen Barad. The automatic transcripts garble the names, but the surrounding references to Einstein, the Copenhagen interpretation, agential realism, and intra-action make Niels Bohr and Karen Barad the strongest contextual resolutions.

Barad’s concept is a useful comparison because intra-action rejects the assumption that fully constituted relata must exist before their relation. The analogy should not be expanded into an assertion that agential realism and Madhyamaka are identical, or that Barad supplies the full meaning of Nāgārjuna.

Comparison verified: Scholarly descriptions of Barad’s intra-action explicitly state that relata do not pre-exist relations but emerge within specific intra-actions. See Jaksland, “Decoherence, appearance, and reality in agential realism”.
Back to top

34. The organization of John’s video material and its AI-oriented component

When asked whether he had recently read or learned anything especially insightful, John says, “I stopped reading already.” A participant then says “Soto”; John replies “Zen. The Korean, is it? Ah, Dōgen. I actually picked up…” before the exchange fragments into several participants showing or discussing books. Because the remainder is incomplete and speaker-shared, the synopsis does not infer a substantive teaching point from it.

John then says the videos are being reclassified into five main parts. The recording clearly mentions “decoding of view” and “understanding of dependent origination,” then describes axioms and mathematics as material aimed more at AI and standardization across LLMs. The meeting does not give five cleanly recoverable titles, so the synopsis does not invent them.

John imagines loading an axiomatic representation of his framework into an LLM as a persona or analytical system. When he asks a question, the system would check it against those axioms and tell him whether it is right or wrong. He then asks, in a phrase whose intended technical meaning is unclear, “Is that reverse? Does it contradict?”, and says the system could report that something does not contradict. The synopsis therefore preserves “reverse” as spoken without inventing a separate formal operation for it. He presents this as an AI-oriented standardization/checking project rather than as part of the meditative realization itself.

Back to top

35. His reservations about public circulation of the videos

John is firm that his experimental videos should not be treated as finished public Buddhist teaching. He first says he had expected about twenty people; later in the same discussion he restates the intended audience as roughly ten to twenty close people. When the count rose to about 220 and then 228, he became concerned and considered making the material private or otherwise restricting access.

He describes the material as personal opinion, a personal journey, storage for ideas that may later become chapters, and experiments with AI-assisted presentation. He says some AI-produced material may be inaccurate, and that his non-orthodox phrases—such as “relation without relata” and “designation without naming and labelling”—require substantial explanation and can mislead when detached from context.

John explicitly says that he is not a teacher. A little later he becomes even more direct: “don’t talk about teaching,” adding that this is very serious because “in Buddhism, we cannot anyhow teach.” He ties that caution to his preference that people study the texts and to his concern that the videos can mislead without the extensive explanation their non-orthodox formulations require.

He says his videos might be used only “probably 10%, 5, 10%,” describes them as personal opinion and a personal journey, and says close friends may take them as reference. The phrase “five or ten percent of someone’s study” is therefore a synopsis of those adjacent remarks, not a verbatim quotation.

He would rather keep the material within a small circle or restricted sharing context. He emphasizes that it is his work and that the decision about wider release is his. John says he had already left Facebook and then created YouTube mainly as a place to save his material and to test some AI. Some of that AI-produced material, he adds, was not fully correct because he had not yet mastered the tools. Wider reposting therefore conflicted with the private/reference purpose for which he was keeping the channel.

Back to top

Supplemental source — full excerpt from John Tan’s new, as-yet-unreleased book manuscript

The following is reproduced verbatim from the manuscript excerpt supplied for this article. It is later authorial material, not part of the 27 June 2026 Zoom meeting. The wording is intentionally preserved exactly as supplied, including “Three terms and distinctions,” even though five methodological items are subsequently discussed.

A Note on Method

This work is divided into five parts. Part One, this volume, is the main text: the sustained argument running from the collapse of the observer through dependent designation, causality, and the resonances and open questions gathered near its close. Part Two, Three Formations, carries that same logic through three coherent contemplative exercises — the mountain, the flower, and space — applying it directly rather than continuing to argue for it. Part Three, Nothing to Find, Nothing Missing, is a shorter, more accessible companion, walking a newer reader through the central argument from the beginning. Part Four, Science and the Dharma, sets this argument alongside developments in modern physics and cognitive science, carefully distinguishing resonance from proof throughout. The Appendix lays out the formal and linguistic scaffolding underlying the whole project — why ordinary grammar keeps reconstructing substance, and one proposed notation for avoiding it.

This book draws extensively on Nāgārjuna, Candrakīrti, Tsongkhapa, Mipham, Dōgen, and the Dzogchen tradition. It is not a translation, a commentary, or a scholarly exposition of any one of them. It is a personal philosophical synthesis, developed in continuity with Madhyamaka and Dzogchen, offered for its own coherence and usefulness rather than as a claim to represent orthodox doctrine.

Three terms and distinctions used throughout this book are my own, not classical divisions found in the source texts, and it matters that this is stated plainly rather than left for the reader to assume otherwise: Conceptual designation versus dependent designation. Classical Madhyamaka does not separate these into two distinct categories. Madhyamaka's own position is that all designation is dependent designation — there is no legitimate "conceptual designation" standing apart from it as a rival account of how labels attach to things. The distinction drawn throughout this book, between a "thing first, label second" sequence and a "thing and label arising together" structure, is a pedagogical separation of my own, built to make the core insight easier to approach for a reader encountering it for the first time. It is not a division Nāgārjuna or Candrakīrti would recognize as their own, even though the conclusion it leads toward — that all designation is dependent — is entirely theirs.

Designation by relation. The distinction between designation-by-thought and designation-by-relation, and the claim that structural, non-conceptual individuation (illustrated by the blue-and-yellow contrast) operates even prior to explicit conceptual labeling, does not appear as a formal division in classical Madhyamaka sources. It is a personal synthesis in continuity with the tradition, not orthodox doctrine.

The logic of the single stroke. The framing of Nāgasena's chariot as containing every subsequent insight of this book in miniature — no residue, exhaustive conditionality, no hierarchy or sequence, mutual dependence, full function without essence — is my own organizing device. It is a way of reading the chariot dialogue that I have found genuinely illuminating, not a claim about how the dialogue was originally intended or has traditionally been read.

Spontaneous presence equals dependent arising. This book argues, in its later chapters, that Dzogchen's spontaneous presence (lhun grub) and Madhyamaka's dependent arising are the same nature under two descriptions, and that Dzogchen's direct introduction can be understood as the experiential actualization of what Madhyamaka's analysis was always pointing toward. This reading has real support within the tradition — Longchenpa's insistence that the ground is empty, not a subtle existent thing, points in the same direction — but it is not a settled cross-tradition consensus. Other lineages and commentators hold that Dzogchen constitutes its own resultant vehicle, not reducible to or guaranteed by Madhyamaka analysis alone. The equivalence of nature is a position I hold with real confidence, built carefully across this book. That it follows Madhyamaka analysis in a way that makes the two traditions simply two descriptions of one path is my own synthesis of a live and unresolved question, not a report of settled doctrine.

The desynchronization of view, experience, and insight. A central organizing claim of this book is that direct contemplative experience — the taste of anatta, of total exertion — can arrive complete while the conceptual view used to understand it remains, unnoticed, substantialist, and that this mismatch, rather than any deficiency in the experience itself, is what keeps a mind from opening fully. The underlying phenomenon this points to — that realization and view can run at different paces — is recognized in various forms across contemplative traditions. The specific framing of it as a "desynchronization," and the use of that framing as the engine organizing this entire book from the collapse of the observer through to the final chapters, is my own construction. It is offered because I have found it clarifying and, I believe, accurate to how this process actually unfolds — not because it is a term or a diagnostic framework drawn from any classical source.

None of this diminishes what the book is trying to do. It simply means the book should be read as what it is: one practitioner's attempt to synchronize direct contemplative experience with a rigorously non-substantialist view, built using the tools Madhyamaka and Dzogchen provide, and organized with distinctions of my own devising where the tradition itself does not supply one ready-made. Where a claim is demonstrated by the classical arguments themselves, I have tried to say so. Where a claim is my own extension, reading, or synthesis, I have tried to say that too, both here and at each point in the text where it becomes relevant again.

Source status: unpublished manuscript excerpt supplied by the user. It is included here as later authorial clarification and is not used to rewrite the meeting transcript itself.

Integrated account of John’s position

Direct realization of anatta can bring vivid nondual experience and total exertion, but John’s central warning is that the practitioner’s framework may still remain inherent. Experience and view can be out of sync.

That residual framework may still treat consciousness, fluid process, space, time, conditions, or other explanatory bases as inherently established. Madhyamaka analysis is used to see why phenomena with essence could not arise, interact, communicate, or appear dependently.

Dependent designation, relation without relata, and causal efficacy without causal power are John’s ways of pressing the same point from different angles: function does not require an independently existing substrate.

Yet emptiness does not eliminate appearance. Phenomena remain conventionally valid and functional. The absence of ultimate foundation makes conventionality more important, not less. Ultimately phenomena are empty and unfindable; conventionally they appear, function, and arise dependently.

Mere negation, however, is only half the story. John repeatedly insists that the difficult part is seeing formation and seeing that formation as empty. When conventionality is understood in this way, he says one is no longer worried about conceptual conventionalities or pure perception, and connects that directly with non-meditation.

His practical standard is sincerity: allow what is not understood to drive further investigation rather than bypassing it. He describes this as opening the body-mind, thoughts, and attachments, and says that deeper understanding leads him to practise more seriously and to respect the great Buddhist masters more deeply.

Sources and verification scope

Unreleased-manuscript source:

The later methodological clarifications marked above come from a new, as-yet-unreleased John Tan book manuscript excerpt supplied for this article. Because the manuscript is not publicly available, these passages are used only as later authorial clarification of how John himself classifies his terminology, pedagogical distinctions, and cross-tradition synthesis. They are not used as independent verification of what was said in the 27 June meeting, and they are kept visually and verbally distinct from the meeting synopsis.

The meeting transcript witnesses control the spoken content, while speaker attribution is reconstructed from diarization, direct address, continuity, and cross-Part identification. Where the user directly re-listened to a disputed word or phrase, that check controls the phonetic reading actually checked; it is not treated as a blanket source for speaker identity. Public sources are used only to verify names, titles, textual references, or the limits of historical/comparative claims. They do not certify John Tan’s interpretations, realization claims, traditional anecdotes, or unresolved audio.

  1. YouTube Videos and Audios by John Tan: Union of Dependent Arising and Emptiness — companion media collection.
  2. Milindapañha 3.1.1 — the chariot simile.
  3. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Nāgārjuna.
  4. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Theory of Two Truths in India.
  5. “Not Even Absent: Dependent Origination, Emptiness, and the Two Truths in the Thought of Nāgārjuna”.
  6. A scholarly explanation of Karen Barad’s “intra-action”.
  7. Yoshiaki Niisaku, “Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, Chapter 18, Verse 2 and the Prasannapadā’s Commentary Thereon”.
  8. Karma Phuntsho, Mipham’s Dialectics and the Debates on Emptiness
  9. Mipham’s Beacon of Certainty — official publisher page
  10. A scholarly account of relata and intra-action in agential realism
  11. Possible textual comparison: Jan Westerhoff, The Dispeller of Disputes (Oxford University Press)

Watch and listen: John Tan on dependent arising and emptiness

The companion collection gathers John Tan’s videos and audios on right view, phase six, dependent designation, relations without relata, causal efficacy, the five MMK deconstruction logics, and why mere negation is inadequate.

YouTube Videos and Audios by John Tan: Union of Dependent Arising and Emptiness

Prepared from the supplied 27 June 2026 Zoom transcript witnesses. This is a comprehensive synopsis, not a verbatim transcript.

The AtR Dharma Library

Must Reads

New here? Begin with Seven Stages, then On Anatta. Explore the full collection below.

View full list on page →

New in the AtR library

Latest posts

Up to 20 recent articles, newest publication first.

Browse more posts below.

Browse more posts →

AtR Library

Browse books, articles, recordings and ways to follow AtR.

Continue reading

Your unfinished long articles on this device.

    Start Here →Recommended readings and the free AtR guides John Tan’s Website
    Free Books
      View section on page →
      Featured Articles
        View section on page →
        Audio & Video
          View section on page →
          Further Reading
            View section on page →
            Follow Awakening to Reality
              View section on page →
              Full library on page

              Search AtR

              Examples: anatta · I AM · emptiness · dependent origination · Zen · Mahamudra · Dzogchen

              Try Google for broader results

              Google searches this site in a new tab.