From “I AM” to non-duality, no-self, emptiness and spontaneous perfection
About this library
This blog is about spiritual awakening, maps and stages, the blinding effects of our strong momentum/conditioning (karmic propensities), view, realization, experience, etc. If you are new, begin with the Must Reads.
A conversation with Soh and John Tan · 8 October 2026
Soh was reflecting on some recent discussions about artificial intelligence in online Buddhist communities.
In some English-language Buddhist spaces, including discussions on Reddit, he had encountered considerable hostility towards AI. This contrasted with the greater enthusiasm he felt he was encountering in some Chinese and other Asian contexts.
These are impressions from particular online spaces, rather than a comprehensive picture of “Western Buddhism” or “Asia.” Neither is homogeneous. Nevertheless, the contrast prompted a conversation about technological change, spiritual practice, and how we respond when familiar ways of living and working come under pressure.
The following exchange took place on 8 October 2026. The exchange has been edited for readability. Square brackets identify an editorial clarification. Duplicate reply previews and a stray letter have been omitted. Predictions and political assessments are the speakers’ views.
Soh
There’s a lot of AI hate in some of the Western Buddhist circles I’ve been seeing online—anti-AI narratives throughout discussions on the Buddhism subreddit, for example.
I think people should learn to use these tools and understand them. We can’t really expect technological progress to stop simply because we dislike it, lol.
In some of the Chinese and Asian spaces I follow, the atmosphere seems much more enthusiastic about AI.
John Tan
Lol. Progress will not wait for anyone. We can talk about spirituality and consciousness, but to deny or reject AI progress is naive.
A mature person must upgrade and update himself and see what really works. We can say it can’t replace spiritual liberation, but we can’t deny its progress.
But it will create lots of economic restructuring problems. Lots of unemployment, but lots of new opportunities in new ways.
We cannot just worry about feeling threatened. I doubt they are affected anywhere near as much as I am. My core accounting business might become obsolete; still, we have to face it. We can’t just sit and blame here and there.
My finance business is also affected.
The agentic AI course I was taking became obsolete before I even completed it… lol.
But instead of blaming, know the threats and know the opportunities. Economies will definitely be affected, and governments will have to think about how to solve these structural issues.
Many will reject it, including my partners and even my dad… lol. I have been educating them also.
But to date, I have never seen how the core teachings of Buddhism are affected. In fact, it sheds new light on how they can be re-presented.
It makes me aware that many fields are moving in accordance with the core philosophy, and that makes me happy… lol. Be it quantum physics, new mathematics, cognitive science, or even AI itself—topics I couldn’t even imagine associating with Buddhist ideas.
It’s like making videos and keeping on improving them. Meanings get distorted, and we keep finding new ways to edit them, to prompt the AI, and so on. That is what improvement is all about, isn’t it?
There are so many insights that I find difficult to articulate and present, and now it is made possible.
I mean, I’m new to AI and it changes so fast, but once we learn, we will eventually master it, right?
Do you remember two years ago, when I went to your house and we were both still struggling to understand it? Lol.
Now we’re quite familiar… so what is there to fear?
Jobs, opportunities, and safeguards
Soh 8:15–8:16 am
Yeah… I agree.
I still have some concerns about AI. I think eventually it’s going to automate everything, and most people will be out of jobs and so on. We might eventually transition to universal basic income (UBI), and the capitalist model of society may break down. A lot of upheaval lies ahead, and this is just the beginning… There are also safety risks and concerns, potentially even existential ones. But I just don’t think rejecting the technology is the way to go. We have to learn the technology and work on safeguards and so on.
John Tan 8:20–8:25 am
Now let me ask you: how many small businesses can make use of AI now to automate, integrate, analyse, search, etc.? These are all wide-open opportunities… Who is going to do all this automation? The people running the businesses, new talents, new IT firms, etc.
There will definitely be lots of people out of jobs through automation, like in China now, but what exactly is the problem?
Not the technologies, but politicians, corruption, etc.
Politicians who promise policies that make people lazy but still get money.
How can there be no problems if the world is never thinking about one another’s welfare for the benefit of the world?
Let me give you an example. In Singapore, there is a foreigners-to-citizens ratio, right?
Soh 8:25–8:26 am
Yeah.
[Replying to John’s remark about one another’s welfare.] What do you mean?
John Tan 8:26–8:28 am
So why can’t this be implemented for computing power and automation?
It’s the same.
If you let all foreigners come in, many Singaporeans will be out of jobs also.
Singapore didn’t do that until there were some economic issues.
Similarly, all these will come.
Soh 8:28 am
I see…
John Tan 8:29–8:32 am
It’s like carbon credits to handle environmental issues.
When social and economic issues become so severe, automation will be taxed heavily until they employ people. That is how I see it.
But a good government will balance every step.
That is why we are not all working from home.
Human judgment, useful tools, and creative work
Later that afternoon, the conversation turned to human judgment, programming, and criticism of AI-generated creative work. The following are edited and condensed excerpts. One participant is identified simply as “A Dharma friend”; person-directed remarks and identifying references have been omitted.
A Dharma friend Later that afternoon · edited excerpts
AI is another development in computing and automation. If someone wants to be a purist, then don’t even use a computer or a washing machine—be a Luddite, go rogue all the way!
Arguments about Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, or Jeff Bezos are different from arguments about AI itself.
Human judgment still matters: explaining something in its particular context, rather than offering blanket suggestions. There is still plenty of room for people to develop what they contribute.
I’m tired of the AI arguments. Every talk I attend now seems to end up discussing AI!
Soh 4:14–4:15 pm
AI can already handle the programming tasks I give it, and I’m happy to use it, lol. It saves me time and mental effort. I suppose it’s a matter of perspective.
Or perhaps I’m just lazy! 😂
Soh 4:23–4:24 pm
I like reading Calvin Cheng’s comments. I don’t agree with everything he says, although I agree with many—perhaps most—of his takes.
He is a political commentator and a former Nominated Member of Parliament in Singapore. I often find his views close to the government’s position.
His comments about “Luddites” came to mind here.
Calvin Cheng on AI, creative work, and adaptation
The Dharma friend’s mention of “Luddite” reminded Soh of Calvin Cheng’s comments on AI and creative work. He shared Cheng’s Facebook post, dated 10 August. The following reproduces Cheng’s own commentary as shown in the supplied screenshots, preserving his wording, spelling, and punctuation. Screen-width line wrapping has been removed. The separate news article preview beneath his post is not part of this quotation.
There is a difference between criticising badly made AI film , and criticising AI-made film and content in general.
Arvind Jay seems to be against AI made films and ‘art’ in general.
He says “ if you use AI don’t call yourself a filmmaker. You are an ass”
This person is making himself sound like a Luddite , out of touch with reality.
In China, AI made film and TV content is getting better and better. Soon it will be indistinguishable from human-made content.
The analogy with Luddites couldn’t be more apt.
In the 19th century, English textile workers smashed looms and automated knitting frames. They said it wasn’t craftsmanship. Not art. But consumers didn’t care. To them, the textiles woven by machines were indistinguishable enough to prefer them, as they were cheaper and produced more quickly.
This is going to happen to TV, film , music and even art.
If the consumer feels it’s indistinguishable, then who is the human ‘producer’ to stop the consumer from preferring it ?
People in the creative industries have to learn how to use AI , or be made irrelevant by it. Right now, prompting and refining the content is still important. A good ‘eye’ is still needed to parse bad AI slop from good AI content.
It helps the artist / creator be more efficient.
And until AGI arrives , human input is still important. But when AGI is developed , then the AI itself can prompt, and create.
But that’s development. And human beings will have to find another way to be relevant to each other.
(Human copyright of course still needs to be protected. But machine learning is in a way like human learning. We also look at past examples of content , art , and the try to produce something ‘original’)
The passage above presents Cheng’s views, historical interpretation, and predictions. Quoting it does not imply agreement with every claim or personal characterisation.
The distinction does not require defending every AI production. In its review of Trace Project, Mothership identified storytelling and visual problems and reported the filmmakers’ statement that the script was mainly human-written. A work can be criticised on its merits while the broader possibilities of the technology remain open.
What strikes me is that John is personally exposed to the disruption he is discussing. His accounting and finance businesses are affected, and even the agentic AI course he was taking was overtaken by developments before he completed it. Yet he continues learning, examining the threats and exploring the opportunities.
I am not suggesting that AI is all good. Job displacement, concentration of power, misinformation, safety concerns, and potentially even existential risks deserve serious attention. Nor should we assume that new jobs will necessarily compensate for those lost, or that everyone can simply “reskill” their way out of structural economic changes. Governments and businesses have responsibilities here; individuals cannot shoulder the entire burden.
But taking these concerns seriously is compatible with learning to use AI thoughtfully. We can support safeguards, question harmful applications, and still explore its usefulness—including in studying, translating, and communicating the Dharma, with careful checking of sources and meaning.
That is the spirit in which I understand John’s remarks: remain willing to learn and update ourselves, recognise both the dangers and possibilities, and respond constructively. Neither blanket rejection nor uncritical enthusiasm will do that work for us.
Afterword: What did the Luddites actually oppose?
An interesting historical qualification is worth adding to our earlier use of “Luddite.” Today, the word often means someone who resists technology. The original Luddites, however, included skilled textile workers who knew their machines intimately. Their protests concerned wages, livelihoods, workmanship, and the terms on which machinery was used. The familiar image of people simply frightened by unfamiliar inventions misses much of that history.
The video linked below offers a useful corrective. Its central argument is supported by historical scholarship: opposition to particular uses of machinery was not necessarily opposition to technology as such. There were regional differences, however. Some workers challenged wage-cutting practices and inferior production; others resisted machines that directly threatened their occupations. Their actions also included intimidation and violence. Understanding their grievances need not mean endorsing those methods.
This also qualifies the historical analogy in Calvin Cheng’s post quoted above. Learning to use new tools can be valuable, but the original conflict cannot be reduced to a contest between stubborn craftsmen and consumers choosing cheaper goods. Nor does using a computer or a washing machine oblige someone to accept every application of AI. The relevant questions include what a particular use makes possible, what it costs people, and who has a say in the decision.
For me, this connects with John’s recognition that automation creates structural problems requiring a public response. We can learn the technology while also asking how its gains should be shared and how people whose livelihoods are disrupted should be supported. Adaptation and a concern for fairness belong in the same conversation.
A note on the video: its broad framing is sound, but some details need qualification. Frame-breaking was already occurring in March 1811, before the November raids used as its opening scene. The Luddites were not the first to contest the effects of mechanisation. Ned Ludd is best treated as a legendary figure, and the movement had varied aims rather than one unified programme.
My friend Sim Pern Chong, also known in earlier online discussions as Longchen or Simpo, has organised and documented his spiritual journey and present understanding into a newly expanded 101-page document. He is doing this partly because the web-hosting service for his old site will soon remove it, and I think the material is worth preserving.
Sim himself describes the work with some humour as “not fully about Buddhism type awakening” but more a kind of “Rojakism” of the process he went through. For readers outside Singapore and Malaysia: rojak is a local mixed salad, and in everyday speech the word is also used for an eclectic mixture of different things. Sim’s playful term “Rojakism” therefore means a deliberately mixed or hybrid spiritual path rather than one that fits neatly inside a single orthodox system. That is an apt description. The PDF moves from awakening and meditation into dream work, karmic-imprint work, a larger-consciousness framework, his “New Earth” material, chronological dream or vision transmissions, and accounts of unusual or otherworldly experiences.
October 2026 edition update: Sim has substantially expanded and revised this documentation since the earlier 84-page release. The current PDF has a new illustrated cover and 100 numbered pages (101 PDF pages in total), while retaining the same seven main chapters. This article reflects the expanded edition rather than treating it as a second book.
John Tan once described Simpo (Longchen) as “a very insightful and sincere practitioner.” He also spoke highly of the quality of Sim’s writings on non-duality. I agree. Sim is an unusually insightful practitioner, and over the years I have found many of his observations on spiritual experience, non-duality, no-self, emptiness, and the changing phases of practice interesting and valuable.
“Simpo (Longchen) is a very insightful and sincere practitioner.”
— John Tan / Thusness, on Sim’s Dreamdatum writings
The organising idea: “horizontal” and “vertical” insights
Horizontal insights
Sim uses this term for insights into the nature of reality and experience accessible from the human contemplative perspective. Elsewhere in the PDF he gives examples such as I AM, non-duality, no-self, and emptiness.
Vertical insights
He uses this term for experiences that, in his framework, extend beyond ordinary human perception—for example access to what he calls a Higher or Larger Consciousness Structure, other lifetimes, dreams, visions, non-linear time, and other dimensions of experience.
This horizontal/vertical distinction explains much of the book’s “Rojakism.” Sim is not trying to reduce everything to one Buddhist map. He is combining the AtR-type progression of insight with a much broader experiential and cosmological framework of his own.
What is actually in the PDF
Chapter One · Groundwork Information (pp. 4–20)
Horizontal and vertical insights; why conceptual analysis alone is insufficient; why awakening attempts fail; meditation; thoughtlessness versus awakening; two main types of practice; causal imprints or karma; an orientation toward increasing harmlessness; simultaneous/past lives; and past-life trauma and imprint work.
Chapter Two · Larger Consciousness Connection Practice (pp. 21–35)
Sim’s “hybrid path”; his model of a Larger Consciousness Structure; two modes of connection; meditation-vision transmission; an example of past-karma healing; expanded dream-interpretation guidance; recurring dream symbols; a dream-and-vision authentication protocol; and the strengths and limitations he sees in this mode of practice.
Chapter Three · Overall Insights and Experiential Records (pp. 36–54)
The beginning of his spiritual journey; why he regards awakening as a matter of discovery rather than mysticism; the progression from I AM / Eternal Witness → non-duality → no-self or anatta; inquiry after I AM; how the sense of self is formed; emptiness; non-arising and conventional reality; stable visions; non-linear time; dimensionlessness; rebirth dynamics; and his interpretation of karmic debt.
Chapter Four · The New Earth (pp. 55–65)
Sim’s personal New Earth / planetary-ascension framework: proposed cycles and timelines, planetary versus individual transformation, a “New Earth human” consciousness model, vibrational and biological transformation, an androgynous-ancestor hypothesis, and possible future transaction dynamics.
Chapter Five · Independent Articles (pp. 66–79)
Shorter pieces on the nature of the body, identity as energetic configuration, the head-and-heart mechanism of letting go, a primordial humanoid archetype, synchronicity and non-linear interconnected causality, the fluidity of time, the challenges of awakening, multidimensional experience, transformation of causality, and what he calls the universal dynamics of dream awakening.
Chapter Six · Chronological Transmission Records (pp. 80–88)
Dream or vision transmissions that Sim dates to 2001, 2002, 2012, 2024, and 2026—including a “return to source” transmission, the rainbow snow-leopard dream, a lucid-dream lecture involving Kṣitigarbha, and later experiences he associates with non-linear time and the New Earth framework.
Accounts Sim interprets as encounters with a deceased woman, alien-human hybrids, an encounter with an apparently ordinary figure in the context of consciousness projection, a gateway to a Chinese netherworld, a deity in a lucid dream, and a possible higher-dimensional or “Arcturian” being. These are presented as his own experiential records and interpretations.
Why Chapter Three may be especially interesting to AtR readers
One of the clearest connections with Awakening to Reality appears in Chapter Two, where Sim writes that AtR materials are excellent for paving the way to anatta (no-self) and expresses gratitude to John Tan for pointing out when he was stuck at the I AM stage. At the same time, Sim explains that his own path became a hybrid: he combines AtR-type insight work with what he calls larger-consciousness work.
Chapter Three then lays out his own progression explicitly. He presents I AM Presence or Eternal Witness first, followed by non-duality, and then no-self, which he calls the matured stage of non-duality. He says his no-self insight occurred while walking, when “I am walking” gave way to simply walking with no separate “I.” From there he describes further movement into emptiness, non-arising, non-linear time, dimensionlessness, and related investigations.
This is one reason Sim’s record is useful. It does not freeze his earliest experience into his final view. You can see an actual practitioner’s interpretation changing as further insights and experiences accumulate.
How I suggest reading it
I would read this primarily as a spiritual autobiography and field record—the record of an intelligent and sincere practitioner’s long investigation—rather than as a textbook whose every proposition must be accepted.
Some parts overlap closely with subjects discussed on Awakening to Reality, especially I AM, non-duality, anatta, emptiness, non-arising, and the loosening of identification. Other parts move far outside the usual AtR framework. That difference is worth preserving rather than editing away.
In fact, this is what makes the compilation interesting to me. It preserves the actual contours of a person’s path: breakthroughs, experiments, changing views, dreams, unusual experiences, hypotheses, errors that may later be revised, and attempts to make sense of all of it. Sim himself repeatedly presents parts of the work as his current understanding rather than final truth.
For me, the important point is not that a reader must accept every part of Sim’s synthesis. It is that Sim has spent decades seriously looking into experience, and he has been willing to revise his understanding as his practice developed. That kind of record is worth preserving.
Sim Pern Chong · 101-page expanded edition
Read the complete Inner Journey documentation
Sim gathered this material before his old web-hosting service removes the site. The direct PDF link below points to the expanded October 2026 edition of the documentation.
The older archive is useful precisely because it preserves material from different periods rather than rewriting the earlier stages to sound like the later ones.
I hope this new compilation remains available even after the old site disappears. It gives readers a chance to encounter Sim’s journey in his own terms: not as a perfectly tidy system, but as a wide-ranging and evolving exploration of awakening, dreams, consciousness, karmic patterning, unusual experience, and the nature of reality.
Awakening to Reality · Facebook archive · 2021–2022
Anatta, Luminosity, and Emptiness
Ryan Burton’s November 2021 breakthrough report and his October 2022 “Update 10 Months After Anatta,” together with the substantive discussion threads that followed.
Ryan Burton · with discussion by Soh Wei Yu, Angelo Grr, and other AtR participants
November 30, 2021 — Breakthrough Report
Ryan BurtonNovember 30, 2021
3 nights ago at the end of a week long period of silence I read your “Two Non-dual Contemplations Post I Am” you explained that moment with the gong sound. It reached me.
The background fell away completely and all perceptions were perceived as presence. Presence and manifestation inseparable. The insight was so clear so I wanted to test it. Took a shower in full effortless natural continuous awareness. Couldn’t sleep laid there for 4 hours too much awareness and luminosity behind the eyes.
Next day there was continuous presence for the first time in life. Have practiced meditation for 12 years. Never happened before. 90% of the moments of that day effortless continuity very little deviation. All thought all perceptions were presence. Couldn’t believe it. Still can’t. Seems I’m phasing between Stage 4 & 5 or I’m just completely delusional and experiencing mere clarity a silencing of the 6th consciousness.
Formerly sensory objects were always cause for distraction. I couldn’t apply Longchenpa’s advice on Abiding in the immediacy of sensory appearances. Namkhai Norbu explains this as well but it wasn’t experiential with profound continuity until reading your explanation that unfolded into appearances as presence.
It’s different than previous non-dual inseparability. Presence still felt like something definable yet empty. Now it seems just ineffable.
I think you saved me a decade maybe a lifetime of meditation. Still a long way to go but wanted to say thank you and if you have any advice for me I’d be honored to hear it.
Your stages especially how you described cycling through I Am where it would be prominent for some time then vanish for months is exactly what I went through.
I have no idea what stage or phase I’m definitively at at all it seems to just happen. If recognition is present, everything is perceived as mind. The atman is just a thought. Ill be reading the rest of the ATR Guide but if there are any sections any of the admins think I should focus on specifically please let me know.
Discussion thread
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Did you go through I AM before?
It is a good breakthrough. Your insight is more on second stanza. Both stanzas must be thorough.
Regarding the “cycling through I Am” which article are you referring to?
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Also can you link me the Longchenpa text you mentioned too. Thanks
ADA.D.
Ryan and Soh I'd love to see an interview between you two...Im sure it would be well watched 🙂
In such an interview it would be great to start with Soh describing in his own words the various stages, with you Ryan asking any relevant questions,
THEN go on to describe this experience you've had,
which will provide a nice real-world example.
ADA.D.
...especially since the interpretability of text on page makes it alot harder to gain certainty one understands what people are talking about, compared to a proper chat
AGAngelo Grr
Awesome, congrats man, I’m so happy to hear it ☺️
SWYSoh Wei Yu
A.D. haha was just telling someone I don't do zoom meetings
WLW.L.
Soh Wei Yu, why not? Embrace the #newnormal 🙂
AGAngelo Grr
Soh Wei Yu I’m happy to interview you Ryan if you’re up for it 😉. No pressure of course it’s not everyone’s cup of tea but I find it tends to be helpful for others to get the feel of what it’s like to go through these shifts.
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Angelo Grr Maybe you can just interview Ryan, that'll be nice 😂
AGAngelo Grr
Soh Wei Yu yes that’s what I meant, I think I just put it in a sub thread 😂
RBRyan Burton
Angelo Grr Sure we can do an interview I'll dm you and we can figure out a time
AGAngelo Grr
Ryan Burton sounds good
ESE.S.
Soh Wei Yu in the world of interconnection and inter penetration you are being a boob of separation!
RBRyan Burton
Soh Wei Yu do you have any advice for sleeping problems post Anatta? There’s been too much clarity and presence to sleep at reasonable hours
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Ryan Burton
Read Tips on Energy Imbalances chapter in AtR guide, be somatic and dont strain or overfocus on the radiance
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Ryan Burton
Text shown in the image shared with this comment:
Soh Wei Yu: Ryan can’t sleep.
John Tan: Lol, energy imbalance... Just don’t think about it; come back to it later. 🤣
John Tan: So far, most people seem to have this problem. Maybe I should write something to caution people about it.
Soh Wei Yu: Lol, I see... Yeah, I just told him to read the energy-imbalance chapter.
YLY.L.
Soh Wei Yu please do . I myself too have a ceiling of practise for 3-4 hours, anything more than that the energy is uncomfortable so have been looking into energetic practises.. not sure if they help tho
AHA.H.
Ryan Burton shift to practices like calm abiding. where you orientate the mind and body towards relaxation and tranquility.
other than that what I've found with energy is to learn to absorb it. this leads to crystallization of a different kind of body. which in turn leads to more capacity to take in energy. etc.
there isn't really an end.
discomfort usually arises when a subtle energy mets a coarser energy. so tension in the body is a coarse energy, which then a subtle solvent of energy breaks down. that discomfort is natural and one has to just understand that is what is happening without fighting or trying to manipulate.
another way is understanding too much energy can equate to agitation. when there is agitation then you need spaciousness or the sensation of openness. this greatly helps work out the kinks so to speak so that there is much more evenness and pervasiveness.
but all in all when you access an infinite source of energy, the crux point is to re-cognize it as your own radiance. welcome it as a friend, be gentle and love it. let it do and be what is needs to do.
AHA.H.
I didn't write anything on how, but you can probably figure it out. =]
AHA.H.
in a way energy and that knowing of that energy is the most subtle dualism. like motion and stillness. as long it appears two or distinct, there is always desire for union or incessant fighting. when energy and knowing are single, meaning they are the same exact manifestation then there is no issue as there is just transparency. make body, make feeling, make everything transparent through recognition then whether there is energy or not, luminosity knowing or not, flows in through and out and simultaneously nothing at all ever happening.
RBRyan Burton
A.H. well said thank you🙏
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Text shown in the image shared with this comment:
John Tan: Damn, I’m scared you’ll turn it into a cult group. 🤦
John Tan: Did you also do the same in the Chinese forum?
Soh Wei Yu: Lol, I haven’t. It’s just that in the future, I hope to translate and share more.
Soh Wei Yu: 🤣
John Tan: When advising on energy imbalances, you need to consider each individual’s situation and conditions. Your case and Ryan’s are due to over-focusing on the intensity of clarity as appearances.
John Tan: For example, when you read about Actual Freedom (AF) instead of refining selflessness.
John Tan: That is why I am against non-conceptuality as the way.
Soh Wei Yu: Oh, I see...
John Tan: Have you wondered what selflessness in active mode is? What does freedom from self-nature entail?
SWYSoh Wei Yu
John Tan wrote to me on the week I broke through to anatta with Bahiya Sutta:
Just managed to scan through the past few posts you wrote. They are quite insightful. In summary you are beginning to experience the ‘taste’ you described in the “certainty of being” of the formless presence in transient phenomena. That is what I meant by bringing ‘this’ from the background (formlessness) to the foreground (forms). It is also what I meant by the ‘fabric and texture of Awareness’ in forms. Below are some of the points that came to mind after reading them. I will just jot down some of them for sharing purposes.
1. One Taste
You mentioned about ‘one taste’ but do take note that what you are experiencing is just the ‘same taste’ of luminous essence, not the ‘same taste’ in Emptiness nature. I use the term ‘essence’ differently from Dzogchen. In Dzogchen, luminosity is the ‘nature’ and Emptiness is the ‘essence’. As I see Emptiness as the absence of an essence in whatever arises, I do not feel appropriate expressing the Dzogchen way.
2. “Obvious and direct…yet always missed!”
I like how you expressed it, it is quite apt. However I sense that you may have underestimated the power and full meaning of ‘deeply rooted in consciousness’. If we are unaware of the impact, we will not realize what is meant by ‘latent tendencies’. Try imagining ‘someone’ standing right in front of you yet you are unable to see him because you are under a magical spell that is planted in the deep most of your consciousness. If you are unaware of the latent deep, whatever realized is merely a surface understanding. Day in day out, these tendencies are always in action. You may want to ask yourself will the latent deep find its way up even in a PCE mode?
3. Feels Universe, Pure Consciousness, Pure Aggregates
“You are not just the formless presence/knower/consciousness... you are all forms, you are the universe univers-ing, you are whatever is arising moment to moment as a complete non-dual experience in itself... There is no background awareness and foreground phenomena happening in awareness... there is simply foreground pure consciousness always, be it the pure existence experienced in a formless mode (e.g. I AM, aka the 'thought realm' as Thusness puts it), or in all forms... the making of a non-dual experience into a background is simply trying to capture and reify a moment of pure consciousness.”
I remember writing this to Simpo few years ago in his forum. It is related to his experience of ‘feeling light and weightless’. This also relates to mind-body drop and your dream about ‘transparency’. Being ‘light, weightless and transparent’ is the result of dissolving the body-construct. It is quite an obvious contrast moving from ‘Self/self’ to no-self. Prior to what you have written you should also experience this, otherwise you are being too focused on being ‘brilliance and luminous’ of the 'actuality'.
On the othe hand, feeling ‘universe’ has to do with the deconstruction of ‘identity’ and ‘personality’. You have to have clearer insight of what ‘deconstructions’ leads to what experience.
The text in bold is quite well expressed but knows the dependent originated nature of consciousness. There is the experience of primordial purity of the aggregates and 18 dhatus but there is no 'a substratum background' that is called 'pure consciousness'. The sense of self is dissolved and is replaced by a sense of inter-penertration.
4. No agent and the intensity of luminosity
In the seen, there is just the seen! It is completely non-dual... there is no 'the seen + a perceiver here seeing the seen'.... The seen is precisely the seeing! There is not two or three things: seer, seeing, and the seen. That split is entirely conceptual (though taken to be reality)...
Well expressed! But in the subsequent paragraph, you said,
“All the bullshit concepts, constructs and images of an 'aliveness', a 'hearing', a 'seeing', an 'awareness' simply dissolves in the direct experiencing of whatever arises... just 'seeing is seeing, hearing is hearing, thinking is thinking and they are all flowing independently', with 'no self holding all these sensory experiences together'”
In the article on https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/2009/03/on-anatta-emptiness-and-spontaneous.html, I mentioned about the 2 stanza. There is the no-agent aspect and there is the intensity of luminosity aspect. I find that your present experience is still centered on the luminosity aspect. You are directly experiencing seamlessness of any happening where no clear line of demarcation can be drawn between the subject-object split. You realized the boundary is purely illusionary and is clear about the cause that resulted in such division but still, that is not the ‘essence’ of an experiential insight of anatta in my opinion. There is a difference in saying "there is no split between thinking and thinker, the thinking itself is 'me'" and "there is thinking, no thinker". You must be aware that having immediate and direct experience but with dualistic framework intact and complete replacement of the dualistic framework entirely with DO (dependent origination) yields very different experiential insight; you may want to investigate further and move from "they are all flowing independently" to "manifesting in seamless inter-dependencies."
5. "How am I experiencing the moment of being alive?" (HAIETMOBA)
But.... if you contemplate on "How am I experiencing the moment of being alive?", or, "How am I experiencing the moment of hearing?", or "How am I experiencing the moment of seeing?" or "How am I experiencing the moment of being aware?"
"How am I experiencing the moment of being alive?" (HAIETMOBA) is the key question of the AF. I will not comment on it but how does it differ from the question “Without using any symbols of ‘I’, how is ‘I’ experienced?” Also how it differs from the question “Who am I?” -- the question that led you to the realization of “I AM”.
As you get clearer and clearer where exactly are all these questions leading you and the mode of perception that are involved in I AM realization and PCEs, you will have to asked yourself sincerely is this the ultimate mode of perception that will lead you towards genuine freedom. Is being lockup permanently in PCE the way towards liberation and how it differs from seeking permanent uninterrupted abiding in “I AMness”.
Edited by Thusness, 17 Oct 2010, 4:35 PM
SWYSoh Wei Yu
I think point 4 is relevant to you Ryan Burton
In the article on https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/2009/03/on-anatta-emptiness-and-spontaneous.html, I mentioned about the 2 stanza. There is the no-agent aspect and there is the intensity of luminosity aspect. I find that your present experience is still centered on the luminosity aspect. You are directly experiencing seamlessness of any happening where no clear line of demarcation can be drawn between the subject-object split. You realized the boundary is purely illusionary and is clear about the cause that resulted in such division but still, that is not the ‘essence’ of an experiential insight of anatta in my opinion. There is a difference in saying "there is no split between thinking and thinker, the thinking itself is 'me'" and "there is thinking, no thinker". You must be aware that having immediate and direct experience but with dualistic framework intact and complete replacement of the dualistic framework entirely with DO (dependent origination) yields very different experiential insight; you may want to investigate further and move from "they are all flowing independently" to "manifesting in seamless inter-dependencies."
Actually the insight of anatta has arisen in both stanzas to some degree even back then, but the first stanza became clearer over the next few months and I think particularly in February 2011 (about four months later) I had another breakthrough. The second stanza was clearer for me first. Usually those who enter anatta with I AM prior, their second stanza is clearer first.
RBRyan Burton
Soh Wei Yu fascinating that people with prior I Am get clear on second stanza first
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Ryan Burton
They enter by tasting, expanding and exploring the nature of the luminosity
SWYSoh Wei Yu
But as I said better to put aside all thinking, contemplating or even reading until you resolved your energy imbalances. Take a 1~2 week rest and if things improve.
LZGL.Z.G.
Ryan Burton can also try hatha yoga. I had the same issue three months ago when I could only sleep for three or four hours for several days(albeit still mentally functional). Hatha yoga resolves the metitation insomnia,which is likely induced by energy imbalance.
I remember I searched thru this grp for info and hatha yoga popped out
SWYSoh Wei Yu
L.Z.G.
What caused your issue?
LZGL.Z.G.
Soh Wei Yu I pinpointed to either meditation or rumination due to job change.
But likely meditation as I reembarked on meditation a month or so prior to insomnia. Maintained sitted meditation for at least 30mins daily,and it resolved my worries lol.
Though my mind still abit too still and I had a devil-may-care mentality,not sure if I could call it ennui. One night during the insomnia period,it even felt my heart literally opened out and a bliss of sort overwhelmed my body at around 3-4am(and I was smiling goofily to myself).
So everytime I woke up early and can't sleep I just do meditation. I wonder if that aggravated it lol.
Though I notice that I might had a breakthrough then. At one point there was a schedule screwup during working hours,so I went to a hustling and bustling area to meditate open-awareness style. To my surprised I was able to be mentally still despite the noises of chattering and clattering engine,cold breeze hitting upon my skin, and crowds in front of me.
Btw my main meditation is putting my intent on nosetip or area above upper lip and watch the in-out breath. Though sometimes I feel mental tightness so later I adopted watching breath moving throughout the body(which is the method favoured by Tibetans afaik).
Usually when I had completed I switch to open-awareness of the senses. Whatever it comes,it comes;whatever it goes,it goes. Just be aware.
Also did kindness and compassion(metta) meditation,though not as frequent and in separate sittings. Some walking meditation. Other than these,body scanning sometimes but not much.
So what caused my insomnia then might be likely mental exertion of trying to be too aware😑
RBRyan Burton
Soh Wei Yu put all thinking aside... that's certainly the best advice at this time thank you
NRJN.R.J.
Ryan Burton embodiment takes time. The Great Vow to save all beings clarifies and with this brilliant alive energy we can be of service to others. I practice Zhan Zhuang and Qigong and would highly recommend both of these in terms of becoming useful. If you need any info please let me know.
◆
October 5, 2022 — Update 10 Months After Anatta
Ryan BurtonOctober 5, 2022
Update 10 Months After Anatta
From “there is only now” to “there is no now.” From “there is only here” to “there is no here.” From “there is only mind” to “there is no mind.” From “there is only This” to “there is no such thing as a This.” From “I Am Nothing” to “I Am Everything.” From “I Am Everything” to “There is Only Everything.” From “There is Only Everything” to “There are No Things.”
There are No Things— Sunyata (Emptiness). There never was a Thing— Anutpada (Non-arisen).
There never was a Thing nor will there ever be. There is only transience without beginning. Transparency of experience, the “emptying” of the aggregates is the meaning of “all phenomena are like mirages, dreams, dew drops, bubbles, flashes of lightning.”
To see arising and passing is to see impermanency. To see non-arisen is to see without reference points. Without past or future, here and there, now and then— all gone, phenomena as unproduced. What is considered to be a cause or condition cannot actually be found.
All things are “chariot” made of parts put “together” by designation only and therefore are empty. Because they are empty they aren’t there at all. In understanding this it is seen there is no being to liberate, no self that becomes enlightened, no self that was un-enlightened. There’s only dependent origination, there’s only process, illumined, perfect, empty, Buddha activity.
Tasting presence/phenomena as absence, Maha rolls on and on as DO. The myriad field of experience is doing the myriad field of experience. The Universe in every iota of experience—immaculate immensity. Not a shred of a permanent, solid, real anything to be found. No ending, no beginning. Just “This” which isn’t anything at all. Everything is “Wisdom” which cannot be found. Nothing abides anywhere. Non-abiding, non-arisen. No where, No when, No Here, No Now, No referents.
Tathagata.
Still have to finish Finding Rest In Illusion, Shobogenzo and Avatamsaka. If anyone has any advice or corrections please feel free to share. Thank you Soh Wei Yu and John Tan.
Discussion thread
JWJ.W.
Hi Ryan, can you shed some light on your relationship with "conventional" life as it stands? Is it easy for you to engage with the relative, conceptual world despite apprehending its ultimate lack of reference points?
RBRyan Burton
J.W. in former years especially in the “I Am Everything” phase I had some difficulties functioning in life, but those have smoothened out. The difficulty I had with conventional life was mostly from this spiritual life vs ordinary life dichotomy I had in my mind. Since that split vanished a few years ago I haven’t had any issues with conventions. There’s no particular resistance to human construct.
JWJ.W.
Ryan Burton Your description almost reads like a secret chapter of my diary 🙂 Very familiar... Excellent progress, and always a treat to read your content. Be well.
RBRyan Burton
J.W. thanks J.W. 🔥
ORO.R.
Did you go via self inquiry and I Am stage, or were you a vipassana yogi?
RBRyan Burton
O.R. I Am & I Am Everything happened after 7 years of meditation. I read the line “Moksha is to know you were never born” in Ramana’s “Talks” and that’s when it began. My practice was mostly Theravadin Samatha and self-enquiry up to that point. Not much Mahasi or Goenka style vipassana. Just a couple retreats in those traditions.
SWYSoh Wei Yu
Text shown in the image shared with this comment:
John Tan: In short, Kyle is talking about the afflictive twelve-link model of dependent origination (DO), which begins with ignorance—when sentient beings take conventional existence to be real. Sentient beings do not see dependent origination; they see true existence.
John Tan: Dependent origination is an enlightened view prescribed by the Buddha to end proliferation. That is why Nāgārjuna begins by praising the Buddha in the dedicatory verses of the MMK (Mūlamadhyamakakārikā) for teaching dependent origination. Those who see dependent origination also see the eight negations, which are used to describe nirvana. Tsongkhapa shares a similar understanding.
John Tan: There are too many subtle points of mental deconstruction to elaborate on easily.
Soh Wei Yu: Oh, I see...
Soh Wei Yu: What should I tell Ryan?
John Tan: If I have time, I may write to him.
Soh Wei Yu: Oh, I see. Okay.
RBRyan Burton
Soh Wei Yu I’ll message him 🙏 thank you Soh
JPJ.P.
Well said and nice progress! I couldn't have said it better myself
Archived on Awakening to Reality so that these two discussions remain easy to locate and read.
Wow, did you read it all? Essentially covers all the important points. 👍 I think 洪文亮 is probably the only Zen master that is in perfect alignment with all my insights and experiences.
Soh Wei Yu
Haven’t read it yet… going to read. I see.
John Tan
Read the whole piece… many important points. A bit long.
John Tan
This message was deleted.
John Tan
But his explanation of the part between appearance and external reality, in my opinion, is no good.
Hong Wenliang was born in 1933 in Yunlin County, Taiwan. He graduated from the School of Medicine at National Taiwan University and served as a surgeon at Kaohsiung Medical College, an attending surgeon in the surgical department of Kaohsiung Municipal Datong Hospital, and a forensic medical examiner for the Kaohsiung District Prosecutors Office.
As a child, Teacher Hong loved to watch the changes in nature, and he especially loved to watch the rain. Whenever it rained, he liked to hold an umbrella and walk alone in the rain.
The greatest inspiration for Teacher Hong came at the age of nine. While walking on a country path, he saw the smoke from the incense in front of a local Earth God temple and suddenly touched upon that which is before mind, mentation, and consciousness arise. "Strange! How can there be two of me?"
A deep shock and doubt suddenly arose in his heart. This real and profound shock, along with the accompanying doubt, left him with no understanding of what was happening, much less how to resolve it.
After returning home that day, Teacher Hong became melancholic, refusing to eat or drink. He lost a significant amount of weight in a matter of days, and his father even made a special trip home from afar to see him.
From then on, Teacher Hong began to search for answers everywhere. During his school years, when he first encountered physics and chemistry, he thought, "I might be able to find the answer here!" But he was disappointed.
Later, he also delved into the study of the five Chinese arts, psychology, philosophy, science, and more, but all resulted in great disappointment; he was still unable to resolve the real and profound doubt from his childhood.
One day, a friend gave him a copy of Teacher Nan Huai-Chin's book, "A Glimpse into the Sea of Chan." Teacher Hong initially set it aside without much thought. It wasn't until he picked it up to browse during a break that he realized it seemed possible to find answers within it. Thus, through a friend's introduction, he began to study with Teacher Nan Huai-Chin, devoting himself wholeheartedly to cultivation and realization.
Teacher Nan placed considerable trust in Teacher Hong, and Teacher Hong regularly assisted Teacher Nan by giving lectures and leading Chan meditation.
Around 1984, at Teacher Nan's request, Teacher Hong began to give Dharma talks at the Shifang Chan Lin Vihara in Taipei.
After Teacher Nan left Taiwan, Teacher Hong traveled extensively between the United States, Taiwan, and Hong Kong, contributing his energy to spreading the Buddhadharma in his spare time away from his medical practice.
By 1993, after a pilgrimage to Jizu Mountain to pay homage to the Venerable Mahākāśyapa, he followed a command from Teacher Nan and closed the medical clinic that had been his livelihood, dedicating himself entirely to propagating the Dharma.
In 1995, by another turn of fate, Teacher Hong met with Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche in the United States. Rinpoche was extremely happy to see Teacher Hong and immediately invited him to his center in America. He transmitted the Great Perfection teachings to Teacher Hong, and as Teacher Hong was leaving, Rinpoche gave him all the tantric Dharma texts to take back to Taiwan.
In March 1997, the Dalai Lama visited Taiwan for the first time. On that day, after giving a speech in Kaohsiung, His Holiness went directly to National Sun Yat-sen University to give another lecture and receive an honorary degree. After the lecture, His Holiness went to the president's office to be interviewed, and at this time, Dr. Hong was also invited to be present. When Dr. Hong approached to pay his respects to His Holiness, His Holiness unexpectedly lowered his head, touched his forehead to Dr. Hong's forehead, recited a mantra, and held Dr. Hong's hand. For His Holiness, this was a very rare gesture. His Holiness's attendants were all extremely surprised, as they had been with him for decades and had rarely seen him act this way, except when meeting with other Rinpoches. Later, His Holiness inquired about Dr. Hong's lineage and the course of his practice, and was very pleased to have a photo taken with him. He said to Dr. Hong that meeting him was the happiest event of his trip to Taiwan.
During his period of Buddhist cultivation and realization, Teacher Hong had many corresponding states arise in relation to numerous practices, such as the contemplation of the white skeleton, the contemplation of the fire element, the contemplation of the wind element, and so on. Despite this, these accomplishments seemed to be a different matter from his childhood doubt. They seemed to offer no help in resolving the deep and subtle doubt within his heart. Therefore, no matter who recognized or affirmed Teacher Hong, he could never affirm himself.
Later, Teacher Hong was invited to Japan and met with Harada Sekkei Roshi, a direct successor in the orthodox lineage of the Japanese Sōtō school. Teacher Hong had a private interview with Master Harada for two hours, whereupon the great causal condition of awakening upon seeing the morning star manifested, and he and Master Harada mutually authenticated each other's realization.
When Teacher Hong was leaving, Master Harada watched him go. Even when Teacher Hong reached the foot of the mountain and looked back, Master Harada was still standing on the mountainside, gazing at him.
From a talk in 1992
Why Spiritual Practice Is Not Easy to Get Started On
A Transcript of a Lecture by Dr. Hong Wenliang
Interleaved Original Text, English Translation, and Annotations
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 1: Section 壹 , Paragraph 1)
Let's all think together, why is it that after so many years of practicing Buddhism, we feel we are not getting anywhere? What is the reason? Of course, many of you here are new participants, and some are longtime Dharma friends. In terms of meditation practice, I know many are very skilled in the practical aspects. However, today we are here to discuss this topic together. Although we are practicing Buddhism and listening to the Dharma, where do we seem to be benefiting? What dharma-benefits are we receiving? We ourselves do not know. Some practice Pure Land, reciting a Buddha's name; and this recitation also differs—some recite Guanyin Bodhisattva’s name, some visualize Amitābha Buddha, some only recite ‘Namu Myōhō Renge Kyō’¹ (Japanese), and some recite other mantras. Then there are those who practice the Chan (Zen) school; they say: We do not practice mindfulness of the Buddha, we just sit in meditation and work on our meditative concentration. And what about those who practice other dharma gates? The methods are all different.
Annotations (for Segment 1):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 2: Section 壹 , Paragraph 2)
Among the various schools, there are always disputes. Some are very strict, saying things like: ‘You who practice Chan easily go astray or fall into demonic states; practicing mindfulness of the Buddha is steadier and safer.’ Then there are those who practice the esoteric schools (Vajrayāna), who say: “You practitioners of the exoteric schools only know how to talk about principles. You have no actual cultivation and realization, none of that actual degree of realization.” What does this mean? If one had such an actual degree of realization, consider this: everyone must eventually die, and after death there is rebirth. Among practitioners of the Buddha-dharma, who can say before death: “At that moment [of death], I will definitely have confidence”? He says you can’t find many who dare to say such a thing. Why is that?
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 3: Section 壹 , Paragraph 3)
He says: “The situation at the moment of death is very similar to when we are dreaming.” Therefore, if you are dreaming, you yourself do not know that you are dreaming. In the dreamscape, you act as the master of the dream, but you do not know that you are the “dreamer,” whose surname is Hong, given name is... The thought, “I, this person, am dreaming,” does not arise at all! There is no way to spare even a fraction of your mind to know, “I myself am dreaming.” Even when a terrifying dreamscape appears, you are scared to death! You don't even realize that it is illusory,¹ that it is a dreamscape; you will still be very afraid.
Annotations (for Segment 3):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 4: Section 壹 , Paragraph 4)
Someone with genuine meditative skill can transform the dreamscape. “This dream is unpleasant; I don’t want to see it,” and they can change it. In fact, someone who has cultivated meditative concentration very well according to the Buddha’s methods should be able to do this. At the very least, they can divide their attention, setting aside a small part to know, “I am sleeping,” while most of the mind is at rest. One should have this skill, this capacity. Because your sleeping is also your mind, yet you are completely unaware of it. You do not know any of this until you wake up the next day! So you have practiced so much Buddha-dharma, heard so much about Amitābha Buddha and Guanyin Bodhisattva, learned so many mantras, and may even know the theories of the Thirty-seven Aids to Awakening, Madhyamaka, and Yogācāra! But when you sleep, you don't even know your own surname or given name! At the moment of death, the situation is the same as in sleep. Do you really think you will still remember Amitābha Buddha? Will you still know that Guanyin Bodhisattva’s Six-Syllable Mantra is “Oṃ maṇi padme hūṃ”? You won't even be able to utter the "hūṃ"! You will have forgotten your own name, forgotten your own surname.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 5: Section 壹 , Paragraph 5)
Therefore, in our practice, we must consider such practical problems. If you just say, I have studied Buddhism, I follow my teacher in reciting mantras, reciting the Buddha's name, learning to sit in meditation, participating in merit associations, and doing volunteer work—this is not wrong, these are good things. But they are merely tainted¹ good deeds; they are not of complete or great benefit. Therefore, to truly practice Buddhism, you must consider the actual degree of realization you have genuinely attained. Merely performing formal prostrations, practicing mindfulness of the Buddha, or just knowing the explanations of the sūtras is of no help to you at all, and of course, it is of no use to others either. This is a very practical problem.
Annotations (for Segment 5):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 6: Section 贰 , Paragraph 1)
So, why are we talking today about "not getting anywhere"? "Not getting anywhere" actually means: have you experienced any real benefit, any dharma-benefit? There was a very famous Rinpoche from Tibet named "DILGO," Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche, who just passed into parinirvāṇa last year. He analyzed that many people who practice the Buddha-dharma do not practice well because they have one of three kinds of defects. He used the analogy of filling a teapot with water. He said:
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 7: Section 贰 , Paragraph 2)
第一种 是根本就把茶壸倒过来,让你不能装进去,很多人是这样子。
第二种 茶壸里有一个洞,你怎么装,都从小洞里漏出去!听了一百次,忘了一百
次。再多参加几次法会、禅修、念经、读经,通通大部分都忘掉了,从洞
里漏出去了,这是茶壸有洞。
第三种 很严重,这茶壸里头有毒!你放甘露也好,清净的水也好,茶壸里本身有
毒啊!这个水变成毒水,喝了会毒死人!
English Translation (Segment 7):
The first type is that the teapot is turned completely upside down, so you cannot pour anything into it. Many people are like this.
The second type is that the teapot has a hole in it. No matter how much you pour in, it all leaks out from the little hole! You listen a hundred times, and you forget a hundred times. No matter how many more dharma assemblies, meditation sessions, sūtra-chanting sessions, or sūtra-reading sessions you attend, you forget most of it. It all leaks out through the hole. This is the teapot with a hole.
The third type is very serious: the teapot contains poison! Whether you pour in nectar or pure water, the teapot itself is poisonous! The water becomes poisoned water, and drinking it will kill people!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 8: Section 贰 , Paragraph 3)
This means that before you accept and listen to the Buddha-dharma, your own thoughts, your own concepts, and your value judgments are already fixed. You have extreme views, you have wrong views; you already have many views in your own mind. Therefore, no matter how you listen, you take things out of context! Originally, the Buddha taught: "All dharmas are neither empty, nor existent, nor non-existent." But oh! This person doesn't understand the true meaning of "existent" and "non-existent," and thinks, "Ah! It's not 'existent' and not 'non-existent,' so it must be this 'middle'!" Not belonging to existence, and not belonging to non-existence, so they grab onto a concept of "the middle," and believe they have understood the Buddha-dharma. But that is simply another position among left, right, and middle. Where is that “middle”? If you do not know left or right, where could the middle be? He does not know. In any case, it's "neither empty, nor existent." He thinks, "I know the core of the Buddha-dharma is this, one cannot speak of existence and one cannot speak of non-existence. Hey! I've got it."
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 9: Section 贰 , Paragraph 4)
这个是什么?他已经有 “ 对有跟空,跟平常人接受这个东西的存在的有没有,在这个境界里,判断那个中间。 ” 他以为这个是 Middle Way ,中庸之道。像这样的错误,是常常见到的例子。像这样的情况之下,他的边见、邪见加进来,把佛法扭曲了。我们叫 distorted 。这个扭曲,是非常严重的。本来佛是这样讲,但是一扭曲,变成别的意思去了。
English Translation (Segment 9):
What is this? He already has a preconceived way of "judging the middle within the context of existence and emptiness, based on an ordinary person's acceptance of whether things exist or not." He thinks this is the Middle Way, the doctrine of the mean. Errors like this are common. Under these circumstances, his extreme views and wrong views are added in, distorting the Buddha-dharma. We call this being "distorted." This distortion is extremely serious. Originally, the Buddha taught it one way, but once it is distorted, it turns into a different meaning entirely.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 10: Section 叁 , Paragraph 1)
Right now, we are talking about this aspect of distortion: our misunderstandings, our extreme views.
First, all dharmas¹—everything we see, hear, can touch, even smell, and taste with our tongue, or think of in our minds—we say they are without self-nature,² without their fundamental essence.³ What you see and hear is all through your mind; how your mind receives something is how you perceive that thing to be. If we do not reflect deeply on this, we easily overlook it.
Annotations (for Segment 10):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 11: Section 叁 , Paragraph 2)
For example, this color white. What I see is white, and all of you also see it as white, believing that whiteness is its characteristic and will absolutely not change! But would other animals, like a horse or a color-blind person, also see it as white? It could be green, or red; they are all different. Which color, then, is the true appearance¹ of color? Our eyes are located on the flat plane of our face. If our eyes, like a fish's, grew on the left and right sides, then when a fish leaps from the water to look at Mount Fuji, the way it appears would be different from the Mount Fuji we see. It's the same Mount Fuji, but its shape has changed again.
Annotations (for Segment 11):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 12: Section 叁 , Paragraph 3)
Therefore, everything seen, heard, and touched does not have its own intrinsic characteristic.¹ We understand and experience all of them through our mind. That appearance is not its true fundamental nature,² because a fundamental nature does not exist. Therefore, all dharmas are without self-nature. Furthermore, you are able to know that all these dharmas are without self-nature, without their "Self-nature," without that inherent quality of "existing without relying on other conditions."
Annotations (for Segment 12):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 13: Section 叁 , Paragraph 4)
Knowing occurs through our mind, yet we do not realize that this mind itself is also without self-nature! Does the mind have a shape? Does it have the appearance of color? Does it have a size? Does it have weight? Is it located in any particular part of the body? In the chest cavity? In the brain? You search and search but cannot find it! Where does your mind come from? From what point in the past did it begin to exist? Until when in the future will it continue? You search and search, but cannot find it.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 14: Section 叁 , Paragraph 5)
That these reflections¹ appearing through the mind are without self-nature is easy for us to understand. But the mind itself is also untouchable and unfindable. We call this quality "the inherent characteristic of the mind." What characteristic? Emptiness! This is called emptiness. Therefore, this emptiness is actually the mind’s infinite and limitless potential to experience all kinds of phenomena. This includes reflections and sensory experiences. Whether we are born or we die, whether in saṃsāra or attaining Buddhahood and nirvāṇa, these are all experiences! They are all states experienced by the minds of sentient beings. Saṃsāra and nirvāṇa are both experiences of the mind.
Annotations (for Segment 14):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 15: Section 叁 , Paragraph 6)
But what is the reason that you are able to experience this and not experience that? It is according to our good karma and bad karma, the results of our actions, correct? However, the mind itself has this limitless capacity: it can undergo all kinds of countless, unrestricted experiences. This is its characteristic! Because it can experience such an unimaginable range without limit, it itself has no fixed nature.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 16: Section 叁 , Paragraph 7)
If it were round, it could not experience what is square; if it were red, it would not know what is white; if it were heavy, it would not know what is light; if it were located here, your mind could not function elsewhere! Location, Size, Shape, Color—these things, and even taste—you cannot use a single adjective to describe its characteristics. There is no object or adjective you can use to describe it. It has this quality, and this quality is called emptiness.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 17: Section 叁 , Paragraph 8)
所以,空不是什么都没有,反过来可以讲:空什么都有可能。什么都可能经验,有这个特性,所以我们把这个叫做空~心的它的原来的本性。它本来是这个样子。好,这个自性本空,它没有自性,没有一个东西可以限制它,描述它,或指定它。但是,它能够显出各种各样的经验,让你尝受到,自己尝受、自己经验自己。这个不是我们二元世界的情况。处在轮回的众生,没有办法了解 Mind ,这个心。
English Translation (Segment 17):
Therefore, emptiness is not nothingness. Conversely, you could say: in emptiness, anything is possible. It is possible to experience anything. It has this characteristic, so we call this emptiness—the original, fundamental nature of the mind. It is originally like this. Okay, this self-nature is fundamentally empty; it is without self-nature, there is nothing that can limit it, describe it, or designate it. However, it can display all kinds of experiences for you to taste: you yourself taste them, and you yourself experience yourself. This is not the situation of our dualistic world. Sentient beings in saṃsāra are unable to understand Mind, this mind.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 18: Section 叁 , Paragraph 9)
请大家千万不要误会,以为我们看到这个茶杯,看东西,知道这个是手表,看到这一位是林教授,那一位是一个 lady ,以为这个是我的心。错了!佛讲的心,不是这一种心!我们时常把这作用;因为有对象,你看到、你听到、你摸到,才知道的这个作用;我们把它当作心。
English Translation (Segment 18):
Everyone, please do not misunderstand. Do not think that when we see this teacup, look at things, know that this is a watch, see that this person is Professor Lin, and that one is a lady—do not think that this is my mind. Wrong! The mind the Buddha spoke of is not this kind of mind! We often take this function—this function of knowing that arises because there is an object that you see, you hear, you touch—and mistake it for the mind.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 19: Section 叁 , Paragraph 10)
But, the Buddha said: This mind is not the right one! You absolutely must know this; this is the very first thing to know! This means taking an object as a condition and reaching out toward it¹: using the ears to cling to sound, using the eyes to cling to color, right? Using the nose to cling to scent, and the tongue? To taste, to cling to that flavor. Using the mind to cling to and remember the content of your thoughts. This is all the grasping mind! The grasping mind is not the mind being discussed here! The mind being spoken of here is, in its fundamental nature, empty; it does not refer to this grasping mind. Therefore, we have forgotten this true mind that we inherently possess. We mistake that which is not our true mind for our own mind.
Annotations (for Segment 19):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 20: Section 叁 , Paragraph 11)
He gives an analogy: a child is switched at a very young age, and the parents don't know. They raise the child, always believing this child is their own biological child. Suppose your biological son is taken by the neighbors and switched; you do not know it and forever believe the child you are raising is your own biological son. We take this grasping mind to be our own mind. So we look, we listen; when we hear something displeasing, we get angry. When we see something beautiful, we like it very much—we take the grasping mind as our self! We take this thing that is not our true mind and treat it as our self. As a result, this grasping mind gives rise to many impressions and emotions: liking, disliking, aversion, hatred, jealousy, displeasure—these are all brought out by the grasping mind. This is "Emotion"; all these emotions are brought out by the grasping mind. These emotions grow larger and larger, like a snowball, and become our habitual tendencies, our personality. We have been completely deceived by this grasping mind! Why are we deceived? "Distortion"—extreme views. There is poison! The teapot contains poison! We have once again misheard the mind that the Buddha spoke of!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 21: Section 肆 , Paragraph 1)
肆、无明的根由
所以,最根本的无明是什么?就是真正你的心, mind 它的真正的空性,那个空性,你抓不到。没有智慧看清楚你自己的心的真正的本性,禅宗所讲的 “ 本地风光 ” 。这个本地风光看错了,把它当做我。
English Translation (Segment 21):
Section IV: The Root of Ignorance
So, what is the most fundamental ignorance?¹ It is that you cannot grasp the true emptiness of your own mind. Without the wisdom to see clearly the true fundamental nature of your own mind—what the Chan school calls the "original ground and scenery"²—you misperceive this original ground and scenery and take it to be an "I."
Annotations (for Segment 21):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 22: Section 肆 , Paragraph 2)
Because this empty nature, your own fundamental nature, your original mind—the mind's original ground and scenery—is empty in nature, yet you misapprehend it, you see this empty nature wrongly! You grasp that state, that "thing" which is the original ground and scenery, as being "I." This is the origin of the "self-view."¹ Then the "I" begins to exist, doesn't it? Originally it is empty and without self-nature, with many "Limitless Characteristics"; it cannot be captured by any limiting description. You lack the wisdom to recognize the empty nature of your own true mind, and then you take this empty nature, this "Essential Empty," this which is originally empty and without self-nature—you distort this into "it is I," and so the concept of "I" appears.
Annotations (for Segment 22):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 23: Section 肆 , Paragraph 3)
Because this is the mechanism by which fundamental ignorance appears. This is very, very subtle, and I am deliberately explaining it verbally. In truth, once you know this principle, you still need direct realization—a "direct real," a direct experience—and that has to come through meditative concentration. So, why is it that we often read the sūtras or listen to a teacher's logical inferences, and we feel they make sense, yet they have no power? Why? Because you only understand this as "knowledge." 'Ah! So it turns out our true mind is not that object-referential kind of mind; it possesses this incredibly supreme potential that is impossible to describe'—as the Sixth Patriarch said upon his awakening, "Who would have thought that self-nature is inherently complete!"¹ It is originally endowed with so many capacities: it can cognize and is clearly aware. But it does not belong to any "one" thing, which is why it is called "empty." You fail to recognize this, and so you take it to be your own "I." "This is I." Therefore, the five aggregates—form, feeling, perception, formation, and consciousness—come together as one aggregated appearance,² and we believe this aggregated appearance is “I”! We have a general, vague sense of it! The moment fundamental ignorance stirs, you fail to recognize that empty nature, the true empty nature, and you mistakenly recognize it as "I." This is the poison in our teapot!
Annotations (for Segment 23):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 24: Section 肆 , Paragraph 4)
Now then, once there is an "I," a problem arises. Because there is an "I," "you" appears. If it's not me, it's the other party, it's you! Once there is a "you," then a third, "he/she," appears, and even more sentient beings appear. When there is an "I," looking at objects from my perspective, the "I" and "that which is opposed to it" emerge, and the dualistic, deluded state appears. Duality means there is a "subject" and an "object."¹ "I" see this "watch," "I" touch this "cup." If there is no "I," who touches this? Because you are always holding onto this body and mind; from childhood until now, what I do, that I am male or female, my surname, my job, I am a teacher, I am a doctor, I am... this "I" is constantly being reinforced. So, after the "I" exists, of course there is an "other." The "I" and "that which is opposed to it," subject and object, are established. We call this "duality," "Dualistic"; the dualistic conceptual world manifests.
Annotations (for Segment 24):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 25: Section 肆 , Paragraph 5)
二元的概念呈现,开始有什么?保护我,不能让你占便宜!你说什么我就不高兴,你说我怎么样我就高兴。贪嗔痴慢疑五种情绪,五种真正的烦恼大病,就开始有了。 没有你我之分的话;你说什么让我高兴的话,我会很快乐吗?你讲一句毁谤我的话, Blame me 就很不高兴;这种情绪会来吗?因为有你我的关系,当然就有这个情绪发生。
English Translation (Segment 25):
Once the dualistic concept manifests, what starts to happen? "I must protect myself, I can't let you take advantage of me!" "If you say something, I get unhappy; if you say something else about me, I get happy." Greed, aversion, delusion, arrogance, and doubt—the five kinds of emotions, the five great sicknesses of affliction, then begin to exist. If there were no division between you and me, if you said something to please me, would I be so happy? If you said a word to slander me, to "blame me," would I get so unhappy? Would this kind of emotion arise? Because the relationship of "you and I" exists, this emotion will of course occur.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 26: Section 肆 , Paragraph 6)
Alright! Encountering many situations, sometimes you get angry, sometimes you are happy; greed, aversion, delusion, arrogance, and doubt keep rolling on, becoming a habit, which then becomes your habitual tendency. Someone who gets angry easily will be even more prone to rage when they encounter the opportunity. Some people, upon encountering a certain situation, will become greedy and want a little more. This is because of emotions, because of these five great sicknesses. Some are more heavily afflicted with one of these sicknesses, while others are more lightly afflicted with another. Slowly, slowly, it becomes your habitual tendency, and "it's hard to change one's nature," it becomes what you call your “nature.”
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 27: Section 肆 , Paragraph 7)
Now, because these habitual tendencies are brought forth, in your daily life when dealing with people and situations, you are often "Unskillful," very unwise. Every sentient being, including the smallest insects, wants to pursue happiness and avoid suffering; they all want to be happy. They don't want to be sick, too hot, or in too much pain. They pursue happiness because there is already "self-grasping," there is a "perception of self."¹ Everyone wants to pursue happiness, "Happiness"! But why does the happiness we ordinary sentient beings pursue fail to turn out as we wish? The error lies in this "Distortion," this extreme view. To pursue from a "selfish" standpoint will never satisfy you and will, moreover, bring even more "Suffering," more pain! If you could know all this and give rise to true compassion, to forgive others—if this kind of true compassion arises, it will, on the contrary, bring us a great deal of happiness, but we do not know this.
Annotations (for Segment 27):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 28: Section 肆 , Paragraph 8)
This is our great delusion: seeing something before our eyes that is beneficial to us, we think it can bring us happiness. And the result? We go in the opposite direction, like climbing a tree to find a fish. What can truly bring you happiness and joy is the ability to give rise to a truly "Non-Conceptualized," non-conceptual compassion.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 29: Section 肆 , Paragraph 9)
‘Conceptualized’ Compassion, Compassion that Seeks Something
Much of the time, it seems as though we have done many compassionate deeds. But this compassion, if we reflect on it, is often based on our own concept of compassion: "Doing this and this is compassion." We call this 'conceptualized' compassion, "Conceptualized Compassion." Why "Conceptualize"? This word is too philosophical. It should be put like this: "It is I who am being compassionate to you!" 'I see you are pitiful, so I am compassionate and give you these things.' 'I am giving you charity.' 'I am comforting you.' Is there an "I" in this? Yes. Is there an "other"? Yes! 'I see you are pitiful!' 'I see you are foolish, so I am instructing you.' 'I see you have no money.' 'I see you are cold, so I am giving you an extra piece of clothing.' 'I am giving you a little money.' All of these involve an "I am giving you" or "I am doing" some good deed for you. This is all compassion within concepts! Because you have self-grasping, you have the perception of a self, the perception of another person, and also the perception of a sentient being who is the object of this compassionate act. The perception of self, perception of a person, and perception of a sentient being mentioned in the Diamond Sūtra are precisely this. Therefore, if it is like this, it is not the true compassion of a Bodhisattva.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 30: Section 肆 , Paragraph 10)
Of course, these are good deeds. However, their merit and benefits do not decisively determine your future rebirth or which of the six realms you will enter. Speaking of the six realms of saṃsāra, sometimes I find it very interesting watching roulette on TV. When playing roulette, the ball keeps rolling, and wherever it falls, if you win a prize of fifty thousand or twenty thousand dollars, you are very happy, right? When we are in the six realms of saṃsāra, the force that pushes that ball is our own karmic power. It rolls and rolls and rolls through the six places—the god realm, the hungry ghost realm¹, the hell realm, the animal realm, the human realm, or the asura realm—and wherever it falls, you must be reborn there. When the time for rebirth comes and the realm of rebirth is decided, your will has absolutely no autonomy!
Annotations (for Segment 30):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 31: Section 肆 , Paragraph 11)
When we are awake, we know what we want to do. But at the moment of death, even wanting to drink tea—this kind of coarse, object-referential function of the mind—cannot arise at all! You don't even have that much power! It is just like the body in a dream; you cannot control it. For someone without meditative concentration, without true practice of the Buddha-dharma, who just chants sūtras and sits in meditation—that is all just playing around. For a person whose practice has not actually become their true power, at that critical moment, it will have no effect whatsoever. At that time, you are just like the ball in roulette; wherever it rolls, that's where you go. You have no way to say: "I want to come to the human realm to seek the Bodhi path again," or "I want to manifest in a human body to help many sentient beings." You can't. Therefore, this extreme view—the poison in the teapot, or something already in the teapot—means that any water you pour in becomes impure water. This is a very serious matter.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 32: Section 肆 , Paragraph 12)
But generally, we are especially unclear about our own extreme views and wrong views. If someone else is slightly incorrect, or what have you, we say, "Oh! You are an atheist," or "Oh! You are a theist." We are very clear about that. But when it comes to our own views, it's like our own eyes being unable to see themselves; it is extremely difficult to know our own views. That is why Mr. Nan Huai-Chin often said that telling someone to drop their afflictions, to have fewer afflictions, is very easy. But telling them not to cling to their views is extremely difficult! If you say any more, he'll want to stab you. You can't say more. If you do, he'll say, "What do you know! Our teaching is like this."
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 33: Section 肆 , Paragraph 13)
It's like what I just said about the teapot being upside down so you can't fill it with water; sometimes, it is because of a person's views. "Because I believe in Jesus—go on, say another word!" He hears one sentence, the very first sentence, and he is already unhappy. He turns and walks away, stops listening, will not listen at all! So the teapot has these defects. In particular, what I especially want to report to you all today is how we perceive the "I." We constantly feel "it is I," and this self-view is very difficult to eliminate. Let's try and see: when you are sleeping, do you still have a self-view? Is there still the existence of an "I," the thought "I am sleeping"? Yes! When you are dreaming, you also feel "I am dreaming." It is extremely difficult to eliminate!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 34: Section 肆 , Paragraph 14)
Someone once said to me, "Dr. Hong, you say that external things and phenomena are all without self-nature, that they are actually all projections of the mind. That it is through your mind that you use your eyes to perceive an appearance, or use your ears to hear a sound, or your nose to smell a scent, or your tongue to taste sweetness, bitterness, or spiciness. That thing must pass through your mind for you to become aware of it. Without passing through the mind, this object has no meaning for you."
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 35: Section 肆 , Paragraph 15)
He gave an example, he asked me: "For instance, this cup is here. You say this cup originally does not exist, it is without self-nature, completely without self-nature. But you know this is a teacup because your eyes see it and your hands touch it! Or you might even open the lid and take a drink, and only then know this is a cup of tea. This sensory experience, I admit 'it' is without self-nature. Whatever your tongue is like, that is the flavor it will perceive; if you tap it, your ears hear a high or low pitch, a long or short sound, and know the sound of it being tapped; your hand makes contact, and whatever that tactile feeling is, it only exists through your mind! That sensory experience is through your mind, I admit it is completely without self-nature. However, when you die, and someone else, say Professor Hou, comes here to look, this teacup is still here! I have died, but this teacup is still here! It has nothing to do with your consciousness! It was there all along. You say: this is completely without self-nature, that it originally does not exist. You are telling an untruth!"
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 36: Section 肆 , Paragraph 16)
这个人很聪明,能够这样反驳,是相当深入的思惟。但是,他的错误在那里?很多念唯识的还错在这里:他以为他有一个心能够观察,他有他的 Mind ,他有他本身的心能够知道: ‘ 这个东西,虽然我没有了,但这个东西依然在这里,这个茶杯没有破坏掉 ’ ,这是很重要的一点。你走了,你不在了,但你讲:这个存在,是因为你的关系这个存在,它本身没有。是 ‘ 你 ’ 的心的影像。那你走掉、你不在了,怎么侯教授还看到这个杯子呢?那这杯子,是跟我存在不存在,毫不相干的存在嘛! Independently Existence ,独立的存在嘛!你还讲什么 “ 这个心的影像 ” !他的错在那里?哈!9
English Translation (Segment 36):
This person is very intelligent. To be able to offer such a rebuttal requires quite deep thinking. But where is his mistake? Many who study Yogācāra still make this mistake: he thinks that he has a mind that can observe, that he has his Mind, that he has his own mind that can know: 'This thing, although I am gone, this thing is still here, this teacup has not been destroyed.' This is a very important point. You are gone, you are no longer here, but you say: this existence is there only in relation to you; in itself it is not there. It is a reflection of 'your' mind. Well then, you are gone, you are no longer here, so how can Professor Hou still see this cup? Then this cup's existence is completely unrelated to whether I exist or not! It is an “independent existence,” an existence independent of me! How can you still talk about "reflections of the mind"! Where is his mistake? Ha!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 37: Section 肆 , Paragraph 17)
He is again grasping tightly to the function of his own mind, "my mind's function," his mind's function is still there! The mind the Buddha spoke of is not 'you have your mind, and he has his mind'! He fundamentally tells us: this 'mind that we think we have'—you taking that grasping mind as the mind—that is where the mistake is! The mind he points to is this: 'all that manifests within the entirety of space-time is a "Manifestation" of that Mind.' This is the point one fails to penetrate. Whether it's the table, or celestial bodies—the Earth, the sun, the stars—the flow of space and time, all of it is a manifestation of the true mind, the Buddha-mind. This is the principle, the principle of Yogācāra and Madhyamaka. But if this principle has not been penetrated "Through Meditation"—the most important thing is meditation; without meditation—you will not penetrate this point! This is not something you have directly realized.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 38: Section 肆 , Paragraph 18)
你听别人讲了好几次:夏威夷多好玩、多好玩!你没有亲自到那地方,好玩是人家说的啦!旅行的指导书讲的啦!或者是那个照片上看的啦!你真的亲自到了那个地方,你才能说: Oh ! Hawaii , Wonderful !所以,我们这个前面的很多见,像我分析的这个 Mind ,为什么会有那一种错误、对于这个空性这么大的错误认知? 禅修的重要就在这里!那是因为:你没有好好的去做禅修!禅修的重要就在这里!跟我们做学问有一点不同。这个禅修,毕竟你真的要上座,真的要!坐在椅子上也可以,念佛就念佛、念佛号就念佛号、观想观自在菩萨、或者观想准提佛母,一定得坐,不坐,没有办法证入这个境界!没有办法你的妄想心都使它休息、停掉!真正的心显现的那个境界,你不可能达到。 这是喜欢用头脑、用概念、用自己的聪明才智去做学问的,像我这样,过去的习惯这样带来的人,最大的一个缺点 (Short Coming) !很不容易去想到这一点!除非你真正放下去做,这个经典、理论,都只是让我们多一层知识, Knowledge ,而已!
English Translation (Segment 38):
You've heard others say many times: "Hawaii is so much fun, so much fun!" But you haven't personally been to that place. That it's fun is what other people have said! What the travel guidebooks say! Or what you've seen in photographs! Only when you have truly, personally arrived at that place can you say: "Oh! Hawaii, Wonderful!" Therefore, these many views we hold, like the mistake regarding the Mind that I just analyzed—why do we have that kind of error, such a great mistaken cognition of this empty nature? The importance of meditation lies right here! It is because: you have not properly practiced meditation! The importance of meditation lies right here! It is a bit different from doing academic scholarship. For this meditation, you absolutely must get on the cushion, you really must! Sitting on a chair is also fine. If you practice mindfulness of the Buddha, then practice mindfulness of the Buddha; if you recite the Buddha’s name, then recite the Buddha’s name; visualize Guanyin Bodhisattva, or visualize Cundī Buddha-Mother. You must sit. If you don't sit, there is no way to realize this state! There is no way to make your deluded mind rest and stop! The state where the true mind manifests—it is impossible for you to reach it. This is the biggest "Short Coming" for people who like to use their heads, use concepts, and use their own intelligence to pursue knowledge, people like me, who have brought these past habits with them! It is very difficult to think of this point! Unless you truly let go and do it, these sūtras and theories will only give us one more layer of knowledge, "Knowledge," and that's all!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 39: Section 伍 , Paragraph 1)
Section V: Three Defilements in Studying Buddhism That Make Practice Difficult to Get Started On
Several Mental States That Make Practice Difficult to Get Started On
Besides this, Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche talked about those defects in oneself—the three defects, right? The teapot being upside down, having a hole, and being poisonous! Now he brings up three kinds of defilements, "Pollution," or "Stains," blemishes. These several defilements make it very difficult for our practice to get on track.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 40: Section 伍 , Paragraph 2)
第一个是骄傲, Pride ,就是傲慢。「贪瞋痴慢疑」的第四个大毛病,傲慢。
他说:傲慢是对师父或对你的老师、或者你的上师,觉得他的做人不行嘛!他有的时候发脾气嘛!他有的时候,对某一个东西也非常贪着嘛!他的法,讲来讲去,都是诸行无常啦、诸法无我啊!这些书上都有呀,那有什么稀奇!我看了都知道!对他的法、对他的为人,都觉得是没什么!那个不是你的傲慢心来的吗? Pride 。有了这么一点染污,你修法呢?绝对不上路!尤其是对你的师父、对你的上师,有这一种傲慢心的话,绝对不成。这是顶果钦哲仁波切谈到的第一个染污,傲慢。他把这个傲慢,摆在第一个!
English Translation (Segment 40):
The first is pride, "Pride," which is arrogance. It is the fourth of the five great sicknesses: greed, aversion, delusion, arrogance, and doubt. He says: Arrogance is when you feel that your master or your teacher, or your guru, is not good enough as a person! "He sometimes loses his temper! He is sometimes also very attached to certain things! As for his dharma, what he talks about over and over again is just that all conditioned things are impermanent and all dharmas are without self! These are all in the books, what's so special about that! I've read them and I know it all!" You think there is nothing special about either his teaching or the way he conducts himself! Isn't that coming from your arrogant mind? "Pride." With even a little of this defilement, your practice? It will absolutely not get on track! Especially if you have this kind of arrogant mind towards your master, your guru, you will absolutely not succeed. This is the first defilement Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche spoke of, arrogance. He put this arrogance first!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 41: Section 伍 , Paragraph 3)
释迦牟尼佛在初期塬始的阿含经裡,他讲过一句话,他讲:『能离我慢,顺得涅槃。』我时常记到这一句。因为我求学的过程太顺利了,就觉得这不难嘛!念书不难嘛!这个害我养成了傲慢的心态,变成我最大的缺点!现在,当然还是有习气、还有很多,很不容易掉。这是害我不能成佛,障碍我的道的最主要的一个塬因, Pride 。『能离我慢,顺得涅槃。』,顺就是自然的意思,很自然的就得到涅槃。能离我慢, 很自然你不要用功、不要用力,自然你能得到涅槃!不得了呀!他只讲一个法门哪!只要你能够离开我慢,自然水到渠成,得到没有烦恼的境界。1
English Translation (Segment 41):
Śākyamuni Buddha, in the early, original Āgama sūtras, said one sentence. He said: “If one can be free of self-conceit, one naturally attains nirvāṇa.”¹ I often remember this sentence. Because my own academic career was too smooth, I just felt, "This isn't hard! Studying isn't hard!" This caused me to develop an arrogant mindset, which became my biggest flaw! Now, of course, I still have habitual tendencies, still a lot of them, and they are very difficult to drop. This is the main reason preventing me from attaining Buddhahood, the principal obstruction on my path: "Pride." “If one can be free of self-conceit, one naturally attains nirvāṇa.” Here, he explains 順 as meaning “naturally”: you very naturally attain nirvāṇa. If you can be free of self-conceit, then very naturally, without striving, without effort, you can naturally attain nirvāṇa! That's incredible! He is only talking about one dharma-gate! As long as you can be free of self-conceit, then, like water arriving and the channel forming of itself, you will naturally attain a state free from afflictions.
Annotations (for Segment 41):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 42: Section 伍 , Paragraph 4)
Because, where does self-conceit come from? It comes from self-grasping! Without the perception of a self, how can there be self-conceit? Because you emphasize that "it is I who am capable, you all are not!" My "Knowledge," my scholarship, my good looks, my beauty, my whatever... everything is mine, mine, mine. Therefore, as I just said, you lack the wisdom to truly recognize the empty nature of all dharmas: everything, including space-time, is without self-nature. You do not have the wisdom to realize this directly. At this point, "Confusion" immediately arises, and in that confusion you take it to be "I"!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 43: Section 伍 , Paragraph 5)
宗萨仁波切把这个叫做 Shock ,你被无明 Shock 掉了,休克掉了!所以,当下就觉得是我。那『我』的概念是从 Shock , Being Shocked !被震坏了,震撼掉了!这个结果,就是『有我』。那是 Because you want of wisdom ,没有智慧的结果,你就在一瞬间就觉得『这是我』。这个我的开始,『 I 』,那变成『 I am 』,『我』变成『我是』。我是什么?我是男的,我是女的,我是中国人,我是有钱,我是聪明,『 I 变成 I am 』,我是 ‧‧ ;那我是之后呢?变成什么? I want ,我需要。我要什么,都从「 I 」开始, I 到 I am , I am 变成 I want ,这样愈滚愈大。这个 delusion ,这个妄想境界, Confusion 这样来的3。
English Translation (Segment 43):
Dzongsar Rinpoche calls this a "Shock"; you have been "Shocked" by ignorance, you've gone into shock! So, in that instant, you feel that it is "I". The concept of 'I' comes from this "Shock," from "Being Shocked"! From being shaken up and stunned! The result is the sense that ‘there is an I.’ That is because of a lack of wisdom; in a single instant you feel, ‘This is I.’ This is the beginning of 'I'. From 'I', it becomes 'I am'. 'I' becomes 'I am'. What am I? I am male, I am female, I am Chinese, I am rich, I am smart. 'I' becomes 'I am.' 'I am...' And after 'I am'? What does it become? "I want," I need. Whatever I want, it all starts from "I". "I" becomes "I am," "I am" becomes "I want." It rolls and gets bigger and bigger. This "delusion," this delusory state, this "Confusion" comes about in this way.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 44: Section 伍 , Paragraph 6)
所以一个 Pride ,他提出来,对你的师父,你向他恭敬都做不到,批评他这个不对、那个不对,「哎!师父还有这个习气喔!」、「师父的见解没什么嘛!」、「哎!这个经典都在讲嘛!」,如果有那么一点点,那个念就障碍了你的道!这是 Pride !
English Translation (Segment 44):
So, one thing is "Pride," which he brought up. If you cannot even show respect to your master, and instead criticize him for this and that—"Hey! Master still has this habit!" "Master's view is nothing special!" "Hey! This is all said in the sūtras!"—if you have even a tiny bit of this, that thought obstructs your path! This is "Pride"!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 45: Section 伍 , Paragraph 7)
What is the second? The first "Stain" is pride. The second is "Indifference," apathy. Not caring! Oh, today you're talking about this Buddha-dharma, about how to be liberated from the cycle of birth and death. If we believe what the Buddha said—that this cycle of death and birth definitely exists, that after death there is a state, and after passing through that state which we cannot control, we will undergo another rebirth, another life—if you believe this, you would absolutely not be indifferent. Because of this indifference, it doesn't matter whether you know or don't know. "Anyway, I'll just come and listen," as if it were a pop song; if you hear it, you hear it, and if you don't, it doesn't matter! Apathy, "Indifference." So this apathy makes it very difficult for us to achieve true accomplishment in our practice of the Buddha-dharma! "Whatever you're talking about, I'm just listening anyway. If I don't have the chance, I just won't listen!"
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 46: Section 伍 , Paragraph 8)
So Śākyamuni Buddha, when he first began to teach the dharma—please pay attention everyone—he turned the wheel of the Four Noble Truths. He didn't say anything else; the very first time he taught, he taught the Four Noble Truths. What was the first one he taught? The Noble Truth of Suffering! He said: Life in saṃsāra is suffering! Don't think that saṃsāra is: sometimes happy, sometimes joyful, "life is pretty good!" "I have money, fame, and a long life; I don't lack anything; I'm not blind, not deaf, so it's not bad!" "My younger siblings, children, and grandchildren are all filial, not bad!" "My students are all obedient!" "My monthly salary might even go up every month!" Right? So he says: Everyone, you have misperceived! Actually this saṃsāra, which makes us feel that this happiness is not bad—that is a false appearance!¹ If you truly reflect on it, there is nothing—no saṃsāric existence, no mode of existence—that is truly happy. The Truth of Suffering, the Noble Truth of Suffering! Because we do not know suffering, we do not want to leave! Not wanting to leave, we become indifferent! "Indifference," not wanting to leave! "Hmph, this is not too bad. I'll come back and be a human again." "If I die, so be it; coming back as a human again wouldn't be so bad!"² (Taiwanese). Just like that, indifferent. Because you do not know the Truth of Suffering, the suffering of saṃsāra.
Annotations (for Segment 46):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 47: Section 伍 , Paragraph 9)
However, there is a pitfall here. Many people who study the Buddha-dharma have heard about saṃsāra and nirvāṇa too many times. The true suffering of saṃsāra that Śākyamuni Buddha spoke of—they don't have the wisdom, they are not illuminated by the light of wisdom, they haven't seen it clearly, they haven't seen it in meticulous detail. They are unable to see; they only see a tiny bit. "Oh! So that's what's called suffering! I know, I know." What is this called? He has created a new saṃsāra in his concepts, in his imagination. We can call it the 'new saṃsāra.' And then, oh, he practices the dharma, goes into retreat, does good deeds, prostrates, recites 'Namu Myōhō Renge Kyō' (Japanese), and thinks of a state of nirvāṇa. He has fabricated for himself, using imagination and concepts, a new saṃsāra, and then desperately tries to throw away the saṃsāra he himself has created! This is a common sickness among us practitioners. This is indifference! This is the second.
Annotations (for Segment 47):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 48: Section 伍 , Paragraph 10)
第叁个毛病,昏沈和掉举
我们活到的时候,对世间法太执着、太用心了,法执很重!看得太过分, Take it too seriously 。非常执着的话,你在用功,这个修佛法的时候,很容易这个散乱,我们叫『掉举』。如果不是掉举的话呢,因为疲劳了,一上坐,一修佛,一念咒,你就会昏昏沈沈 Drowsiness 。不是昏沈,就是掉举,就犯这个第叁个毛病。 (昏沈和掉举7)
English Translation (Segment 48):
The Third Sickness: Dullness and Agitation
When we are alive, we are too attached to worldly dharmas, we put too much heart into them; our grasping at phenomena is very strong! We see it too excessively, "Take it too seriously." If you are very attached, then when you are applying effort in practicing the Buddha-dharma, it is very easy to become scattered; we call this 'agitation.'¹ If it is not agitation, then because you are tired, as soon as you get on the cushion, as soon as you start your practice, as soon as you recite a mantra, you will become drowsy, "Drowsiness."² It's either dullness or agitation; you fall into this third sickness. (Dullness and agitation)
Annotations (for Segment 48):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 49: Section 伍 , Paragraph 11)
Some people think: "Oh, my career is at its peak right now. I don't have time to listen to the dharma, nor do I have time to spend five or ten minutes to think about these principles the Buddha taught, or to quiet my mind and do the practice of calming. I don't have time. I'll wait ten years, or wait until my children are grown up, then I'll talk." This is being affected—being “annoyed”—by circumstances! There is another type of person who says: "Oh! There's no way!"¹ (Taiwanese). "To become a Buddha is so difficult, I can't do it." This is "Discouragement"; they don't have the courage to learn. So, from the very beginning, they use this excuse, saying: "I don't have what it takes! To become a Buddha, how could that be possible for me! I can't do it! I'm not able! I cannot do such a difficult thing! I don't want to!" There are people like this too. All of these are "Stains," defects, all are incorrect mental states.
Annotations (for Segment 49):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 50: Section 伍 , Paragraph 12)
Now, regarding these teachings: why is it not easy for us to get started in practicing the Buddha-dharma? As for these “Teachings,” what they teach—the problem is that our attitude and our way of applying ourselves are wrong. This part is relatively straightforward. What does he say? Some people know the scriptural wording and terminology; they know all the technical terms. They have a literal understanding of the wording, but they do not know its meaning. They lack a definite understanding of what it actually points to. Some people are the opposite: they know the meaning, but they often forget the technical terms. This is also not good! Then there are those who know both the terms and their meanings, but, excuse me, they do not know the ultimate meaning,¹ the genuinely ultimate meaning. Śākyamuni Buddha sometimes spoke for convenience, in sūtras of provisional meaning.² They understand and remember the words, they also know the meaning, but they do not know the ultimate meaning, and so they go wrong.
Annotations (for Segment 50):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 51: Section 伍 , Paragraph 13)
有的人文字也知道,意义也通,究竟义也知道,但是他呢,次第颠倒了。修佛法是有次第的,一个次第,一个次第慢慢进步,他把次第弄颠倒了。好像,我们修无上瑜珈 (YOGA) ,应该是先修生起次第,对不对?生起次第修好了,你才修圆满次第,一步一步来。圆满次第要先修「身远离」,然后是「语远离」,然后是「心远离」 ( 有的人叫意远离 ) ,然后修那个净光,「根本净光」,对不对?净光修好了,你再修「幻身成就」,是不是?幻身成就了,你最后才修 Union ,「融合」。这是圆满次第的六次第。你前面的身远离都没有;身远离知道意思吗?9
English Translation (Segment 51):
Some people know the words, understand the meaning, and also know the ultimate meaning, but they have inverted the sequence. Practicing the Buddha-dharma has a sequence; you progress slowly, one stage after another, but they have mixed up the sequence. For example, when we practice Highest Yoga (YOGA) Tantra, we should first practice the generation stage, right? Only after you have practiced the generation stage well can you practice the completion stage; it's step by step. For the completion stage, you must first practice "body isolation," then "speech isolation," then "mind isolation" (some call it mental isolation), and then you practice that clear light, the "fundamental clear light," correct? After you have practiced the clear light well, you then practice the "attainment of the illusory body," right? Once the illusory body is attained, you finally practice "Union," "fusion." These are the six stages of the completion stage. You haven't even done the initial body isolation—do you know what body isolation means?
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 52: Section 伍 , Paragraph 14)
Everyone, perhaps those who are practicing already know; if you haven't even practiced body isolation well, and you immediately want to practice the clear light, you think to yourself: "Oh! When I die, the first 'Stage,' the first thing that appears, is the slow dissolution of the four elements, then the function of the subtle mind appears, and when the fundamental clear light appears, if I recognize it, I will attain the dharmakāya and be liberated!" So you immediately try to practice this clear light, and consequently, during meditation, you desperately try to see light. As a result, what kind of light does he see? The kind of light that can drive you crazy! That means you've been taken in by mere light-and-shadow appearances! This is truly a terrible thing.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 53: Section 伍 , Paragraph 15)
Speaking of this, I am reminded of an error concerning seated meditation; many people make a mistake here. Because they have heard the Buddha-dharma—emptiness, seated meditation, being able to settle the mind, many states appearing—they get on the cushion. Whether they are reciting the Buddha's name, reciting a mantra, visualizing a syllable wheel, or visualizing a Buddha image, they really sit very well! At this point, there is a fork in the road. The very first and most common sickness that can occur is that you fall into an annihilatory emptiness.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 54: Section 伍 , Paragraph 16)
The principle of emptiness—he has not penetrated it thoroughly, has not illuminated it with wisdom, because your merit and wisdom are insufficient! You have not done enough good deeds, and have done many bad deeds. Bad behavior, that "Karmic Tendency," the tendency of negative karma has not been eliminated, and if you immediately try to understand, to thoroughly penetrate emptiness, you will run into problems. You will end up grasping onto emptiness and not letting go. In an annihilatory emptiness, one believes that nothing exists. "How can there be karma? How can there be good actions? How can there be evil actions? How can there be any Buddha-dharma? How can there be any Pure Land? Nothing exists!" They don't believe in anything. Emptiness! They think this is emptiness. This is very dangerous (to cultivate an annihilatory emptiness), a very great crisis! Grasping at emptiness, it becomes an annihilatory emptiness! Nothing exists, they don't believe in anything! "Cause and effect? Retribution? That's what you superstitious people talk about. What cause and effect and retribution? This world is just realistic; if you earn more money you'll be comfortable. With money you can buy a house, buy a car, wear beautiful clothes, and people will be submissive and flatter me..." Emptiness like this becomes the nihilistic view of emptiness. The second, third, and fourth defects are sicknesses that those who are truly practicing are more susceptible to.
Annotations (for Segment 54):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 55: Section 陆 , Paragraph 1)
陆、真妄之别 因为真正的心,它本身有明觉、明照,它本身不是煳裡煳涂的,它本身不是什么都不知道。心,我讲的是真心,不是攀缘心。真正的 RIGPA ,藏文把这个真的心,用 RIGPA 表示,把我们那个攀缘的心叫 SEM ;现在我看到各位,听到声音,能起作用的这个,是攀缘心,不是你的真心;我们给这个攀缘心骗了,所以一直在轮迴,这个心叫做 SEM 。它分得很清楚, RIGPA 是真正的心。我介绍中阴身解脱的时候,头一个 Stage 就出现的那个净光, Clear light of The death ,那死净光,那是 RIGPA 。所有一切都从这裡出现,这个是真正的佛心。有的人1教做佛心,禅宗叫本地风光,或者是用『这个』、『那个』讲这个。有的呢,唯识学家就是『真常唯心』的『真常』。但是呢、印顺长老常常讲『真常唯心』是这个密宗、禅宗的真常论,其实他是从学问讲的。真常唯心的『唯心』,不是你用想像概念,去想那个真常的那个,它既不属于无常、也不属于真常。常、无常都是你的概念,时间就是一个妄想境界,既然时间是妄想,你怎么能够描写这个 RIGPA 是真常呢2?还是无常呢?你不能把它用时间的概念套进去描写它嘛!所以真正的 RIGPA ,不是这样的东西!
English Translation (Segment 55):
Section VI: The Distinction between True and False
Because the true mind itself has clear knowing and clear illumination; it is not muddled or confused, it is not something that knows nothing. The mind—I am speaking of the true mind, not the grasping mind. The true RIGPA—in Tibetan, this true mind is represented by the word RIGPA, while our grasping mind is called SEM. Right now, this functioning—seeing all of you and hearing sounds—is the grasping mind, not your true mind. We have been deceived by this grasping mind, and that is why we are continuously in saṃsāra. This mind is called SEM. The distinction is made very clearly: RIGPA is the true mind. When I introduced liberation in the intermediate state (bardo), that clear light which appears in the very first stage, the "Clear light of the death," that death-time clear light, that is RIGPA. Everything arises from this; this is the true Buddha-mind. Some call it the Buddha-mind; the Chan school calls it the "original ground and scenery," or they use "this" or "that" to speak of it. Some, like the Yogācāra scholars, speak of the "True-Constant" of "True-Constant-Mind-Only." However, Elder Yin Shun often said that "True-Constant-Mind-Only" is a doctrine of true permanence in the esoteric schools and the Chan school; actually, he was speaking from a scholarly perspective. The "Mind-Only" of True-Constant-Mind-Only is not something you can think about with your imagination and concepts, that "True-Constant" thing. It belongs neither to impermanence nor to true constancy. "Constant" and "impermanent" are both your concepts. Time itself is a delusory state. Since time is a delusion, how can you describe this RIGPA as being truly constant? Or as impermanent? You cannot fit it into the concept of time to describe it! Therefore, the true RIGPA is not this kind of thing!
Annotations (for Segment 55):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 56: Section 陆 , Paragraph 2)
This death-time clear light, RIGPA itself—its "Essential Nature," its fundamental nature, is empty, right? I have introduced this many times. However, it also has other characteristics. This characteristic—everyone, please pay close attention! After you know this characteristic, you will be clear about what the phenomena that manifest in the bardo stage, or the phenomena that emerge when you are in seated meditation, truly are, and you will not be deceived by them! This mind, the true mind, the Buddha-mind or the original ground and scenery—its fundamental nature is empty. Although it is empty, it itself has clear knowing and illumination—vividly clear and aware, lucid and distinct; “Clarity” is its inherent quality. It itself is clear. This clarity does not mean, "I see this cup and know this cup"—that is delusion, that involves a subject and an object. The capacity that can see and can manifest many phenomena—that which can know brightness and darkness—does not itself belong to brightness or darkness. To know "bright"—that is to stir a deluded thought, "Ah! This is bright." Delusion! "There is no light, this is dark"—that is already to have stirred a dualistic thought, it is already "Dualistic," already "Conception," already conceptualized, already a delusory state. That knowing capacity does not itself belong to brightness, nor does it belong to darkness! Otherwise, when brightness passes, you would not know darkness! When darkness passes, if that which knows darkness belonged to darkness, then when brightness arrived, you would not know it either! It itself does not belong to brightness or darkness, right? The Śūraṅgama Sūtra explains this slowly.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 57: Section 柒 , Paragraph 1)
This "Clarity," this characteristic of bright, clear knowing—when you are in seated meditation, practicing, truly in "Meditation," you will come into contact with this state of clarity! Alright, because you have practiced so diligently, your level of practice is very good. Many people's level of practice is not this good, so they won't make this mistake. However, your meditative practice is very deep, very high, and you can reach a deep concentration. What does a deep concentration mean? It means that the kind of function belonging to conceptual thought, to the brain, has completely disappeared. That false function disappears, continuously disappears, drops away, until you come into contact with the vividly clear knowing of the original mind, the original ground and scenery. If you mistakenly think, "This is it," you begin to cling to this clarity. If you don't cling, you are correct! But you think that this original mind, the Buddha's original mind, the original ground and scenery, the Buddha-mind, is this, that this is the self-nature. You think this is the self-nature, you are "Clinging," you are attached, you have grasped it, right? Once you take that thing as an object and grasp it, problems arise! You sit in meditation, apply effort, practice mindfulness of the Buddha very well, and you are able to see the clear knowing of your own mind. Believing "this is it," you begin to cling to it. At your future rebirth, you will be unable to escape saṃsāra. Where will you go? Professor Lin? To the heavens. How many heavens are there? Seventeen; which one a person reaches differs according to their condition during life. Does everyone know about the three realms? There are seventeen heavens, layer after layer. Depending on the clarity of your knowing—how bright and clear it is—you will be reborn in one of the seventeen heavens and become a deva! Become a god! In many Taiwanese customs, we worship the "Lord of Heaven" (天公), but sometimes this is a deva of the desire realm! Not yet in the form realm.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 58: Section 柒 , Paragraph 2)
This clear knowing—if you mistake it for the self-nature, the Buddha's original ground and scenery, then at your next rebirth, during the bardo of rebirth, bingo! You are instantly reborn in this place of clarity! Then, our true mind also has another side, another "aspect" that can be used to describe it: it is very blissful, "Bliss." Bliss, clarity, and non-conceptuality are its attributes. Didn't I just speak of clarity? If you mistake this clarity for our Buddha-nature, thinking that our own mind is simply this clarity, and you grasp onto it, you will be unable to gain liberation from the three realms and will go to one of the seventeen heavens to become a deva! Not bad, becoming a deva. Now take bliss—true bliss, a bliss that far surpasses the pleasure of the desire realm, surpasses it by many, many times. Some people, meditating to this point, oh! It feels so good they don't want to leave the meditative state! They indulge in that comfortable state of bliss, which exceeds the pleasure of male-female desire in the desire realm many, many times over, and they take this to be it! This is why many friends out there who have a decent level of meditative skill, those who talk about supernatural phenomena—don't look down on them! Many of them have a meditative skill that can reach bliss, clarity, and non-conceptuality. But the mistake lies in not having the Buddha's right view; they take this to be real, to be the Tao, to have arrived home! That it is Buddha-nature, that it is the self-nature, that it is the dharmakāya! It's over! Where are they reborn? In the desire-realm heavens. The desire realm—at the very top of our desire realm are the desire-realm heavens. We are in the desire realm, aren't we? Within the desire realm, there is the animal realm, the human realm! At the very top are the desire-realm heavens. Reborn in the desire realm, they become a deva of a desire-realm heaven, not a deva of a form-realm heaven, but a desire-realm deva! Why are they reborn here? Because of bliss, it's extremely comfortable, so blissful you don't want to leave the state.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 59: Section 柒 , Paragraph 3)
Alright, what is the last attribute? Non-conceptuality.¹ In that state, you have no dualistic thoughts. You have already reached a “Non-Conceptualized” state; the conceptualized dualistic state is absent. It doesn't arise; your mind does not stir, absolutely does not stir. The delusion here is thinking, "This is emptiness." The moment you cling, you take this emptiness to be the real Buddha-nature, the secret source of the myriad phenomena of the universe—"this is it." Grasping this "Emptiness" as an object, where are you reborn? The formless realm. The formless realm—when you die, you do not pass through the intermediate state (bardo). Instantly, this "Consciousness," this spirit-consciousness², emerges and immediately, instantly, without passing through the bardo, you are immediately reborn in the formless realm. This is because your meditative skill is too good. The formless realm has four planes: the sphere of infinite space, the sphere of infinite consciousness, the sphere of nothingness, and the sphere of neither perception nor non-perception. You go to one of these four places in the formless realm, who knows which one. This is all because you perceived it wrongly, you were off by just a tiny bit. The experiences of bliss, clarity, and non-conceptuality during seated meditation constitute an exceptionally sublime meditative state. However, if you lack the right view, if you lack an experienced person or a true teacher to give you an "Oral Instruction," you become happy because of this state. Your state of clarity might enable you to know things. When people come to ask you questions, you can answer them—for example, whether someone may have a car accident³ a month from now, or what realm they were in during a past life. At that point, such things are clear to you; you have reached that state. That is very impressive. But, the moment you cling to it, it becomes an obstacle. You will continue to roll in the three realms, unable to break free. You must transcend this, only then! Because of clinging to bliss, clarity, and non-conceptuality, the final fork in the road becomes like this. Therefore, my dharma friends who practice meditation, you must absolutely pay attention to this point! Therefore, actual experiential verification is extremely important!
Annotations (for Segment 59):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 60: Section 捌 , Paragraph 1)
Section VIII: Why is it So Hard for Us to See the True Mind?
Now, for the last question, a very interesting question. Why is it so hard for us to see the mind? Why don't we understand the true mind? We fail to recognize RIGPA; we only recognize this SEM. We are turned by circumstances, carried away by circumstances, with no way to guard and sustain this genuine RIGPA—the RIGPA you occasionally glimpse in a flash! This RIGPA is very interesting—please everyone, pay attention—it's not only in meditative concentration that you can see the fundamental clear light, the original face of the mind. But in meditative concentration, it flashes by and is gone. Truly great masters with meditative skill, like Dilgo [Khyentse Rinpoche], Kalu Rinpoche, Jamyang Khyentse, these great masters, or Dudjom Rinpoche, they are able, within their meditative concentration practice, to abide in, to rest in this "Clear Light," the fundamental clear light, without having to wait until the moment of death for it to appear!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 61: Section 捌 , Paragraph 2)
Some dharma friends might have this phenomenon appear while sitting in meditation, but it's very likely just for one or two seconds; it flashes and is gone. It is very difficult; you see it yourself but don't even know it. It manifests, and you are not aware. Some people with slightly better concentration and slightly better wisdom are able to know it, but have no way to "Stabilize" (sustain) it. The “sustain” in “guard and sustain it well” means this. The Diamond Sūtra’s phrase “guard it well and keep it in mind” is what he is referring to here. It's not just talking on a superficial level, saying, "Don't give rise to greed!" When you truly see the Way, this is called "realizing the mind and seeing one's nature." After truly realizing the mind and seeing one's nature, you enter and exit concentration, enter and exit concentration. After awakening, why do you still have to practice? It is precisely to be able to lengthen the time of the 'clear light,' the "Duration," to be able to maintain it, to protect it for as long as possible, to be able to abide in that concentration for as long as you wish.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 62: Section 捌 , Paragraph 3)
Therefore, when Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche passed away last year, he remained in the fundamental clear light for over half a year. But he told his disciples: “If by the 4th day of the 11th lunar month (in 1993) I have not yet transformed into light, cremate me.” His body, which was two meters tall, had by that time (the 4th of the 11th month) already shrunk (transforming into rainbow light) to be as small as 30 centimeters (in a seated posture). A lama friend of mine from Pingtung went to Nepal and saw this personally, and came back and told me. Dudjom Rinpoche was also the same, shrinking to become just as small, and Master Gonga was the same.
Editorial chronology note (Segment 62):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 63: Section 玖 , Paragraph 1)
玖、死亡的实相 为什么能这样呢?我们死掉,物质的四大~地水火风,开始慢慢分解,然后,粗的心慢慢溶掉 (dissolve) 、细的心出现,白心、红心,然后,最后全黑暗时期,一闪,根本净光出现!打坐的时候一样,就是把这个四大分解,粗心分解的过程在坐中经验!这个 Experience 是 Your mind itself !你的 mind 本身! Mind 可以体验, Experience 无限无量的境界, 所以说它有『无可限制的特性』!所以说 Limitless Characteristics ,没有办法限碍它,所以把它叫做『空』。但是这个空,威力大得很!死的时候,它能够经验很多境界、很多的相。由于你过去的业力、你的习惯,它能够显出来:你多坏,它就显出多坏的可怖的相;多慈悲、心多柔,那个时候,它就显出净土的境界出来;对你的上师、对你的师父,非常诚敬,那你的师父的影子,他的智慧、就由你的 Mind 现出来,所以把心叫做不可思议!很多人误会了,通通从概念裡头看佛法,不从实証的立埸讲。出家的师父,也可能都注重解说,或从宗教信仰方面去开脱,而它是实証的、科学的东西,不是说光在那裡讲来讲去,『好心肠啦!』『拜佛,你就可以到西天啦!』 ‧‧‧ ,那是靠不住的。为什么靠不住?因为你没有进到实验室去做实验!怎么做实验呢?等一下我们有时间再解说!
English Translation (Segment 63):
Section IX: The Reality of Death
Why is this possible? When we die, the four material elements—earth, water, fire, and wind—begin to slowly dissolve. Then, the coarse mind slowly dissolves, and the subtle minds appear—the white mind, the red mind¹—and then, finally, during a period of total darkness, in a flash, the fundamental clear light appears! It is the same during seated meditation; you experience this process of the dissolution of the four elements and the dissolution of the coarse mind while sitting! This "Experience" is "Your mind itself!" Your mind itself! The Mind can experience, can "Experience" infinite and limitless states, which is why it is said to have "unlimited characteristics"! It is said to have "Limitless Characteristics"; there is no way to limit it, which is why it is called "empty." But this emptiness has tremendous power! At the time of death, it is able to experience many states, many appearances.² Based on your past karma, your habits, it is able to manifest them: however bad you were, it will manifest correspondingly terrible appearances; however compassionate and gentle your mind was, at that time it will manifest the state of a pure land. If you had great reverence for your guru, your master, then your master’s image³ and his wisdom will manifest from your Mind. This is why the mind is called inconceivable! Many people misunderstand this; they see the Buddha-dharma entirely from within concepts, not from the standpoint of experiential verification. Monastics, too, may focus on explanations or explain things away from the standpoint of religious faith, whereas this is a matter of experiential verification, something scientific. It is not about just talking and talking, "Be a good person!" "Worship the Buddha, and you can go to the Western Paradise!"... That is unreliable. Why is it unreliable? Because you have not entered the laboratory to conduct the experiment! How do you conduct the experiment? We'll explain later if we have time!
Annotations (for Segment 63):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 64: Section 拾 , Paragraph 1)
拾、禅修的真正目的 这是个实証的功夫。我们讲到四大分解,细心现出来。根本净光在禅定、禅修的时候,不管你是光打坐、或者是念咒,或者是观想观世音菩萨,或者準提佛母,你能够自己、慢慢知道你的心的变化,经验的过程慢慢变,变到最后定中出现光。因为你不是等到死嘛,这个叫子净光, Son Clear Light 。是你修行的功力和智慧达到这个本事。做到才算本事,没有做到,那是书上写的,是释迦牟尼佛的,诸大菩萨的,不是你的4!你会讲法,你会穿着袈裟讲来讲去,被人恭维,到死的时候一点用都没有,不管你是什么大师不大师!平常听懂佛法,知道如何用功,在日常生活裡真正培养你的慈悲心,把心净化了,在念佛中或者打坐中,一闪,看到净光,定中看到。并且,你能够时常训练,出定入定,在出入中,慢慢的你能够跟它 ( 净光 ) 熟了,你出定时成就幻身!这是一个秘密!
English Translation (Segment 64):
Section X: The True Purpose of Meditation
This is a matter of actual experiential verification. We spoke of the dissolution of the four elements and the manifestation of the subtle mind. As for the fundamental clear light, during meditative concentration and meditation practice—whether you are just sitting, reciting mantras, visualizing Guanyin Bodhisattva, or visualizing Cundī Buddha-Mother—you can gradually become aware of the changes in your own mind. The course of experience changes step by step until, finally, light appears in concentration. Because you are not waiting until death, this is called the Son Clear Light. It is your power of practice and wisdom that achieves this skill. Only when you have done it does it count as your skill; if you haven't done it, then it's just what's written in books, it belongs to Śākyamuni Buddha, to the great Bodhisattvas, it's not yours! You may be able to teach the dharma, you may wear robes and talk on and on, be complimented by people, but at the moment of death, it is of no use at all, no matter what kind of master you are or are not! If in ordinary life you understand the Buddha-dharma, know how to apply yourself, genuinely cultivate compassion, and purify your mind, then during mindfulness of the Buddha or seated meditation, the clear light may flash forth—you see it in concentration. Furthermore, if you can train constantly, entering and exiting concentration, then in the process of entering and exiting, you can slowly become familiar with it (the clear light). When you exit concentration, you attain the illusory body!¹ This is a secret!
Annotations (for Segment 64):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 65: Section 拾 , Paragraph 2)
定中慢慢、慢慢,好像死亡现象的境界,最后根本净光出现 ( 佛光出现 ) ,然后出定,再变作平常的你。 React process 倒过来, Reverse 。因为你的智慧的力量,你出定的时候,并不走普通人的『黑心 → 红心 → 白心』这个路子,出定时,你会成就一个『幻身』, Illusory Body ,我们叫『浊幻身』。当然,平常一般人没有办法做到很『纯净』的幻身,刚刚开始成就的时候,变做『浊』幻身。但是,悟后你时常这样练习,由于你的功力、定力和智慧的关係,最后变成『净幻身』。所谓净幻身,是在印度,二千五百年前佛的色身。释迦牟尼佛他也有色身,祂的色身跟我们为什么不同5?这个净幻身,就是我们自己成佛的时候,色身的基础。我们的肉、皮都会烂掉,这是生灭法。所以,定中能够做到的修行人,悟后起修,是在修这个,要成就幻身!
English Translation (Segment 65):
In concentration, slowly, slowly, you experience a state that resembles the phenomenon of death, and finally the fundamental clear light appears (the Buddha-light appears). Then you exit concentration and become your ordinary self again. The "reaction process" is inverted, "reversed." Because of the power of your wisdom, when you exit concentration, you do not follow the ordinary person's path of 'black mind → red mind → white mind.' Upon exiting, you will attain an 'illusory body,' an "Illusory Body." We call this the 'impure illusory body.' Of course, an ordinary person cannot achieve a very 'pure' illusory body. When it is first attained, it becomes an 'impure' illusory body. However, if you practice like this constantly after awakening, due to your power, concentration, and wisdom, it will finally become the 'pure illusory body.' The so-called pure illusory body is the form-body of the Buddha in India two thousand five hundred years ago. Śākyamuni Buddha also had a form-body; why was His form-body different from ours? This pure illusory body is the foundation of the form-body when we ourselves attain Buddhahood. Our flesh and skin will all decay; this is a phenomenon of arising and ceasing. Therefore, a practitioner who can accomplish this in concentration, who practices after awakening, is practicing this: they must attain the illusory body!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 66: Section 拾 , Paragraph 3)
有了幻身,就不会有生灭的身体。浊跟净有什么差别?浊幻身就是,你对空性还是概念的了解;你成就净幻身是:你的智慧,已经达到 directly realize 、直接悟认、亲証到空。你稍微有真正的空的智慧,它变成你实在的力量、实在的智慧,你有这个本事!我们的 Mind ,我们的心的本性是「空」。初地菩萨就亲証到了!初地,开悟了。这个时候和你没有亲証到空慧,有什么地方不一样?举个例子,千手千眼观世音菩萨,千手、每一个手拿东西,手指裡头有眼睛啦、相是怎么样啦,你如果时常修这一尊的话,当你証到空慧的时候,一『定』下来,祂的千手千眼、每一隻手、衣服、颜色、形状,甚至有一百个很小的项目,都可以同时记到、显现!但是,每一位修的本尊都不一样,并不是每一位都这样。如果你修的本尊是準提佛母的话,你说:我了解空、我証到空。那么这个修行人,怎么知道呢?他眼睛一闭起来观想準提佛母;不是矇眬,刚开始练习是矇眬;每一隻手指、眼睛,手裡拿什么东西,十六隻手剎那间清清楚楚现出来,不要费力,这就是証明。 Prove It !做到,算是对空慧有一点了解。这是无上瑜珈讲很深的 Teaching( 教授法 ) ,请大家应该感谢无上密宗的传承,很多(空行)都在这裡听!
English Translation (Segment 66):
Once you have the illusory body, you will no longer have a body subject to arising and ceasing. What is the difference between impure and pure? The impure illusory body means your understanding of the empty nature is still conceptual. Attaining the pure illusory body means that your wisdom has reached direct realization: you directly recognize and personally realize emptiness. Once you have a little of the true wisdom of emptiness, it becomes your real power, your real wisdom; you have this skill! Our Mind—the fundamental nature of our mind—is "empty." A first-bhūmi Bodhisattva has directly realized this! On the first ground, they have awakened. At this time, what is the difference between you and someone who has not directly realized the wisdom of emptiness? Let's take an example: Thousand-Armed, Thousand-Eyed Guanyin Bodhisattva—a thousand hands, each hand holding an object, with eyes in the fingers, the appearances being thus and so. If you regularly practice this deity, then when you realize the wisdom of emptiness, as soon as you 'settle' in concentration, Her thousand arms and thousand eyes, every single hand, the clothes, colors, shapes, even if there are a hundred small items, can all be remembered and manifested simultaneously! However, the chosen deity of every practitioner is different; it's not like this for everyone. If your chosen deity is Cundī Buddha-Mother, and you say, "I understand emptiness, I have realized emptiness," then how does this practitioner know? When he closes his eyes to visualize Cundī Buddha-Mother—not vaguely, as it is vague when you first start practicing—every finger, every eye, what is held in each hand, all sixteen arms¹ manifest with perfect clarity in an instant, without effort. This is the proof. "Prove It!" To have done this counts as having some understanding of the wisdom of emptiness. This is a very profound "Teaching" from Highest Yoga Tantra. Everyone should be grateful for the transmission of the highest esoteric schools; many (ḍākinīs) are listening here!
Annotations (for Segment 66):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 67: Section 拾 , Paragraph 4)
As the wisdom of emptiness becomes deeper and deeper, the freedom of the mind can be brought to its fullest expression! What does this mean? The mind is originally extremely free ("Freedom of Mind"), but because of our delusions, we grasp the grasping mind, believe "this is I," and take my mind to be "me." Therefore, the many, unlimited "Manifestations" and the freely-acting capacity of the true mind (RIGPA) are all covered over and cannot be expressed. A person who has realized the wisdom of emptiness can freely express this capacity. So why could the Venerable Milarepa, in the midst of concentration, instantly emanate ten or twenty tigers at the foot of the mountain to block bad people from coming up? This is the expression of the mind's freedom; it is not a supernatural power, nor is it miraculous. You have to realize this directly. If you are not like this, but instead rely on talismans and incantations, or on possession by malevolent spirits to display some supernatural ability, that is falling into a demonic state, being possessed! It does not come from your concentration and wisdom! When you truly develop and see RIGPA, this true mind, this true 'emptiness,' you dissolve—you “Dissolve”—and then we appear together with the “wisdom of emptiness.” The freedom of the mind is controlled by you with perfect ease. This, and only this, is called truly realizing the wisdom of emptiness!! It is not what we talk about with our mouths: 'All dharmas are without self-nature; they are assembled from many conditions and have no fundamental essence, this is emptiness.' That is theory. If your karma is such that you are to become a tiger, can you say, "I don't want to become a tiger, I want to become a cockroach"? You have no way to do that! Let alone becoming a human! Therefore, practice is something real and concrete, not just talking about theory.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 68: Section 拾 , Paragraph 5)
Let's further explain the essence-nature and function of the mind. We now know that its fundamental nature, its "Essential Nature," is Emptiness. There is no way to describe its shape, size, "Color," or "Location." So what about its function? Its "Clarity" is a bright, clear knowing. Therefore, our ability to know phenomena is its Saṃbhogakāya. The "Essential Nature"—that is its Dharmakāya; we call it its "Dharmakāya." It itself has vivid clear knowing and illumination; we call this its Saṃbhogakāya. Everyone, don't get all confused by dharmakāya, saṃbhogakāya, and nirmāṇakāya. Actually, these are states of direct realization. What does "Nirmāṇakāya" mean? It is the ability to present all sorts of forms, a "Limitless Manifestation" that appears according to your karma: if you think of a space shuttle, a space shuttle appears. This unobstructed ability to manifest is what we call its 'emanation body,' its "Manifestation," which is the Nirmāṇakāya.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 69: Section 拾 , Paragraph 6)
So, for friends who have just begun to study Buddhism, when you encounter the Buddha-dharma there are many precepts. We are told to have revulsion for the world: "This is not good, this isn't real, this is unreal,¹ we shouldn't cling"—Hīnayāna, this is the Hīnayāna teaching. The Hīnayāna teaching is: "Everything is real, but it is impermanent, it will change, so we should not cling to it!" A cup is a cup, a person is a person, a bad person is a bad person, a good person is a good person, a woman is a woman, a man is a man, one cannot casually have contact with the opposite sex. This is to make you generate a sense of revulsion. However, it does not teach you that these things are 'unreal,' but only speaks of 'impermanence.' Impermanence implies that it really exists, but that it will change, it will die, it will get old, it will be destroyed, it will become worn out! It does not directly tell you: "Originally, all is empty." Because when we are just beginning to study Buddhism, our wisdom is not yet developed, so we are taught this way.
Annotations (for Segment 69):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 70: Section 拾 , Paragraph 7)
When your wisdom has developed a little, he comes with a "Mahāyāna," a Great Vehicle teaching. He says: "All of this is illusory and unreal, empty and without self-nature!" The 'empty and without self-nature' that he speaks of still acknowledges that there are appearances and phenomena! Those phenomena are empty and without self-nature, but because people do not know this, they fight for fame and profit. If you truly understand the wisdom of emptiness which is without self-nature, if you truly understand the principle of 'emptiness,' you will certainly feel compassion for these people. Everyone is unaware, and there they are, fighting and snatching from one another, fighting until their heads are broken and blood flows. It is so pitiful, including yourself. Therefore, the Mahāyāna is compassionate, with altruism as its main spirit.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 71: Section 拾 , Paragraph 8)
最高的教授是什么?我们这裡叫做『金刚乘』、『密乘』,这只是我们给的名字,其实佛在世的时候已经教了的,尤其是莲花生大士带来的。就是时机到了,因为你透过小乘、大乘,有基础了!没有这个基础,你没有办法!你没有通过小学、中学、大学,能不能念研究院呢?不能呀!一样呀,佛法最高的教授,在最后,佛才讲真话:「一切相,都是法身的显现!」。一切相,空间、时间,有情、无情,物质的、有生命的,通通是 Dharmakaya ,都是佛的净土!境界是佛的净土,我们看到的众生,每一位都是你的本尊, Deity ,都是佛的身!每一位众生、每一个毛孔都是衪!净土那裡找呀?到西方找阿弥陀佛净土呀?当下即是!你的智慧高,没有 Impure Perception ;用眼耳鼻舌身意所接受的 Perception 是觉受嘛;你的智慧开了,妄想的云雾清除掉了。你的 Perception 本身,变成纯净的 Perception 。所映现的,都是佛的净土,这是最高的教授。 Each and Every Being ,都是 Deities !声音,空中飞鸟的声音,大家在纸上写字的声音,所有声音,都是佛的咒音、佛的真言。声音那裡来呀?你说:是空气振动经过神经,所以变成声音。那是给喜欢理论的人的解说。其实,声音本身空无自性。那空无自性怎么有声音?本来没有东西,怎么会显现成声音?佛的咒音!都是佛性现出来的。
English Translation (Segment 71):
What is the highest teaching? Here we call it the 'Vajrayāna,' the 'Esoteric Vehicle.' These are just names we give it; actually, the Buddha already taught this when he was alive, and it was especially brought by the great master Padmasambhava. It is when the time is right, because you have gone through the Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna and now have a foundation! Without this foundation, you can't do it! If you haven't gone through elementary school, middle school, and university, can you study in graduate school? No! It's the same. The highest teaching of the Buddha-dharma—at the very end, the Buddha finally spoke the truth: "All appearances¹ are the manifestation of the Dharmakāya!" All appearances, space, time, the sentient and the insentient, material and living things, all of it is Dharmakāya, all of it is the Buddha's pure land! The objective realm is the Buddha's pure land. The sentient beings we see, every single one is your chosen deity, your "Deity," the body of the Buddha! Every sentient being, every single pore, is the Buddha! Where do you look for the pure land? Go to the West to find Amitābha's pure land? It is right here in this very moment! If your wisdom is high, you have no "Impure Perception." The "Perception" received through the eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body, and mind is sensory experience. When your wisdom has opened, the clouds and mist of delusion are cleared away. Your "Perception" itself becomes pure "Perception." All that appears is the Buddha's pure land. This is the highest teaching. "Each and Every Being" is a "Deity"! Sounds—the sound of birds flying in the sky, the sound of everyone writing on paper—all sounds are the Buddha's mantra-sound, the Buddha's true words. Where does sound come from? You say: "It is the vibration of air passing through the nerves, which then becomes sound." That is an explanation for people who like theories. In truth, sound itself is empty and without self-nature. If it is empty and without self-nature, how can there be sound? If there were originally nothing, how could it manifest as sound? It is the Buddha's mantra-sound! All of these are manifestations of Buddha-nature.
Annotations (for Segment 71):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 72: Section 拾 , Paragraph 9)
And what about our thoughts? Sound can still be distinguished as high or low, long or short; though it is certainly without form,¹ there is still "Voice," there is "Sound." This is the state of the Saṃbhogakāya, of the Buddha. And thoughts? "I am able to know what you are thinking in your mind." That is the wisdom of emptiness I just spoke of. A person who has realized the wisdom of emptiness to a considerably high degree, if they pay attention to you, will know what you are thinking. They have truly realized that, entered into that state of the "wisdom of emptiness." Human thought itself is the Dharmakāya, the state of the Dharmakāya. Formless, without characteristics,² colorless! You don't know it, you can't see it, but how are you able to move your body and speak words? If your mind does not move, you cannot move! The body and speech are both commanded by the 'mind' ( 意 ). The mind is the monarch, body and speech are the slaves! So how does the mind move? It moves, but we cannot see it! Does it have a color? Does it have a taste? Where does it move? We don't know any of this! It is the Dharmakāya, the Buddha's Dharmakāya. Sound is the Saṃbhogakāya of all Buddhas. What manifests is the Buddha's pure land. Every single one of you sentient beings is a "Deity"!
Annotations (for Segment 72):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 73: Section 拾 , Paragraph 10)
Knowing this, you then take this right view as the basis for meditation practice. You cultivate concentration and wisdom; after concentration there is wisdom, and after wisdom, concentration and wisdom unite. Such a state is called 'one taste'¹ in the esoteric schools, and in the exoteric schools it is called 'concentration and wisdom held in equal balance.' The steps of meditation practice are: first, one-pointedness; second, freedom from conceptual elaboration; third is one taste; and the fourth? No-meditation. So-called one-pointedness is concentration. Your mind is fixed on one point and does not move; it is not influenced by the environment, scattered, or dull. Once you have settled the mind, only then can you, in a very stable state of mind, contemplate what all the Buddhas have taught—'everything is without self-nature'—and develop the wisdom of emptiness. This is the cultivation of wisdom; we call it 'freedom from conceptual elaboration.'² The information we gather through the eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body, and mind is all related to "Impure Perception"; it is all conceptual proliferation!³ The simplest and most obvious example is feeling "this is me, that is you." That is already a fundamental inversion, but we can't help it! In concentration, you can cultivate to the point of being free from conceptual elaboration and have the wisdom of emptiness. In concentration, it's like: "I know there is no self, I am unreal, fundamentally and originally there is no I, so even 'no-self' is superfluous." You know this very clearly in concentration, but upon exiting concentration? It's gone again! Why? The skill of meditative concentration has not yet merged with "Action" (practice and vow) in actual daily life.
Annotations (for Segment 73):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 74: Section 拾 , Paragraph 11)
所以,第叁个是一味,定跟慧都不分了,两个合而为一,『你、我』『能、所』合一了,没有二元的境界叫 One Taste ,一味。就是没有你我,没有能所!我们都是有能所、有对立呀! 我看到什么、我听到什么,这是能所的对立的境界。你在修定、禅修念佛的时候,能亲証到一味;显教就叫定慧等持;等于说是你『能所』都消失了,在一元境界,没有在二元戏论裡头。然后『无修』。那出定了做人做事,你已经『幻身成就』,秘密在这裡了!为什么你能够在日常生活裡,出定入定一样呢?因为你幻身成就了!你 Illusory Body 修成功,在心轮那裡有,假如我修到,我一看,就知道你修有了;如果我没有修成功这个,就是你幻身在心轮裡头,我也看不出来。因为,外表跟他还没有成就以前完全一样,没有差别! No difference at all !并不是说,你幻身成就了,你外表就红光满面,或肤色有什么变化。塬来廋廋的、小小的,黄色皮肤,就是那个样子。但是,他已经幻身成就在心轮裡头。但是,要你真正自己成就的人才看得到!他的心已经变成 Pure Perception ,净幻身。他的心从『他的幻身的心』这里出现、这裡用,所以出定、入定一样!8不是说:「你出定、入定都一样保持那个境界。」。这是最大的秘密,最高级的「幻身成就」的教授。
English Translation (Segment 74):
Therefore, the third is one taste. Concentration and wisdom are no longer separate; the two merge into one. 'You and I,' 'subject and object,' merge into one. The non-dual state is called "One Taste," one taste. It means there is no you and I, no subject and object! We are always in a state of subject and object, of opposition! "I see something," "I hear something"—this is the oppositional state of subject and object. When you are cultivating concentration, meditating, or practicing mindfulness of the Buddha, you can directly realize one taste; in the exoteric schools this is called concentration and wisdom held in equal balance. This is to say that your 'subject and object' have both disappeared, you are in a non-dual state, no longer in the dualistic conceptual proliferation. Then, 'no-meditation.'¹ Now, when you exit concentration to live your life and handle affairs, you have already 'attained the illusory body.' The secret is right here! Why are you able to be the same in daily life as you are in concentration? Because you have attained the illusory body! You have successfully cultivated the "Illusory Body," it is there in the heart cakra. If I had cultivated it, I could take one look and know that you have cultivated it. If I have not successfully cultivated this, then even if your illusory body is in your heart cakra, I cannot see it either. Externally, the person looks exactly the same as before attainment; there is no difference! "No difference at all!" It's not to say that after you attain the illusory body, your face will be glowing red or there will be some change in your skin color. If you were originally thin, small, with yellow skin, you will still look that way. But he has already attained the illusory body within his heart cakra. However, only someone who has truly attained it can see it! His mind has already become "Pure Perception," the pure illusory body. His mind emerges from here, from 'the mind of his illusory body,' and functions from here, which is why exiting and entering concentration are the same! It is not a matter of "maintaining that state equally whether in or out of concentration." This is the greatest secret, the most advanced teaching on the 'attainment of the illusory body.'
Annotations (for Segment 74):
Interleaved Original Text, English Translation, and Annotations
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 75: Section 拾壹 , Paragraph 1)
拾壹、大手印的秘密 最后,我再报告为什么我们心的自性、心的本体不容易看。根本净光,就是我们的心的本地风光,也就是心的源头,为什么我们不容易看到?第一个塬因:真正的、我们的佛心 Too close ,太近了。我们要看纸上的字,太近,你能够读吗?太接近我们了!生下来到现在,那一个人自己看到自己的脸?因为太近了嘛,所以看不见!这个 RIGPA ,是因为这个道理,我们不容易认到它。太近了!每天用的是它,就像自己没办法看到自己的脸一样的,不容易认到,这是第一个塬因。
English Translation (Segment 75):
Section XI: The Secret of Mahāmudrā
Finally, I will report on why the self-nature of our mind, the fundamental essence of the mind, is not easy to see. The fundamental clear light is the original ground and scenery of our mind, which is the source of the mind. Why is it not easy for us to see? The first reason: our true Buddha-mind is "Too close"—too near. When we want to read the words on a piece of paper, if it's too close, can you read it? It is too close to us! From birth until now, which person has ever seen their own face? Because it is too close, you cannot see it! This RIGPA—it is for this reason that we do not easily recognize it. It's too close! We use it every day, just like being unable to see one's own face; it is not easy to recognize. This is the first reason.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 76: Section 拾壹 , Paragraph 2)
The second reason: This RIGPA can manifest many phenomena for you to experience. Everything we now see and hear is its experience. This "Experience" is too profound, unfathomably deep! It's like when we are at the seashore looking at the great ocean; if you want to know how deep the sea is, can you measure it? It's impossible to measure! It is the same with our mind; that which allows us to experience is unfathomably deep. Therefore, we fundamentally have no way to understand this RIGPA!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 77: Section 拾壹 , Paragraph 3)
最后,密宗明心见性,就是禅宗的顿悟法门。「直指人心,见性成佛」那一下子,在密宗的修法,叫做『大手印』教授,直接看到你心的塬来面目。这一种指导, Instruction ,我们叫 MAHAMUDRA ,大手印。大手印太简单了, Too easy !因为太简单,所以你就没有办法认到它! Too easy !你问问那真正的大修行人,像宗萨仁波切等,因为丁果仁波切、敦珠法王都走了。问他们真正亲証到『心的本体』、『心自性』,禅宗讲的本地风光的人,『那么简单,你怎么不会呀?』。 Too easy 的关係,我们没有办法做,这有一点怪怪的呢!
English Translation (Segment 77):
Finally, in the esoteric schools, "realizing the mind and seeing one's nature" is the Chan school's method of sudden awakening. That moment of "directly pointing to the human mind, seeing one's nature and becoming a Buddha"—in the practice methods of the esoteric schools, this is called the 'Mahāmudrā' teaching, to directly see the original face of your mind. This kind of guidance, this "Instruction," we call MAHAMUDRA, the Great Seal. Mahāmudrā is too simple, "Too easy"! Because it is too simple, you have no way to recognize it! "Too easy!" If you ask those truly great practitioners, like Dzongsar Rinpoche and others—because Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche and Dudjom Rinpoche have already passed away—ask those people who have truly and directly realized the 'fundamental essence of the mind,' the 'self-nature of the mind,' what the Chan school calls the original ground and scenery, they would say, 'It's so simple, how can you not get it?' Because it is "Too easy," we are unable to do it. This is a bit strange, isn't it!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 78: Section 拾壹 , Paragraph 4)
第叁个是:成佛的境界太神妙、太美妙。我们的思想,好像很窄的一条沟,大海的水,要从这么小的沟里,一下流过去,能吗?一样的!佛的境界的美妙、神妙,不是我们人这么小小的脑:妄想一大堆的二元境界裡滚的那一种思想能够知道它的。这叫做 Inlightmence too excellent ,太神妙、太神奇!你看这多怪,第一个是太近 Too close ,第二个是佛心的经验;实际上,我们所有的经验,都是心、心本体的经验。我举一个例子,这里有银幕,你要映什么电影,它都可以做,拿什么片子来,它就给你做,是不是?心就是银幕一样,它所有经验都没有问题,你来做什么,我就现出什么给你。一样呀!这佛心的经验!这个味道有一点不对,也只能这样讲。实在难讲这个境界。
English Translation (Segment 78):
The third is: the state of attaining Buddhahood is too wondrous, too marvelous. Our thinking is like a very narrow ditch. Can the water of the great ocean flow through such a small ditch all at once? It can't! It's the same! The marvel and wonder of the Buddha's state is not something that can be known by our tiny human brains, by the kind of thought that rolls around in a dualistic state full of delusions. This is called "Enlightenment is too excellent," too wondrous, too miraculous! See how strange this is? The first is that it is too near, "Too close." The second is the experience of the Buddha-mind; actually, all of our experiences are experiences of the mind, of the mind's fundamental essence. Let me give an example. Here is a screen: whatever movie you want to project, it can show it. Whatever film you bring, it will project it for you, right? The mind is like that screen; whatever the experience, there is no problem. Whatever you bring, it manifests accordingly. It's the same! This experience of the Buddha-mind! The flavor of this analogy is a little off, but this is the only way to put it. It is truly difficult to speak of this state.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 79: Section 拾壹 , Paragraph 5)
The mind itself is like a screen; whatever film you bring to project, I will faithfully project it for you—all of it, our experiences of present, past, and future time, our experiences of space. To get to the West Coast of the United States, you have to take a jet for over ten hours. So far away! That feeling of distance, the length of this distance—the mind has not moved, there is no time! When you feel, 'Oh! It's been so long and we're still not there!', that is the mind functioning, and only then is there the concept of time. To walk from here to Professor Hou's place, it takes one, two, three steps to arrive. It seems like the length can be measured, we believe that distance is a real thing. But if your mind doesn't move, is there any distance? When you think, "I can get there in three steps," it is only when that thought of the mind arises that distance exists! Everything is the mind itself; the ability to experience is the mind itself! It is too unfathomably profound.
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 80: Section 拾壹 , Paragraph 6)
第叁个呢?大手印、顿悟的法门,太容易了!真正亲証到心的本体的修行者说:『哎呀,这么简单,你怎么不会!』。太过简单,所以大家不会。为什么简单?他说:『只要你,不要东想西想,妄想都不要,轻轻的把你的心安放在它的本来的、塬来的面目上就对了。』但是,我们就不敢放呀,也不会放呀!叫你放,就:『安呢耶塞麦?』 ( 这样可以吗? ) 。那个,就是你的妄想!放了,「对吗?」,又是你又随便来了,又头上安头了!「耶,这样吗?」「嗯?不对、不对」「这样就对了」「耶、这个也是不对!」。就是 lightly( 很轻轻的 ) rest in your nature of Mind !轻轻的把你的心,放在本来的、它那个安祥的、本来的、明明觉觉的,它的本位上就对了!做得到的人说:「这么简单,怎么不会呢?」。 Too Easy, MahaMudra !顿悟,就是那么简单!
English Translation (Segment 80):
The third one? Mahāmudrā, the method of sudden awakening, is too easy! Practitioners who have truly and directly realized the fundamental essence of the mind say: 'Oh, it's so simple, how can you not get it!' It is too simple, so people do not know how to do it. Why is it simple? He says: 'All you have to do is not think about this and that; have no deluded thoughts at all. Just lightly rest your mind on its original face, and that's it.' But we don't dare to let it rest, and we don't know how! You're told to let it rest, and you think: 'Can it be like this?'¹ (Taiwanese). That is your delusion! You let it rest, and then, "Is this right?"—there you go again, randomly adding a head on top of a head!² "Huh, is it like this?" "Hmm? No, no, that's not right." "This way is right." "Huh, this is also not right!" It is just to "lightly rest in your nature of Mind!" Just lightly place your mind in its own peaceful, original, clearly knowing state, and that is all. Those who can do it say: "It's so simple, how can you not get it?" "Too Easy, Mahāmudrā!" Sudden awakening is just that simple!
Annotations (for Segment 80):
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 81: Section 拾壹 , Paragraph 7)
But, after awakening, you must begin to practice! If you do not practice after awakening, the moment you get up, there is nothing, it is lost again! In our daily lives, it's not necessarily only in seated meditation that we can see that fundamental clear light. For instance, when we blow our nose—“KNG—”—at that moment, you see the mucus, "Oh, there's a lot, it's yellow"—once you want to check what color it is, that moment is already gone. That “KNG—,” that one instant, it flashed and passed. The intention to blow your nose is not it. It's while you are doing it, "HNNNG"—no thought whatsoever, empty! That one instant, that was a flash, and you don't even recognize it. You finish running a hundred meters, "HAH, HAH, HAH" (panting like an ox), no thought whatsoever. Then, "Oh! I'm tired!"—that's not it anymore! "It's confusion, discursive consciousness." You are again in the midst of confused, inverted consciousness. "Oh! So tired!" "Discursive Consciousness," you are already in the ordinary state of a deluded being in saṃsāra. But in the instant after finishing the run, that "HAH, HAH, HAH," it flashed and passed. Then, “Oh my! This is terrible!”—ah, ah, here it comes again; it is the ordinary saṃsāric state again!
Original Text (Chinese - Segment 82: Concluding Remarks)
所以,大手印 too easy ,我们没有自信,都是怀疑『这个对吗?』『难道这么简单吗?』,这个又丢了!又掉了!就这么一回事。第四个是:如果你能够善护念,能够把这个境界 Developed , Stabilized ,稳定化,并把它扩张的话,太美妙、太美妙,所有的神通变化,都从心的本体的这个,它本身具有,何其自性本自具足!我们就用这一句话,做今天的结语,谢谢各位! 我所讲的这个,是大家『心』的经验, ( 大众鼓掌 ) 。听到声音的时候,大家都说『耶!很多人拍手的声音。』,声音都是拍手的声音,这个念头去不掉,都有这个经验。「喔!这是大家拍手的声音」「哎!这是你讲得好!」,这个就是执着,就是轮迴的动因。根本没有这个东西耶!显现出来这个声音,是佛的法身的那个 Wonderful Mind , Nature Mind 它 Manifestation ,它的一个 Sambhgakaya ,报身境界,就是声音耶!那我们就不是、就抓了!我们不但对声音这样,对自己的相,抓得更紧!我漂亮、我是女的,我的头髮怎么样。睡觉的时候,你都知道你烫成什么头髮!身相拿不掉,你怎么能够成佛呢?相都执着了,还说要把我执拿掉,那是不可能的!为了要去掉身相,所以我们要修『生起次第』嘛!把自己观成释迦牟尼、观世音菩萨,或把自己观成阿弥陀佛,生起次第,是不是?就是为了要去掉我们对身相的执着。
English Translation (Segment 82):
So, Mahāmudrā is "too easy," and we lack confidence; we are always doubting, "Is this right?" "Could it really be this simple?" And so it's lost again! Dropped again! That's all it is. The fourth is: if you can guard it well and keep it in mind, develop and stabilize this state, and expand it, it is too marvelous, too marvelous. All of the supernormal powers and transformations come from this fundamental essence of the mind. It possesses them inherently. "Who would have thought that self-nature is inherently complete!"¹ We will use this sentence as today's conclusion. Thank you, everyone! What I have been talking about is everyone's experience of the 'mind.' (Audience applauds.) When you hear the sound, everyone says, "Hey! The sound of many people clapping." The sound is the sound of clapping; this thought cannot be removed, everyone has this experience. "Oh! This is the sound of everyone clapping." "Hey! This is because you spoke well!" This is clinging; this is what drives saṃsāra. This thing fundamentally doesn't exist! This manifested sound is that “Wonderful Mind” of the Buddha’s Dharmakāya, a “Manifestation” of the “Nature Mind”; it is one of its Saṃbhogakāya expressions—the enjoyment-body realm here is sound itself! But we don't see it that way; we grasp!² Not only do we do this with sound, we grasp our own appearance even more tightly! "I’m beautiful, I’m a woman—how about my hair?" Even when you're sleeping, you know what kind of hairstyle you have! If you cannot let go of the appearance of the body, how can you attain Buddhahood? You are clinging to appearances, yet you talk about getting rid of self-grasping? That's impossible! In order to eliminate the appearance of the body, we must practice the 'generation stage,' right? To visualize ourselves as Śākyamuni, as Guanyin Bodhisattva, or to visualize ourselves as Amitābha Buddha—the generation stage, isn't that it? It is precisely for the purpose of eliminating our clinging to the appearance of the body.
Annotations (for Segment 82):
Translator's Commentary
Introduction
This text is a transcript of a public lecture by Dr. Hong Wenliang, a medical doctor, titled "Why Spiritual Practice is Not Easy to Get Started On." The style is colloquial, conversational, and aimed at a lay audience of Buddhist practitioners who feel they are "not getting anywhere." The lecture is notable for its syncretic approach, seamlessly blending core concepts from early Buddhism (the Four Noble Truths), Mahāyāna (Emptiness, Yogācāra), Chan/Zen (original ground and scenery, sudden awakening), and advanced Vajrayāna (completion-stage sequences, clear light, illusory body, Mahāmudrā). The speaker's primary goal is practical: to diagnose common pitfalls—from pride and wrong views to subtle errors in advanced meditation—and to reorient the practitioner towards a direct, experiential understanding ( 亲证 , direct realization) over theoretical knowledge.
Translation Choices for Key Terminology
The translation uses the following terminology consistently:
无自性 (wú zìxìng) was consistently translated as "without self-nature."
一合相 / 合相 (yī hé xiàng / héxiàng) was rendered as “one aggregated appearance,” referring to the five aggregates taken together as a seemingly unitary self.
空 (kōng) was translated as "emptiness," but the speaker's specific, positive framing of it as "limitless potential" was faithfully rendered in the translation.
相 (xiàng) was rendered contextually: as "appearance" in general phenomenal contexts (e.g., 色相, appearance of color), as "perception" in psychological contexts (我相, perception of a self), and as “without characteristics/appearance” for 无相 (wúxiàng) in the context of intangible thought.
A crucial distinction in the text is between the true mind ( 真心 , RIGPA) and the ordinary mind ( 攀缘心 , SEM). I translated 攀缘心 (pānyuán xīn), literally "climbing-on-conditions mind," as "grasping mind" or "clinging mind" to convey its dualistic function of grasping at objects.
乐、明、无念 (lè, míng, wúniàn), the three meditative experiences, were translated as "bliss, clarity, and non-conceptuality/non-thought," reflecting their standard meaning as pitfalls when clung to.
幻身 (huànshēn) was translated as “illusory body,” which the lecture presents as a completion-stage meditative accomplishment.
Contextual and Doctrinal Explanations
The Teapot Analogy: The lecture's foundation is Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche's analogy of the three faults of a teapot (upside-down/unreceptive, leaky/forgetful, poisoned/wrong views). This provides a simple, memorable framework for the common obstacles to learning.
The Two Minds (SEM vs. RIGPA): The core of the talk is the distinction between the ordinary, deluded, "grasping mind" ( 攀缘心 , SEM) and the "true mind" ( 真心 , RIGPA). The speaker argues that the fundamental error of practice is mistaking SEM for RIGPA, like a family raising a swapped child as their own. All of dualism, the self-view ( 我见 ), and the emotional afflictions arise from this initial misidentification.
Progression of Views: The speaker presents a three-vehicle progression of Buddhist teaching. Hīnayāna sees phenomena as real but impermanent. Mahāyāna sees them as illusory and empty ( 空无自性 ). The highest teaching, Vajrayāna, sees all phenomena as the sacred manifestation of the Dharmakāya—a "pure perception." This hierarchy is used to explain why certain teachings are introduced only after a student has a firm foundation.
Vajrayāna Concepts: The lecture introduces advanced concepts from the esoteric schools in an accessible manner. The “Son Clear Light” encountered in meditation is presented in relation to the fundamental clear light that appears at death; repeated familiarization is linked in the lecture to attainment of the “illusory body” (幻身).
Mahāmudrā: The final section on Mahāmudrā ("The Great Seal") emphasizes that the ultimate realization is "too easy," "too close," and "too profound" for the conceptual mind to grasp, and that it is our own doubt and conceptual overlay that obscure it.
Ambiguities and Challenges
The primary challenge was translating a spoken lecture into fluid, readable English while preserving its informal, didactic, and sometimes repetitive style. The speaker frequently uses English words ("Mind," "Distortion," "Shock," "Clarity") which were retained to reflect the original flavor. Colloquial Taiwanese Hokkien phrases ( 安呢耶塞麦? , 阿有法度! ) were translated and annotated to convey their meaning and the talk's specific cultural context. The structure could be rambling, and I chose to smooth the flow slightly for clarity without altering the sequence or content of the arguments.
Structural and Stylistic Choices
The translation sought to maintain the tone of a live lecture. Rhetorical questions, direct addresses to the audience ("Everyone," "Professor Lin?"), and moments of emphasis ("Ha!", "Wrong!") were preserved. Paragraph breaks were aligned with the logical shifts in the speaker's monologue. The goal was to create a text that reads not as a dense philosophical treatise, but as an engaging and direct teaching from a knowledgeable practitioner to his peers.
Did you go through I AM before?
It is a good breakthrough. Your insight is more on second stanza. Both stanzas must be thorough.
You may want to reread:
https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/2009/03/on-anatta-emptiness-and-spontaneous.html
And
https://www.awakeningtoreality.com/2021/06/pellucid-no-self-non-doership.html